... to implement our own features(new animations, new player skins...etc.)? For our private use ofc. Then we could post them on forum and say "I made a parachute and an animation of sky diving for it. If you like it you can implement it to PS". That wouldn't hurt anyone or...?
AKA: Modding? :P
Well modding is a little bit too much to say. jsut implementing small things into the code.
Doable? Maybe, depending on your technical knowledge. Supported/guaranteed? No.
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 05:40:35 PM
Doable? Maybe, depending on your technical knowledge. Supported/guaranteed? No.
ok let's put it other way, will it be open source after the release?
If we get asked by Epic Games for educational purposes of UDK, yes.
Generally (for now), no. But if you're interested in how we did a certain thing, you're free to ask.
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 05:48:58 PM
If we get asked by Epic Games for educational purposes of UDK, yes.
Generally (for now), no. But if you're interested in how we did a certain thing, you're free to ask.
not rly what I wished it to do frvge... I thought I was clear enough in first post... I mean why not? Is there any reasonable argument against it?
Yes. Same reason why [insert game X]'s source code is not open source.
And in our case also mostly because if you change the code and recompile, the projectstealth.u file differs from the others, and won't be able to connect (took 2 days to figure out why I couldn't connect to Morten, even with the same code). So if people compile their own stuff, they won't be able to play with others. And if people spread their own .u's, we get tens of PS versions and that's a pain in the ass to manage. Constantly swapping .u's is kinda annoying.
LoL. thats why I said for our private use... then we could show it on forum and give you a chance to implelement it IF YOU WANT. Anyway if you get your PS fucked up - whats the problem with reinstall? you won't loose saves(since its not single player) and you won't loose account (since its on net). So there is nothing hard to cope with...
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:18:52 PM
LoL. thats why I said for our private use... then we could show it on forum and give you a chance to implelement it IF YOU WANT. Anyway if you get your PS fucked up - whats the problem with reinstall? you won't loose saves(since its not single player) and you won't loose account (since its on net). So there is nothing hard to cope with...
Project Stealth game is their game, and I doubt they would want someone to be modding it and leaking it and saying "OMG I DIDN'T MEAN TO" + Why would you need to mod it and keep it for your own use? I doubt you will have fun playing alone on your own mod.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 06:26:19 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:18:52 PM
LoL. thats why I said for our private use... then we could show it on forum and give you a chance to implelement it IF YOU WANT. Anyway if you get your PS fucked up - whats the problem with reinstall? you won't loose saves(since its not single player) and you won't loose account (since its on net). So there is nothing hard to cope with...
Project Stealth game is their game, and I doubt they would want someone to be modding it and leaking it and saying "OMG I DIDN'T MEAN TO" + Why would you need to mod it and keep it for your own use? I doubt you will have fun playing alone on your own mod.
gosh you seem to have problems with getting me...
AN EXAMPLE:
You create a damn animation of spy licking his ass and it works properly whenever you launch it. You used kismet to achieve this beautiful thing and now you wish to put it in PS. You put it in YOUR PS and see that it works. You go to forum and say "HEY I MADE AN ANIMATION OF SPY LICKING HIS ASS. SEE THE ANIM ON YOUTUBE(Hyper link here). IT WORKS ON MY COMPUTER. HERE IS A LINK TO IT IF YOU'D LIKE TO TRY IT. I HAVE MADE A FULL INSTALL SYSTEM TO MAKE IT EASIER." - then the great devs could download and see if it works and if it doesnt show any issues and they like the anim they implement it to their official PS. Things taht are running amatuer around the internet are ofc made by amatuers but that is obvious. You wouldnt have to correct the amatuer things taht weren't confirmed by team and added to official PS. so WHAT'S the fuckin problem? ;)
And even if something screwed up on someones computer then REINSTALL and everything works correctly...
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:40:07 PM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 06:26:19 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:18:52 PM
LoL. thats why I said for our private use... then we could show it on forum and give you a chance to implelement it IF YOU WANT. Anyway if you get your PS fucked up - whats the problem with reinstall? you won't loose saves(since its not single player) and you won't loose account (since its on net). So there is nothing hard to cope with...
Project Stealth game is their game, and I doubt they would want someone to be modding it and leaking it and saying "OMG I DIDN'T MEAN TO" + Why would you need to mod it and keep it for your own use? I doubt you will have fun playing alone on your own mod.
gosh you seem to have problems with getting me...
