Main Menu

Poison Mines

Started by Westfall, April 04, 2008, 03:28:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Should Poison Mines stay or be removed in PS

Poison Mines should stay
23 (82.1%)
Poison Mines should be removed
3 (10.7%)
More discussion needs to take place before it can be determined
2 (7.1%)

Total Members Voted: 27

Voting closed: April 18, 2008, 03:28:14 AM

Farley4Fan

Quote from: Cyntrox on April 17, 2008, 08:18:03 PM
Digital-Maniac: How does that contribute to the gameplay, balance and/or depth of the game? Why should the merc be punished for putting the mine far away from where he wants it to hit?

Those ranges are way too small I must say.  10 feet away for minimum dosage?  That would be pretty weak.  How about 20+ feet?  Who the hell ever gets poisoned from a foot away? lmao (maybe agent)... XD  It would contribute to the gameplay (with ranges much larger than that) because it gives mercs more choice where to put their mines.  If you want to guard a door with a poison mine all you have to do is plant it so that the laser isn't 20 ft away from the entrance.   :D  It's not punishment, it's a definite plus.  Hell you can even semi-guard multiple doors at once with a unlimited ranged poison.  Well, maybe a 125 foot (estimately) ranged poison would be a little more plausible and balanced.

Digital-Maniac

yea my numbers were off but mainly laid out to set an example. 

Guys when I say the screen should be blurred I mean something like this...



Thats from some Wii game called "The Conduit"; I just saw it today but I think an effect similar to this would be good... I strongly feel this could work but its not up to me is it?
It doesnt immedietly fill up your screen but the lower your health gets the more distorted it becomes

Farley4Fan

I like it.  The reddish color may scare off people who don't want blood.  :P

It's a good boost to poison.  Especially if you plant a proxy nearby a poison.  Then when their screen becomes blurred they panic and can't see the proxy mines, thus they run into them.  Nice effect.  I can't see why something like this couldn't/shouldn't be implemented.

Digital-Maniac

This is what I was saying in the "Symptoms" thread however it never got across to some.

I really do like the way this Wii game makes it look though I'm sure with the Horsepower of the unreal engine something very nice could be done.  I was thinking more of a blur  effect or a wave effect covering the edges of the screen the same way the veins come in on the image shown...  Like if the spy was having trouble with his vision, maybe the poison is making his eyes burn.

One other thing, I think when the spy dies he shouldnt just fall and die.  LoL Imagine if the spy had a seizure?  or if he vomits?  that would rock :o

Farley4Fan

Instead of all the veins and stuff, a reddish blur on the screen's edges that gets closer to the center the longer you are poisoned would be a nice touch.

Westfall

Quote from: Papa Skull on April 19, 2008, 07:45:20 AM
Instead of all the veins and stuff, a reddish blur on the screen's edges that gets closer to the center the longer you are poisoned would be a nice touch.

y not green?

InvisibleMan999

Quote from: Rambo on April 17, 2008, 12:29:56 PM
best laser mine spots i've come to know are behind non-transparent automatic doors and in combination with prox. mines so that you can't jump over it.

Very weak mine IMO if you have to always use it in combination with another mine.

Also I find using a prox kind of defeats the whole purpose of laser, which has the advantage of being silent.

Really if you think that lasers only work when used in tandem with another mine, that's probably a good enough reason to upgrade them.

Farley4Fan

Quote from: Westfall-US on April 19, 2008, 04:56:49 PM
Quote from: Papa Skull on April 19, 2008, 07:45:20 AM
Instead of all the veins and stuff, a reddish blur on the screen's edges that gets closer to the center the longer you are poisoned would be a nice touch.

y not green?

Because it would be harder to see a bleeping red proxy mine/solid laser mine.  Green would be fine, doesn't really matter to me.  ;D  But red would seem like it would make people panic more, red is a death color.

Farley4Fan

Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on April 19, 2008, 06:27:28 PM
Quote from: Rambo on April 17, 2008, 12:29:56 PM
best laser mine spots i've come to know are behind non-transparent automatic doors and in combination with prox. mines so that you can't jump over it.

Very weak mine IMO if you have to always use it in combination with another mine.

Also I find using a prox kind of defeats the whole purpose of laser, which has the advantage of being silent.

Really if you think that lasers only work when used in tandem with another mine, that's probably a good enough reason to upgrade them.

I agree.  But just because 1 guy thinks that's the best use for them doesn't mean it's the best way. 

Gawain

laser/poison+proxy combo pwns on museum mono corridor because you can't sneak past. it's obvious anyways that there are mines in that place, so the noise doesn't matter. i don't use laser a lot, but besides behind automatic doors, that's one of the few really good places.

Farley4Fan

Yup ^

But they should have a bit more use than being coupled with a different mine.  With a reddish blur on the outside of the screen it could make placing proxies near poisons (but on the way to a medikit) an even better tactic than before...

Gawain

you wanna boost poison mines by making them kill better, but what they really need is a bigger separation from spy traps and a less visible laser.

Farley4Fan

They need both.  But killing time doesn't matter when map design plays a bigger part.

InvisibleMan999

I honestly don't think poisons are that bad mechanically right now. There are a few poorly deisgned maps, that put medpacks near objectives, but for the most part, poisons work fairly well. They generally give you the choice between hacking and dying, or giving yourwself away and surviving.

Westfall

Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on April 20, 2008, 09:30:36 AM
I honestly don't think poisons are that bad mechanically right now. There are a few poorly deisgned maps, that put medpacks near objectives, but for the most part, poisons work fairly well. They generally give you the choice between hacking and dying, or giving yourwself away and surviving.

or taking the hit cuz your mate was there to heal you.