FPS camera position analysis

Started by Serg, October 30, 2010, 11:52:24 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Serg

I just wanted to make some analysis in fps camera position in modern games
So here is what I've got so far:
If you split the screen in 4 equal parts and you take the right-bottom rectangle, then you can see that most of the modern games are trying to have the arm and gun within it. So there are a few games which put it in other way. Also the arm with the gun almost always has the same angle.
analysis 1

Sometimes the surface of the the arm with the gun fills almost the whole rectangle, but usually it doesn't
analysis 2

this is how we have positioned our camera so far:
fps cam now

DreadStunLock

I think the second one looks way more realistic, and definitely more comfortable. I don't really like it when it's too angled, you can almost see the whole side of the gun.

Serg

Quote from: DreadStunLock on October 30, 2010, 12:35:53 PM
I think the second one looks way more realistic, and definitely more comfortable. I don't really like it when it's too angled, you can almost see the whole side of the gun.

which number? (if you look from left to right and top to down
1 2 3
4 5 6
7 8 9
...)

DreadStunLock

Number 3 Looks the most in a straight line. The others look a bit too angled. 3rd one also doesn't take too much FOV, But still the PS one looks the best in my personal opinion. Why? Well I always liked to be able to see the back view of the gun and manage to sometimes see the detail on the scope lense.

VaNilla

Analysis 1, number 4 is my favourite. Play CS alot and it's easily my preferred layout.

Serg

Personally i don't like CounterStrike style, i think it's too exaggerated

VaNilla

It doesn't look the best, but for me it feels the best gameplay wise.

Farley4Fan

My vote goes to either number 4 or number 9.

unskilled

I love 8.
But it will works only with great animations :)

Serg

Quote from: KnoogeR on October 30, 2010, 07:47:09 PM
I love 8.
But it will works only with great animations :)
i think our animations will be great

DreadStunLock

Quote from: KnoogeR on October 30, 2010, 07:47:09 PM
I love 8.
But it will works only with great animations :)

You mean walking animations and the gun shaking animations right? (He just finished Crysis Warhead Oo)

unskilled

#11
Yea walking and guns shaking animations... in crysis they are pretty good. I hope in PS I will have the same feelings :P

Farley4Fan

who's up for some crysis wars (thread hijack)


Spark Mandriller

That scope is still way too big. Angle's okay though.

tigaer

Quote from: B-3A Misty Lady on October 30, 2010, 10:21:06 PM
That scope is still way too big. Angle's okay though.

Use a shotgun then. :-[