AN EXAMPLE:
You create a damn animation of spy licking his ass and it works properly whenever you launch it. You used kismet to achieve this beautiful thing and now you wish to put it in PS. You put it in YOUR PS and see that it works. You go to forum and say "HEY I MADE AN ANIMATION OF SPY LICKING HIS ASS. SEE THE ANIM ON YOUTUBE(Hyper link here). IT WORKS ON MY COMPUTER. HERE IS A LINK TO IT IF YOU'D LIKE TO TRY IT. I HAVE MADE A FULL INSTALL SYSTEM TO MAKE IT EASIER." - then the great devs could download and see if it works and if it doesnt show any issues and they like the anim they implement it to their official PS. Things taht are running amatuer around the internet are ofc made by amatuers but that is obvious. You wouldnt have to correct the amatuer things taht weren't confirmed by team and added to official PS. so WHAT'S the fuckin problem? ;)
And even if something screwed up on someones computer then REINSTALL and everything works correctly...
Great Devs could download, that means other people can download too unless you keep it private, other than that it's public, so that means you are not using it "For your own benefit" right?
I'm not sure what the cooking system will do (if we decide to 'cook' our stuff), but AFAIK you can just load some anim files. So yes, you can probably animate stuff yourself. But getting it in-game requires more stuff.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 06:59:38 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:40:07 PM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 06:26:19 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 06:18:52 PM
LoL. thats why I said for our private use... then we could show it on forum and give you a chance to implelement it IF YOU WANT. Anyway if you get your PS fucked up - whats the problem with reinstall? you won't loose saves(since its not single player) and you won't loose account (since its on net). So there is nothing hard to cope with...
Project Stealth game is their game, and I doubt they would want someone to be modding it and leaking it and saying "OMG I DIDN'T MEAN TO" + Why would you need to mod it and keep it for your own use? I doubt you will have fun playing alone on your own mod.
gosh you seem to have problems with getting me...
AN EXAMPLE:
You create a damn animation of spy licking his ass and it works properly whenever you launch it. You used kismet to achieve this beautiful thing and now you wish to put it in PS. You put it in YOUR PS and see that it works. You go to forum and say "HEY I MADE AN ANIMATION OF SPY LICKING HIS ASS. SEE THE ANIM ON YOUTUBE(Hyper link here). IT WORKS ON MY COMPUTER. HERE IS A LINK TO IT IF YOU'D LIKE TO TRY IT. I HAVE MADE A FULL INSTALL SYSTEM TO MAKE IT EASIER." - then the great devs could download and see if it works and if it doesnt show any issues and they like the anim they implement it to their official PS. Things taht are running amatuer around the internet are ofc made by amatuers but that is obvious. You wouldnt have to correct the amatuer things taht weren't confirmed by team and added to official PS. so WHAT'S the fuckin problem? ;)
And even if something screwed up on someones computer then REINSTALL and everything works correctly...
Great Devs could download, that means other people can download too unless you keep it private, other than that it's public, so that means you are not using it "For your own benefit" right?
the second part of the post covers THIS clearly - Devs won't have to repair things taht are made by amateurs if they are not confirmed as part of the project. Downloading amateurs stuff is at your own risk and that is obvious!
We don't have time to test things craeted by the communtiy. We barely have time to actually do the dev-work. =/
And that anim is basically impossible in Kismet.
Gosh...
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 07:25:44 PM
We don't have time to test things craeted by the communtiy. We barely have time to actually do the dev-work. =/
And that anim is basically impossible in Kismet.
Doesn't it say in the topic "After"? Even if you dont have time - ok then leave it to the community completely. As I said it won't hurt anyone it will be just like downloading maps in CT you dont have it, you can't play on the server. tahts all...
No, the game doesn't even allow you to connect to anybody that doesn't have the EXACT same binary version (same code != same binary for some weird reason).
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 07:43:24 PM
No, the game doesn't even allow you to connect to anybody that doesn't have the EXACT same binary version (same code != same binary for some weird reason).
OMG so if the devs add a new map to the game, then the people have to reDL the whole game? ???
You can't play with others cause your game is not exactly the same that is true. That's why if you would confirm some of those free made, by someone, features then everyone would have the same exact game. There is really much less to do when you have something already done and just waiting to be tested for issues... but if you still wouldn't wish to add such free made implementations then what's the problem with keeping 2 game files?
