http://forums.ubi.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/3651075192/m/7951084295
EDIT: the text from that thread for those who are IP banned/censored:
Quote"Project Stealth" has been turned over to the Ubisoft legal team for possible copyright infringement. ANY posting on the subject will be cause for an immediate ban until we are told it is ok by the "legal". The same rule applies to having links in your signature.
The same also applies to posting links to sites where PS is promoted. Posting any of these will be cause for an permanent ban. Any gray areas will be left for the admins/mods to decide on the appropriate action.
Cool, now they think that the SvM gameplay can be copyrighted?
end of the project ?
NO WAI
Who wrote that?
I doubt anything will come of this considering that some of the SvM devs were supportive of this project.
Jackie is the one who posted it.
Quote from: Spekkio on September 24, 2007, 07:42:43 PM
Who wrote that?
I doubt anything will come of this considering that some of the SvM devs were supportive of this project.
I doubt the devs have much say in anthing concerning copyright infringment and legal action. I seriously doubt the devs like to release half assed, unfinished games either but we know they are probably forced to release it as-is so they can work on the next money making project.
This is not Splinter Cell nor will it ever be. Nothing is being, nor has it been copied from Ubi and no copyrights have been infringed upon. We strive to provide a quality gaming experience that is akin only in that it is an objective based versus game but draws inspiration from many quarters not just from games such as the Splinter Cell series.
I really hope they don't because this has been my shrine and i hate to see it close :(. , also I guess posting on the Ubisoft forums is similar to A hacker boasting on IRC how they did this and that, which in then end = Legal action =/.
UBI cannot do anything to us...
we can still produce a mod, using our content.
We are just not welcome on their forum.,,,which i treat that as a form of respect.
Thing is, we have to now as a team change the game concept and remove all referance to anything owned by UBI.
By change of concept, does not mean we remove stealth, light and shadow, or spy vs merc.
Hopefully we can discuss with UBI about this.
Well depending on how tenatious the legal department is, we may get a cease and desist order. After that we'd have to open up talks with UBI to find out what needs to be changed in order for us to proceed, if at all.
This isn't going to be a game that will be released on it's own. It's solely a mod for UT. I'd be impressed if we actually garnered enough attention that such an order is to be made. Hell, that's news worthy.
Yah, that would be the biggest publicity we will have if Ubi, a huge gaming industry corporation, decides to shut down a small community of about 200 people trying to keep a video game genre alive for FREE.
Quote from: element54 on September 24, 2007, 09:49:00 PM
Yah, that would be the biggest publicity we will have if Ubi, a huge gaming industry corporation, decides to shut down a small community of about 200 people trying to keep a video game genre alive for FREE.
w00t, that'd be awesome - the gaming world would go like BOOM and ubi would lose lots of money.
Really...there is nothing to be worried about. Ubisoft doesn't care about some lone mod team. The Ubisoft moderators just don't like us. That's it. Nothing else to it.
So because I like looking stuff up and research I found some stuff and by stuff I mean a legal case that protects our idea or rather the idea in general. It can be similar, but different, which is what we are trying to do. May I also suggest editing the thread title it actually annoys me as we are atleast semi-respectable here.
Thank Spekkio for this statement: "That's like saying Capcom copyrighted someone doing a jump kick with Street Fighter 2, so every fighting game since is in violation" as it reminded me of this:
These early industry-defining lawsuits are arguably some of the most interesting, and affect the way we play games today. But even though the bedrock has stopped shifting and the lava has congealed, modern video game suits aren't in short supply.
Nor are they exclusive to the companies that manufacture hardware. Software developers often sue each other in court cases that twist and turn. Japanese developer Data East created a 1993 Super Nintendo game called Fighter's History that bore more than a passing resemblance to Capcom's popular Street Fighter II. Many of the characters' moves mirrored those of Street Fighter's World Warriors, and the background art was certainly inspired. Even the roster of characters in Fighter's History was familiar: There was the chunky Commie wrestler, the smart-ass American, the stoic martial artist who lived for the fight, and the Masked mystery man. Although Capcom lost, the lawsuit was still ironic; it was Data East's 1984 arcade game, The Way of Karate, that first used the side-view fighting perspective that was the very basis for Street Fighter II. Even stranger, Data East had previously sued an American software company, Epyx, for its Commodore 64 game, World Karate Championship. Data East had argued that World Karate Championship looked and played very similar to their own Way of Karate. Data East initially won the lawsuit and had Epyx's game pulled, but Epyx appealed and the US Federal Court reversed the judgment, upholding the right of game developers to create and distribute products that express the same ideas, even if the products are similar.
