Main Menu

Tazer

Started by Spekkio, October 29, 2007, 02:04:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

neth

Quote from: Gawain on November 06, 2007, 03:47:14 PM
talking about aim, i think SS on the head is totally overpowered, as it cuts off  sniping/visions/hud way longer than chaff (which takes a gadget slot) does. we should reduce the offline time of ss headshot and increase the chaff timer (chaff hopefully get's the not-working-through-walls-nerf, so this would be a good compensation).

Shooting head - skill
throwing chaff - skill ?

Gawain

throwing chaff in the right situations: brain.
ss headshots every time: aim.
brain > aim imo; at least while playing spy aim shouldn't be more important than tactics.

neth


Yeah, you need to have great intellect to know when to throw the chaff.

<ironic mode off>


Gawain

Quote from: neth on November 06, 2007, 05:09:38 PM
Yeah, you need to have great intellect to know when to throw the chaff.
<ironic mode off>
well, you can't afford to spam them vs good opponents as you got only 5, and you could need one to disable security/mines/traps later on. probably you are a mediocre player who uses chaff only for close combat aggro, but good players use it for far more. for example, you throw a chaff at the sniper position running away with the disc in orph to prevent sniping, you throw a chaff at the doorway if you are going for a camo neck, etc. by doing ss headshots, you safe chaff without any disadvantages. the most stupid thing is trying to ss headshot a sniping merc covering the objective next to you, eg factory main coop, lower machine etc. it's only the question who got the better aim, just like doing quickcams while the merc exactly knows your position. ditch this bullshit.
don't get me wrong, ss headshots should be rewarded; the current reward lasts just too long. 2-3s no hud etc would be better.

neth

The thing is that you not become skilled only because you use chaff in situations you listed. You use it, cause thats your tactics and it fits your play style. You use it, cause you predict that it may be beneficial for you in specific situation and thats not skill. You are skilled when you perform your actions smoothly, quickly, without mistakes and with the effect that would be impossible or hard to reach many times in the same conditions by an ordinary player -> Shooting head.


Example. You say that:

"good players use it (chaff) for far more. for example, you throw a chaff at the sniper position running away with the disc in orph to prevent sniping"

Ok, but it does not make them good. I can be a total noob and do the same thing any time you want me to do it.

Am I good or skilled because of it ? No...

Gawain

neth, you are a n00b. mastering the controls =! good player; quick adaption possible because of experience makes a good player. the examples i gave are two of several hundred different possibilities from which you have to choose again and again. good players don't pull off the same strategy all the time.
btw, the SS headshot influence time is 10s (!) after the usual ss effect, which makes 12s unability to sniper/use visions/see radar. anyone who thinks this is not overpowered is simply wrong.

neth

Dear Gawain,

Do you always insult ppl when you cant beat their arguments ?

Using chaff does not make you skilled, no matter in what situation you do it, cause it only shows that you have some tactics which include it's usage. -> you know when and where you will (or should) use it.

The effect of ss headshot must be better, because it requires SKILL.
Because I can see that you still dont understand me, ill explain it one more time basing on the example you gave:

"for example, you throw a chaff at the sniper position running away with the disc in orph to prevent sniping"

2 situations. We're great friends but youre very pro and im completely noob. Im playing the game and youre sitting next to me.
I run away with the disc in orph and while im lets say near the balcony you say:

1. "Hey, throw a chaff here, they wont be able to snipe you." I do so without problems.
         Am I skilled cause I did it ?    NO.     It only proves that I knew when to use it (in this case you told  me but that doesnt matter)

2. You say: "Hey, shoot his head, he wont be able to snipe you." Can I do it anytime ?    NO. 
    I cant do it, cause i dont have skill to instantly shoot his head.

Things like THIS make the difference if you are skilled or not. Throwing chaffs in situation you need it only proves that you've played the map before and that you found out that when it is the right time to throw your chaff. In this case its a matter of tactics (strategy) or play style. PERIOD
...

Waiting for more insults from Mr. I-Know-Im-Right-But-Cant-Prove-It.

Tidenburg

Quotemastering the controls =! good player;
Is =! the right form? I always though inequalities were != or am I just trying to stop the arguement by distracting you all? Who noes.

p.s. Yeah I did just spell noes that way.

Gawain

Dear neth,
ss headshot should have some advantage compared to ss on the body, but being unable to sniper, use special visions, see the ping reticule and the radar for 10s after being shocked is a quite huge period of time. with smoother mouse implementation you will see it happen way more often, even in large distances; 10 is clearly op, as you take away a lot of the merc's abilities with such a basic action like ss. i'd be ok with 4-5s.
you forget that the sniper rifle makes most kills firing at fleeing spies. you can do a little experiment: try how far you can run while the merc is tazed. it's a really huge distance. the merc is immune to ss for 12s after ss, so all he can do is running after you and spamming nades for 10s (slower than the spy), and 2s of sniping before you can pull off the same "skill" move again...
btw, it should be visible that you can't ss the merc; maybe the shock effect should stay that long (think i've read this idea before), but it would kinda ridiculous. any better ideas for an indicator?

Cyntrox

It could be a reduced effect... Like an occasional spark running over the merc.

frvge

Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

Succubus Dryad Of The Undying Comet

It  was mentioned before, though.

InvisibleMan999

As far as knowing when to use gadgets and how best to use them being "not a skill" is bullshit. They're just different kinds of skills: tactical skill and FPS skill.

The team that goes in carefully planting alarm snares and sticky cams, only to lure a merc into a carefully planned ambush is not less skilled than the team that rushes immediately and relies on sticky shocks to the head and quickcams to take out a merc on a direct rush. In fact, we probably want to reward the former more than the latter.

One thing that differentiates the game from most FPS is that CT had a lot of tactical skills required. It wasn't just run and gun like a standard FPS. The game tried to be about planning and strategy. In fact, if CT becomes too FPS skill intensive, then it really loses its basic feel, so it's something we constantly have to strike a balance with. There are dozens of FPS games out there if you're looking for a straight run and gun feel. What makes CT different is that it somewhat downplays those elements and tries to require strategy.


psyichic

There are still twitch skills required in the game. You need to act fast and developing good reaction times deserves some type of reward. Be it for the ambush cam, slap cam, grab, evasion, or headshot. Twitch skills are just as much part of the game as tactical skills are. The way it works now is just fine, if you can nail a merc with a headshot that you can't even confirm for yourself (Spies don't get that nice little feature of knowing when they make a headshot, they can guess but they can't know 100%) the way it works is just fine the way it is.

neth

Quote from: psyichic on November 07, 2007, 12:44:28 AM

(Spies don't get that nice little feature of knowing when they make a headshot, they can guess but they can't know 100%) the way it works is just fine the way it is.

exactly