1 - original PS
2 - "fucked up with your implementations" PS to play with friends who also have downloaded your implementations to have cool missions with jumping of the heli and skydiving.
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 07:51:48 PM2 - "fucked up with your implementations" PS to play with friends who also have downloaded your implementations to have cool missions with jumping of the heli and skydiving.
LOLz...
In THAT case you should make a whole new game by yourself :P
That exactly what I am thinking, you just basically stealing 90% of the Project Stealth developers game, and you make it your own and you give it out to the public and only they can play it. As well as PS cannot manage it and the only person that can manage it is you, so in overall you are stealing the whole system game and making it your own and publish it by yourself without the proper authority?
Quote from: Meister_Neo on January 06, 2011, 07:53:39 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 07:51:48 PM2 - "fucked up with your implementations" PS to play with friends who also have downloaded your implementations to have cool missions with jumping of the heli and skydiving.
LOLz...
In THAT case you should make a whole new game by yourself :P
Nope. I would have to make a special animated staticmesh(parachute) and anim of spy who is flying with it. Then the whole map but that is to be covered by the editor.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 07:55:26 PM
That exactly what I am thinking, you just basically stealing 90% of the Project Stealth developers game, and you make it your own and you give it out to the public and only they can play it. As well as PS cannot manage it and the only person that can manage it is you, so in overall you are stealing the whole system game and making it your own and publish it by yourself without the proper authority?
GOSH people you have some really big problems... Implementing stuff to the game that is not made by you doesn't mean stealing!!! If so then modding the DOOM 3 is stealing...
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 08:00:10 PM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 07:55:26 PM
That exactly what I am thinking, you just basically stealing 90% of the Project Stealth developers game, and you make it your own and you give it out to the public and only they can play it. As well as PS cannot manage it and the only person that can manage it is you, so in overall you are stealing the whole system game and making it your own and publish it by yourself without the proper authority?
GOSH people you have some really big problems... Implementing stuff to the game that is not made by you doesn't mean stealing!!! If so then modding the DOOM 3 is stealing...
Ok, but you stated you want to mod without allowing the public to be able to download it, then you mention you want to play it with your friends? That basically same thing? Doom 3 allows modding and allows the code to be changed and downloadable by others.
Quote from: Meister_Neo on January 06, 2011, 07:50:56 PM
OMG so if the devs add a new map to the game, then the people have to reDL the whole game? ???
No.
As for the code, the reason it won't be open source is actually quite straight forward: We made A LOT of custom code and only rely on our own subsystems, this means we are
not using the following:
- Epics Input system
- Epics Weapon system
- Epics Network code
- Epics Animation system (partly, at least)
- etc...
Basically everything is custom which took a lot of time to create and think out and we (read: I) therefor don't want it to be out in the open just like that. Giving away the editor alone is already a hazard, as it would easily allow everyone to steal our hand-made assets (again, which took a lot of time).
So, yes, it's basically a matter of stealing and why UDK isn't open-source (moneeeehh). If you are interested in anything specific I am more than happy to explain you how it works and give you snippets where possible, but don't expect me to give you code which I could sell (yes, you read that right) as a framework easily.
Without the source, modding something as custom as ours is mostly likely impossible as you will need reference/documentation. Besides, in UE2 it was impossible to compile code when the U files had their code stripped out (which we did) and I'm sure that's still the case for UE3.
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:04:50 PM
Quote from: Meister_Neo on January 06, 2011, 07:50:56 PM
OMG so if the devs add a new map to the game, then the people have to reDL the whole game? ???
No.
As for the code, the reason it won't be open source is actually quite straight forward: We made A LOT of custom code and only rely on our own subsystems, this means we are not using the following:
- Epics Input system
- Epics Weapon system
- Epics Network code
- Epics Animation system (partly, at least)
- etc...
Basically everything is custom which took a lot of time to create and think out and we (read: I) therefor don't want it to be out in the open just like that. Giving away the editor alone is already a hazard, as it would easily allow everyone to steal our hand-made assets (again, which took a lot of time).
So, yes, it's basically a matter of stealing and why UDK isn't open-source (moneeeehh). If you are interested in anything specific I am more than happy to explain you how it works and give you snippets where possible, but don't expect me to give you code which I could sell (yes, you read that right) as a framework easily.
Tell me what did I steal from you. If I made my own map and implement there a (I'll keep using this example since it keeps showing up in my head) parachute and a spy flying with it?