Who says they need to shut us down?
They can sue Epic for letting us use their software for copyright infringement.
That forces Epic to shut us down.
It doesnt matter, the only thing they can do is prevent us from making our mod to similar to CT.
That my friends, is why I started threads for brainstorming about new visions and moves.
Good find Daybreak!
Also, Blizzard and Games Workshop went through a massive lawsuit over Warhammer and Warcraft having similar characters.
http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl108.html <-- must read.
http://www.gamesetwatch.com/2006/10/confessions_of_a_clone_maker.php .
wow...if that first link is true...then we are certainly safe.
"The idea for a game is not protected by copyright. The same is true of the name or title given to the game and of the method or methods for playing it.
Copyright protects only the particular manner of an authorââ,¬â,,¢s expression in literary, artistic, or musical form. Copyright protection does not extend to any idea, system, method, device, or trademark material involved in the development, merchandising, or playing of a game. Once a game has been made public, nothing in the copyright law prevents others from developing another game based on similar principles.
Some material prepared in connection with a game may be subject to copyright if it contains a sufficient amount of literary or pictorial expression. For example, the text matter describing the rules of the game, or the pictorial matter appearing on the gameboard or container, may be registrable."
This goes back to what I said before: instead of getting paranoid over nothing, go consult a lawyer.
I think that the Ubi mods and CM just want to shut down us promoting PS on the Ubi forums.
With that first link, they can't really touch us.
Then there's the matter of where to send the cease & desist letter. USA? Netherlands? UK? et cetera.
we dont have to do anything yet, but i did consult colleagues in the game dev business and they all agreed that making any referance to Splinter Cell or cloning is enough to cause problems.
Hey Aj this is FARLEYFAN, I've been saying F YOU UBI for a long time now lol
Anyways, Ubi can suck my balls. They suck.
TRUE STORY. No game can copyright an idea of gameplay. Or else sports games would sue other sports game, fps's would sue other fps's, and rpg's would sue other rpg's. That makes the most sense. I say we are just fine.
Guys, I appreciate your loyalty to Project Stealth.
If you want to help promote the Project, it is best done by not attacking UBI.
In fact, if we were to say...get sponsorship for the project, being able to communicate diplomatically is the surest way of having an open dialog.
I just got a PM from Jinx, and the only thing they can criticize is our "intent to clone". We of course have not released anything that is cloned, and have the clear "intent" not to violate copyrights.
Also, she explained that UBI is less likely to cooperate if we bash them.
Seems Jackie has been corrected:
"Ubisoft is concerned about Project Stealth due to the questionable nature of its attempt to clone the multiplayer aspect of Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory. Until Ubisoft has addressed these concerns about the project to our satisfaction, we cannot allow discussion about it to take place on the official Ubisoft forums.
This message has been edited. Last edited by: Vth_F_Smith_, Tue September 25 2007 03:56"
First they falsely accuse us of copyright infringement and threaten banning of anyone that even utters the words. Now its all about wether the Multiplayer can be copywritten or not.
i know goodkebab has said this but again:
an idea is public domain, ANYONE can use it. (im sorry i keep bringing up this game) Fortress Forever has the same class names, and has the name Fortress forever. Valve didnt give a shit, becuase they arent retarded, and they actually know about copyright laws. Black Mesa: Source is using the half-life logo, and the Source name. Valve made them not use Source, to prevent people thinking it was an offical product. thats all. :)
Quote from: Vega on September 24, 2007, 10:11:09 PM
Really...there is nothing to be worried about. Ubisoft doesn't care about some lone mod team. The Ubisoft moderators just don't like us. That's it. Nothing else to it.
That's because guess who's better???
and by not using Source, i meant in the name, not the engine. if they made them not use the Source engine there wuold be some problems!
Quote from: Westfall-US on September 30, 2007, 11:49:34 PM
That's because guess who's better???
Psh, no need to ask that! 8)