Main Menu

Tazer

Started by Spekkio, October 29, 2007, 02:04:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Spekkio

Chaff affecting tazer defeats the purpose of the gadget almost entirely.

Westfall

Quote from: Spekkio on October 30, 2007, 11:20:36 PM
Chaff affecting tazer defeats the purpose of the gadget almost entirely.

Understandably so, but thats what a chaff grenade does: cuts out all electrical circuits. So it is kind of idiotic to have tazer unaffected by chaff when it is an electric device. In fact, its hypocritical in a defined sense.

Spekkio

Huh? How is the chaff saying one thing and doing another? Last I checked, a chaff grenade couldn't talk.

Game balance > realism.

AgentX_003

Quote from: Spekkio on October 30, 2007, 11:51:08 PM
Huh? How is the chaff saying one thing and doing another? Last I checked, a chaff grenade couldn't talk.

Game balance > realism.


Spekkio usually id agree with your diplomatic points but in this case , I stand correct your an idiot =/. it is balanced.. because once the chaff wears off the merc can use it again


-Thanks Murdy for da Sig <3  xD

seefoo.

make taser steam operated and problem solved!

btw wtf is up with your sig, rofl @ it.

Westfall

Quote from: Spekkio on October 30, 2007, 11:51:08 PM
Huh? How is the chaff saying one thing and doing another? Last I checked, a chaff grenade couldn't talk.

Game balance > realism.

Last I checked, chaff grenade was supposed to cut off all electrical devices. Last I checked, tazer was an electrical device. Therefore, the last time I checked, chaff grenade should cut off electrically-charged tazer.

Last time I checked, it was common sense.

This is game balance. Tazer is useful, if it isn't chaffed. I don't see how this is terribly imbalanced when: a merc can easily charge out of a chaff radius; Not everyone who plays spy carries chaff grenade; or any gun the merc has is ridiculously overpowering to the spy.

The tazer is just a helpful hand against aggressive spies.  Kind of like people use the uzi (or shotgun)/charge/tazer combination.

As far as I'm concerned, the tazer needed only this real adjustment. Unless you want to continuously deal with the bunny-hopping, 1-sec rechargeable tazer.

This is not just a realistic adjustment, its a common sense adjustment.

DrKennethNoisewater

or

take it out

and replace it with a squirt gun that would temporarily diffuse the spies visions...

right...


Spekkio

#37
QuoteLast I checked, chaff grenade was supposed to cut off all electrical devices. Last I checked, tazer was an electrical device. Therefore, the last time I checked, chaff grenade should cut off electrically-charged tazer.

Last time I checked, it was common sense.
Quite being both an idiot and a douchebag.

First of all, all that stuff still doesn't make chaff a hypocrite. Secondly, almost everything the spy uses is electronic, but they can still use their equipment in the chaff radius, and the merc can still use both the flashlight and the laser. Why? Because game balance is more important than realism. That is simply common sense.

You already have distorted vision, cannot snipe, and cannot reload in a chaff radius. The tazer does not need to be added to the list of things that don't work. Moreover, the tazer is intended to allow you to fend off aggro spies more easily. If chaff affects it, then that gimps that particular use significantly.

Gawain

chaff should NOT affect tazer/laser/flashlight in any way.
we simply have to find a balanced tazer range (~charge distance/pt distance), hit box size and cooldown timer. there should be a little aiming involved so that flash keeps it's aggro capabilities but with a cooldown between 5s and 10s a hit must be quite likely. it must also be possible to taze after charge/berserk.

Westfall

QuoteQuite being both an idiot and a douchebag.

I don't mean to sound like a douchebag. I wanted to actually edit that in to say I didn't mean to ruffle your feathers. And I'm clearly not being an idiot when it comes to common sense.

QuoteHuh? How is the chaff saying one thing and doing another? Last I checked, a chaff grenade couldn't talk.

Realize you were being an asshole first, so why would I just sit back and let you treat me as such.

But...

QuoteBecause game balance is more important than realism.

Tazer being chaffed is game balance. You have bullcharge+berserk in times of chaff an I already gave examples of getting away from it as well (you can fuckin escape the radius of chaff). ALL of those things you mentioned should be affected by a chaff grenade.

I'm sorry, but on this topic you are wrong Spekkio. This is too blatantly obvious here. I agree with you on practically everything else, but this isn't even close. It is neither balanced nor common sense to have chaff do nothing to the tazer/flashlight. And yes, all that "stuff" does make chaff a hypocrite in the games. Don't like it? Then come up with an idea of a "chaff minus tazer and flashlight" grenade. How intelligent and high tech that sounds.

I really don't want to repeat myself anymore. Can you pay attention to the fact that the "stuff" I stated below is actually all true and that there are so many methods around chaff grenade. Tazer is just going to be another imbalanced piece of shit if the devs don't let the chaff work on it.

In fact, what do the devs think on this?

SITHDUKE

#40
I'd agree Westfall if all aggro spies didn't take triple nade. Shock, smoke, chaff, flash. Now you'll be blind, getting elbowed which if they're host will almost definatly mean you're necked before the first flash even wears off. If the spies are smart one of them will stand in your way so you'll charge straight into him and straight into a neck. Even while blind the taser is useful because you listenfor the elbow sound then fire it as soon as you hear it, because obviously the attacking spy is infront of you now after the elbow.

Believe me I'm a fan of everything having a counter. But the way SCCT works the aggro spy has at least 3 counters at his disposal which is a bit too much. If spies could take only one gadget then yeah, you can spam chaff to make his taser useless because chaff alone isnt enough to get his neck usually.

It would be like

Flash > Normal vision plus disorients them to aggro or escape but countered by vision modes
Smoke > disorients them to aggro or escape but countered by gas mask
Chaff > Taser + Visions but...we have no counter. See what I mean?

Overstatement

#41
Quote from: Westfall-US on October 31, 2007, 06:48:13 PM
You have bullcharge+berserk in times of chaff

Isn't that like saying "you can shoot the spy, why would you need nades/mines?"? Tazer is anti-aggro, if it disables against chaff, it pretty much disables against all aggro (and more) which makes it pretty useless. Escaping from chaff, you'll probably end up in another chaff cloud. That's how aggro works.

I vote for keeping it the way it is and fix the lag on it.

frvge

I see good points at both sides.
I think I am neutral.
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

B1nArY_001

If all it requires is a few changes in code to make the Tazer operate off of a battery that recharges like a spy tazer, or make it have a cool down etc. It would be best to just keep the ideas in mind and try them out. No real way to know what will work best by just theorizing.

Westfall

Quote from: B1nArY_001 on October 31, 2007, 09:33:49 PM
If all it requires is a few changes in code to make the Tazer operate off of a battery that recharges like a spy tazer, or make it have a cool down etc. It would be best to just keep the ideas in mind and try them out. No real way to know what will work best by just theorizing.

Especially because everyone's point above comes from SCCT, when this is going to be Project Stealth.

Does anyone even notice the decline in aggressive spies? I have , seeing as how CT is getting quite old now. New tactics are necessary and the way people handle their merc round now is fierce. I don't even see many instances where people take triple nades anymore, and really, who here can't counter that?

QuoteEscaping from chaff, you'll probably end up in another chaff cloud. That's how aggro works.

9 times out of 10 here you are incorrect sir. And thats not how aggro works. The point is to get the merc to charge into a wall or hit your mate so you can grab the merc before his animation of slapping the spy or running into the wall is up. Thats how aggro works.