What did I steal? Your spy model? Does it really pops up in your head as stealing? I put it on the internet and say you can download if you wish so(I never said you wouldn't be able to).
You either get it but don't want to accept it, or you just read whatever you want it be.
We said we will not make PS moddable for the very simple reason it will make stealing our hard work to easy for the "bad" among the crowd, I've never said you are one of those.
You can do whatever you want within the editor to a certain level, but don't expect us to give you a rig to make animations (which you will need to make your "Spy Ass Likking") and that it works on all clients or access to code to make whatever mutation you want.
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:04:50 PM
Quote from: Meister_Neo on January 06, 2011, 07:50:56 PM
OMG so if the devs add a new map to the game, then the people have to reDL the whole game? ???
No.
As for the code, the reason it won't be open source is actually quite straight forward: We made A LOT of custom code and only rely on our own subsystems, this means we are not using the following:
- Epics Input system
- Epics Weapon system
- Epics Network code
- Epics Animation system (partly, at least)
- etc...
Basically everything is custom which took a lot of time to create and think out and we (read: I) therefor don't want it to be out in the open just like that. Giving away the editor alone is already a hazard, as it would easily allow everyone to steal our hand-made assets (again, which took a lot of time).
So, yes, it's basically a matter of stealing and why UDK isn't open-source (moneeeehh). If you are interested in anything specific I am more than happy to explain you how it works and give you snippets where possible, but don't expect me to give you code which I could sell (yes, you read that right) as a framework easily.
Without the source, modding something as custom as ours is mostly likely impossible as you will need reference/documentation. Besides, in UE2 it was impossible to compile code when the U files had their code stripped out (which we did) and I'm sure that's still the case for UE3.
Just out of curiosity, hypothetically, how much would the whole thing cost?
-Models
-Animations
-Custom Script/Coding
-Textures
Are we talking about, 1000$? 3000$? 5000$? More? (I wouldn't be surprised at all)
By the way Pusianka you did state in one of your posts "Create yourself, and then only use it for myself" now at first I thought what was the point? Self-education? Maybe....Out of boredom? I smell fish...For friends? AHA! Publicz! But seriously why would you even want to mod it?
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:15:59 PM
By the way Pusianka you did state in one of your posts "Create yourself, and then only use it for myself" now at first I thought what was the point? Self-education? Maybe....Out of boredom? I smell fish...For friends? AHA! Publicz! But seriously why would you even want to mod it?
Because devs would have less to do? Isn't it obvious?
I wouldnt dare to say that, but the spy model alone is 800 hours of work, which in terms of hourly salary of 15 euro's would mean it costs about 12000 euro's, if not double (because 15 euro is really the lowest salary a modeller would get).
We all do this for free and therefor have even more rights to protect our intellectual property in any way possible. If not allowing modding helps with that, so be it.
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 08:18:30 PM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:15:59 PM
By the way Pusianka you did state in one of your posts "Create yourself, and then only use it for myself" now at first I thought what was the point? Self-education? Maybe....Out of boredom? I smell fish...For friends? AHA! Publicz! But seriously why would you even want to mod it?
Because devs would have less to do? Isn't it obvious?
And you really think that you would have something to offer? Something that will "MAKE THAT PLACE" less pressurising for developers?
Pusianka you really need to check other developers work, because I think you underestimate the quality that Project Stealth requires, and not to offend anyone?
But I think if a casual person who just gets 3DS MAX/Maya/Photoshop/Zbrush for free and plays around with it and gets the basic stuff in a week, and all of a sudden decides and thinks he can apply to be a 3D modeller/Animator/Scripter/Artist and The Project Stealth developers would accept them? What kind of reputation would that give them?
For the record, we always welcome juniors with reasonable experience, you don't have to be a pro with industry experience.
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:19:47 PM
I wouldnt dare to say that, but the spy model alone is 800 hours of work, which in terms of hourly salary of 15 euro's would mean it costs about 12000 euro's, if not double (because 15 euro is really the lowest salary a modeller would get).
We all do this for free and therefor have even more rights to protect our intellectual property in any way possible. If not allowing modding helps with that, so be it.
So that really clears up a lot, this is almost the same as the one time I was so bored I was checking every "Join us" posts and saw one of the amateur--ish 3D Models and wanted to get accepted but you declined because his standard was too low, so I think this is the point where Modding and the fact that 1 model costs over 20,000$/EU makes a lot of sense to me.
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:25:42 PM
For the record, we always welcome juniors with reasonable experience, you don't have to be a pro with industry experience.
Juniors? What you mean by that, talk to me Lennard, what Juniors? What experience are we talking? How high standard? What!? WHAT?! WHAT!? SPEAK TO ME GIVE ME THE WHOLE SIT REP!!!....Please :)
I'd say a lot more than 5k ;).
Besides, Kismet and Matinee are powerful enough to do skydiving. Just flip the Spy in his falling animation. Should be possible. Animate the various parts of the parachute in Matinee, then combine it. Won't look great, but it resembles skydiving. And if you ask nicely, we might even make a skydiving-ish animation. We're just so nice (and comicsserg being so awesomely good)
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:25:48 PM
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:19:47 PM
I wouldnt dare to say that, but the spy model alone is 800 hours of work, which in terms of hourly salary of 15 euro's would mean it costs about 12000 euro's, if not double (because 15 euro is really the lowest salary a modeller would get).
We all do this for free and therefor have even more rights to protect our intellectual property in any way possible. If not allowing modding helps with that, so be it.
So that really clears up a lot, this is almost the same as the one time I was so bored I was checking every "Join us" posts and saw one of the amateur--ish 3D Models and wanted to get accepted but you declined because his standard was too low, so I think this is the point where Modding and the fact that 1 model costs over 20,000$/EU makes a lot of sense to me.
Wut? Me no understand.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:26:59 PM
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:25:42 PM
For the record, we always welcome juniors with reasonable experience, you don't have to be a pro with industry experience.
Juniors? What you mean by that, talk to me Lennard, what Juniors? What experience are we talking? How high standard? What!? WHAT?! WHAT!? SPEAK TO ME GIVE ME THE WHOLE SIT REP!!!....Please :)
A junior is someone who never did work profesionally but still has good and extensive portfolio showing more than just guns or stools. Among the standards would be proper UV maps, generating good normal maps with low/high resolution models, being able to make textures and good use of edge loop and all those other techniques which simply tell how good you are with a tool. Better yet, being able to determine wheter the number of polys is too high or too low and defend that choice.
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:30:29 PM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:25:48 PM
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:19:47 PM
I wouldnt dare to say that, but the spy model alone is 800 hours of work, which in terms of hourly salary of 15 euro's would mean it costs about 12000 euro's, if not double (because 15 euro is really the lowest salary a modeller would get).
We all do this for free and therefor have even more rights to protect our intellectual property in any way possible. If not allowing modding helps with that, so be it.
So that really clears up a lot, this is almost the same as the one time I was so bored I was checking every "Join us" posts and saw one of the amateur--ish 3D Models and wanted to get accepted but you declined because his standard was too low, so I think this is the point where Modding and the fact that 1 model costs over 20,000$/EU makes a lot of sense to me.
Wut? Me no understand.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:26:59 PM
Quote from: LennardF1989 on January 06, 2011, 08:25:42 PM
For the record, we always welcome juniors with reasonable experience, you don't have to be a pro with industry experience.
Juniors? What you mean by that, talk to me Lennard, what Juniors? What experience are we talking? How high standard? What!? WHAT?! WHAT!? SPEAK TO ME GIVE ME THE WHOLE SIT REP!!!....Please :)
A junior is someone who never did work profesionally but still has good and extensive portfolio showing more than just guns or stools.
Basically what I meant was, By making everything yourself for free, and allowing people to mod and draw dicks on spies faces would be really hurting.
Ekhem... this is just so... ok I ll keep my way of thinking ON topic.
Now to do something for the PS you need to get into the team. You get into the team and yet you still can't do what you want becuase you have to do what the team tells you to do since its first on the list of things TO DO.
Devs team has to concentrate on main things first... always.
When the BETA is out, they will first fix the bugs then start implementing new stuff. SO why not make it so that someone who made an animation that really can be used and is not in the team can't implement it? whats so wrong about it? IT'S not stealing damn it! This person just added a new feature in and devs can take it for the PS. Honestly I don't see it as a problem. You feel worse when someone is trying to offer you some help in project? It's always your choice to download it? Players also see the quality of the made thing so if it's crappy they won't take it jsut like Devs!
If you have a good idea for an animation AND you have the skills, use a test-rig (like a puppet) and then animate it. If it's good enough, you might get into the team (if you want to help). Or we might supply you with the actual rigs so you can tweak your animation to the Spy.
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 08:37:54 PM
If you have a good idea for an animation AND you have the skills, use a test-rig (like a puppet) and then animate it. If it's good enough, you might get into the team (if you want to help). Or we might supply you with the actual rigs so you can tweak your animation to the Spy.
Ok we're gettin closer to some reasonable ending. I do not wish to be in team since it would make me do some stuff that I probably didn't wish for. Also I do not wish to make team make another animation since you have already a lot of animations to do.
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 08:36:28 PM
Ekhem... this is just so... ok I ll keep my way of thinking ON topic.
Now to do something for the PS you need to get into the team. You get into the team and yet you still can't do what you want becuase you have to do what the team tells you to do since its first on the list of things TO DO.
Devs team has to concentrate on main things first... always.
When the BETA is out, they will first fix the bugs then start implementing new stuff. SO why not make it so that someone who made an animation that really can be used and is not in the team can't implement it? whats so wrong about it? IT'S not stealing damn it! This person just added a new feature in and devs can take it for the PS. Honestly I don't see it as a problem. You feel worse when someone is trying to offer you some help in project? It's always your choice to download it? Players also see the quality of the made thing so if it's crappy they won't take it jsut like Devs!
So if I make an animation that will flip my spy 5000 meters up the sky, and someone else makes an animation just a jump with a flip, how will that work?
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 06, 2011, 08:46:02 PM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 06, 2011, 08:36:28 PM
Ekhem... this is just so... ok I ll keep my way of thinking ON topic.
Now to do something for the PS you need to get into the team. You get into the team and yet you still can't do what you want becuase you have to do what the team tells you to do since its first on the list of things TO DO.
Devs team has to concentrate on main things first... always.
When the BETA is out, they will first fix the bugs then start implementing new stuff. SO why not make it so that someone who made an animation that really can be used and is not in the team can't implement it? whats so wrong about it? IT'S not stealing damn it! This person just added a new feature in and devs can take it for the PS. Honestly I don't see it as a problem. You feel worse when someone is trying to offer you some help in project? It's always your choice to download it? Players also see the quality of the made thing so if it's crappy they won't take it jsut like Devs!
So if I make an animation that will flip my spy 5000 meters up the sky, and someone else makes an animation just a jump with a flip, how will that work?
Dread you keep putting examples that are ridiculous and as I said it could be up to devs to accept it in next patch of the game. All the other amateur stuff is at your own risk.
We'll see on a case-by-case base.
So as far as I see it, if the Animations are amateur quality, they don't get accepted, if they are Junior/Professional like, you apply get into the team, they get accepted?
Not necessarily. We'll see if it meets the quality requirements. And even then, that doesn't mean anything. We've had plenty of anims that we used, but then others came to replace them.
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 07:43:24 PM
No, the game doesn't even allow you to connect to anybody that doesn't have the EXACT same binary version (same code != same binary for some weird reason).
It allows you to connect just fine. You just need to wait for the server to finish sending the original versions of the modified files.
Quote from: Meister_Neo on January 06, 2011, 07:50:56 PM
Quote from: frvge on January 06, 2011, 07:43:24 PM
No, the game doesn't even allow you to connect to anybody that doesn't have the EXACT same binary version (same code != same binary for some weird reason).
OMG so if the devs add a new map to the game, then the people have to reDL the whole game? ???
See above.
So from what I understood, puuusianka wants to know if it's possible to get a self-made animation into the game as long as it's deemed to be of enough quality that it can make the cut.
Say I start creating a map, and I come up with a solution for something hackable, say shutting down some electronic devices that allow the spies to move more freely at an area. Now instead of using the usual hacking panel way of doing things, I want the spies to open up a panel somewhere, get a hold of wires and actually visually cut them, in the same time frame it would take for hacking. Of course this would require a new animation, thus I decide that I'll attempt to create it myself (along with the merc animation counter-part)
Now the next step would be to create the animation on a test-rig, make it as good/fluid etc. as you can. After that you could make a video of the animation, send it to the devs for evaluation (as long as they are willing to check it out) and have a chance of getting the actual rigs to make your animation reality and get it into the game. And if that doesn't happen, then you'll just have to develop your skills more.
Get good enough in this and you could have a spot in the dev-team too if you wanted to.
Quote from: ShadowX on January 08, 2011, 01:44:57 PM
So from what I understood, puuusianka wants to know if it's possible to get a self-made animation into the game as long as it's deemed to be of enough quality that it can make the cut.
Say I start creating a map, and I come up with a solution for something hackable, say shutting down some electronic devices that allow the spies to move more freely at an area. Now instead of using the usual hacking panel way of doing things, I want the spies to open up a panel somewhere, get a hold of wires and actually visually cut them, in the same time frame it would take for hacking. Of course this would require a new animation, thus I decide that I'll attempt to create it myself (along with the merc animation counter-part)
Now the next step would be to create the animation on a test-rig, make it as good/fluid etc. as you can. After that you could make a video of the animation, send it to the devs for evaluation (as long as they are willing to check it out) and have a chance of getting the actual rigs to make your animation reality and get it into the game. And if that doesn't happen, then you'll just have to develop your skills more.
Get good enough in this and you could have a spot in the dev-team too if you wanted to.
You just repeated most of the stuff the community read in this thread.
That called "Developers"
People who actually have the needed qualities are already mostly in the current dev team.
Quote from: frvge on January 13, 2011, 12:13:14 AM
People who actually have the needed qualities are already mostly in the current dev team.
gosh frvge how many tines will I have to break it to you?! Maybe there are people who do not wish to be in dev team!!!
Quote from: puuusianka on January 13, 2011, 12:20:51 AM
Quote from: frvge on January 13, 2011, 12:13:14 AM
People who actually have the needed qualities are already mostly in the current dev team.
gosh frvge how many tines will I have to break it to you?! Maybe there are people who do bot wish to be in dev team!!!
If they like Versus, have the skills to help and are waiting for PS, but do not want to help the dev team out, they are egocentrical bastards who take what others make but do not give anything in return.
No. You take it from 1 point of view. I remind you that the topic says after PS is out. You have your team. Team takes care of the main. Not everyone is good enough to work in a team. Some people might be very slow workers. Some might have nt enough time to take care of all project needs. Allowing them to
mod something in their small free time is honestly a good thing for the players and for the devs since their game is getting new feature, ofc you don't have to take it. Like e.g. Parachute jumping ;P
Frvge, just drop the subject. We said all we could possibly say to make clear our intentions.
Quote from: frvge on January 13, 2011, 12:31:19 AM
Quote from: puuusianka on January 13, 2011, 12:20:51 AM
Quote from: frvge on January 13, 2011, 12:13:14 AM
People who actually have the needed qualities are already mostly in the current dev team.
gosh frvge how many tines will I have to break it to you?! Maybe there are people who do bot wish to be in dev team!!!
If they like Versus, have the skills to help and are waiting for PS, but do not want to help the dev team out, they are egocentrical bastards who take what others make but do not give anything in return.
+1
I see it as this:
People who would want to work for PS but don't want to be part of the Dev team, instead would want to make animations for when the game is out already, do so because they are afraid to waste their time working in "development stage" and rather work on a finished project so they can show off their work to their little bastard friends that they worked on something that made it final. Gaining a lot of E-penis without going through all the "bullshit" (In their eyes.) design phases that took years.
Easy cash ride.
As well as, it shows how stupid they are for not wanting to be on developer team with having skills to be one, I mean honestly, putting PS on a portfolio would be an amazing thing to show to company manager who you want to work for.
Quote from: Wh1tE_Dw4rF on January 14, 2011, 11:13:58 PM
I see it as this:
People who would want to work for PS but don't want to be part of the Dev team, instead would want to make animations for when the game is out already, do so because they are afraid to waste their time working in "development stage" and rather work on a finished project so they can show off their work to their little bastard friends that they worked on something that made it final. Gaining a lot of E-penis without going through all the "bullshit" (In their eyes.) design phases that took years.
Easy cash ride.
these could be your intentions but there seems to be no point to discuss it with you guys because you keep on one point of view and interprate it just to make the idea look bad. Still modding was invented by someone and after all this whole thing was a MOD for a few years. But modding is still bad, isn't it guys?
Modding isn't bad, but you didn't show any proof of why you want to do it.
If a person makes a mod, and developers like it, they won't need to do that, because they will ask him to join the team, and if he says something like, I want to be a developer but I don't want to be on the team. That will just straight away show the developers that the person they want to give a chance to be a developer is just selfish.
Games that can be modded, are the ones you pay for, the ones that the Production Team got money for, so far I haven't seen a single indie game, that was free, and allowed people to mod it, why? Because they don't want to share their assets that took them a very long time to make, and allow people to draw balls on them.
@Pus Best thing I would suggest, write a big post, to show every bad and good point and exactly why you want PS to allow you to mod, and how will it benefit the team.
Execept the fact that I did? I won't waste my any more of my time. I'll come back when I have something to show and then we might try to talk again.
Well from all of what you just said was answered and considered selfish :/
As I said only one vision in your eyes.
Well, so far the only vision I have is the one that is the most supported, so it does make sense.
Reading this thread just makes me feel bad.
It began with an innocent question with a sarcastic example (the licking his ass part), and it got answered with a barrage of "well we don't trust you" and "this is mine, you no can haz". I understand the want to keep your assets private and probably nothing is going to change that, but it still sounds bad. (sounds, not IS)
What's been asked is obviously too much, but it is interesting. It would be cool to have custom "intros" to levels. Such as parachuting down onto the level, or say... a swimming entrance for spies on Lakehouse (dock... water.. swimming). Something that would make sense for the given level and explain HOW the spies got to their spawn (could be a video that just plays on the loading screen. Would be cooler looking than a big "LOADING" text deal in your face). If a person from the community (say someone making a map) could make a custom animation? Hell sounds like that someone making a map has even more fun stuff to do. (Making their OWN intro)
The talk of not wanting to be a developer seems to have been taken in the wrong direction though. I see puuu more saying he wants to be like a Mapper, not that he's trying to be selfish and "only do the work he wants to do".
In the end it: Sounds sad, IS asking too much, and IS a cool concept.
Well, if he wants to be a mapper, why not apply to be one? Be environmental artist or whatever like Zedblade? He could actually pair up and make even better maps like Lakehouse.
Big THANK YOU to Cronky the master! Someone who managed second time to speak out my thoughts in a way better then I would.
Yes, but he still didn't really prove to developers why they would benefit from being able to have their game modded, there is still not enough. Well in my opinion at the very least, hopefully to see some green posts.
Look you want always your last word. Now "You listen! I talk" I'll be back with a puppet. Then we'll talk! Keep it in mind I don't need(want) another post from you on topic, pls.
Okay, bring the puppet :)
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 15, 2011, 11:52:22 PM
Well, if he wants to be a mapper, why not apply to be one? Be environmental artist or whatever like Zedblade? He could actually pair up and make even better maps like Lakehouse.
This is talking as if the game is already released. The PS Editor will be out with the ability for anyone in the community (or so I assume) will be able to create maps.
If you are good at making maps or if you were good at making a animation of a spy parachuting down, then you should try out to be a dev and make the game better with your expertise. That much is true.
If you're the average user on the other hand that just wants to make something for fun, say me for instance, then I probably don't have much to offer that would be of help to anything dev-wise. That doesn't mean that I couldn't make something good though if given the right tools and the freedom to work on it on my own time.
That's the point of this whole thread. Would the average community member be able to create complex "mods" that could potentially add content to the game (if viewed by devs and accepted)? The answer is, other than maps, no.
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 16, 2011, 12:05:47 AM
Okay, bring the puppet :)
wow this went incredibly easy... Too easy...
Gotta get back to my "Detective X..." stories - this is some really good material!
Quote from: Cronky on January 16, 2011, 12:08:31 AM
Quote from: DreadStunLock on January 15, 2011, 11:52:22 PM
Well, if he wants to be a mapper, why not apply to be one? Be environmental artist or whatever like Zedblade? He could actually pair up and make even better maps like Lakehouse.
This is talking as if the game is already released. The PS Editor will be out with the ability for anyone in the community (or so I assume) will be able to create maps.
If you are good at making maps or if you were good at making a animation of a spy parachuting down, then you should try out to be a dev and make the game better with your expertise. That much is true.
If you're the average user on the other hand that just wants to make something for fun, say me for instance, then I probably don't have much to offer that would be of help to anything dev-wise. That doesn't mean that I couldn't make something good though if given the right tools and the freedom to work on it on my own time.
That's the point of this whole thread. Would the average community member be able to create complex "mods" that could potentially add content to the game (if viewed by devs and accepted)? The answer is, other than maps, no.
As well as, I am sure Project Stealth would give a chance to apply as Junior in whatever position you want to be, so that can make the situation a lot more bearable.