Splinter Cell Conviction

Started by CurdyMilk, March 18, 2010, 04:32:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

VaNilla

I've just played through the whole game and wow, this is fantastic. Let me just start off by addressing one of the main concerns with Conviction. Yes, the majority of the game can be played through using full stealth (although, you will spend a lot more time figuring out how to go about it). I actually found the shouting guards very immersive, I didn't have any problems with them. The black and white filter is still a bit annoying (but it becomes easier to judge after a while), but I can honestly say that was one of my only problems with the single player game. The story is really good, if not a little far-fetched. On my first play-through I used M&E, and I have to say it's even better than I expected! It's been balanced very well, not once did I feel like I was over-powered. People have complained from the get go that running and gunning would be too easy in Conviction (which was a non-point from the start, as they had never played it), but I tried this and failed every time (however I have only played the game on realistic, so I can't say the same for Rookie/Normal).

The increased emphasis on the use of gadgets is very interesting; unlike previous Splinter Cell games, the gadgets actually need to be used at times, and you have to be very smart about the way you use them. I do feel that the game is a bit linear in terms of level design, they could have created more options for approaching a room or a situation. However, it never stood out as a problem with the game, because the level design is fantastic. It's just something I would have liked to see. Speaking of levels, the Iraq level was the one mission that shouldn't have been in the game. The premise of it is not the problem, but the fact that many of the game's features had been stripped out specifically for that level is lubricious. The factors the game prides itself upon had vanished, it was really dumb. I did enjoy playing through the level, and it served its purpose, but it's out of place.

So the million dollar question, is Conviction better than Chaos Theory? It's a tough question. Single player? Most definitely; not by leaps and bounds, but the sheer quality and attention to detail made the game fantastic; I'm so glad that they've finally tried something new instead of listening to the tools who want to play the same game over and over again. The co-op campaign? I haven't played it yet, but I'll be sure to let you know what I think when I can. Spy vs Spy? It's a great laugh, it's a lot more stealth-orientated than you might believe, and it will certainly keep me coming back for more, but it doesn't hold a candle to SvM. It's a good multiplayer game, but SvM is a masterpiece, it's a shame that they didn't make the game more complex. They could have added more variations on Spy vs Spy, such as to defend a bombsite. Overall? I think that Conviction is the best game in the franchise; but the multiplayer can't beat that of PT/CT/DA. If SvM had never existed, I would have loved the face-off mode in Conviction, but an idea like SvM is something they're mad to have let go.

Cronky

#76
Quote from: STON3COLDKILLA on April 17, 2010, 02:25:02 AM
Speaking of levels, the Iraq level was the one mission that shouldn't have been in the game. The premise of it is not the problem, but the fact that many of the game's features had been stripped out specifically for that level is lubricious. The factors the game prides itself upon had vanished, it was really dumb. I did enjoy playing through the level, and it served its purpose, but it's out of place.

I actually think the Iraq mission was really well done and rides up there with the best of levels in the game. Mainly for the circumstances that the story throws upon you makes it make sense.

****Spoilers Ahead for those who care****







A.) It's a flashback to the past. Before any of them would have been really "Masterful" like Sam is currently.

B.) It was a pure action section. The mechanics that were not used are geared towards stealth. No stealth, no need for the mechanics.

C.) Even if A wasn't true, you weren't Sam. Giving the character of Vic a little more background than it would if those mechanics were in there. Vic doesn't care about being sneaky. Vic was under pressure to find his friend. Vic picks up the only AK with a Scope on it and has infinite ammo. ;) Point being that if he would have played the same, then Sam wouldn't feel as unique. (Much in the same vein that if EVERYONE had Sonar Goggles, the other Splinter Cells wouldn't seem as unique).






***End Spoilers****


All in all it's good to see that you had just as much fun with the game as I did.
If you haven't noticed, I'm REALLY good at making a simple response into a wall of text.
-----------------------
xFire:Cronkbot | Steam:Cronky

VaNilla

I disagree, it took so many of the features that made Conviction unique and interesting, and removed them. On another note, I'm rendering full stealth walkthroughs for the first two missions of the game at the moment (despite that only one section of the tutorial mission can be ghosted), so watch this space :).

Ion.67


Farley4Fan

The stealth in Conviction is just too simplified.  You can "ghost" but you have to memorize the dark/light spots so it's reminiscent of Frogger with 1 route.  There is no choice of where to go when there is only one possible route that you can "ghost" with.  And even then, it's only a matter of time until you will HAVE to get into a firefight.

VaNilla

#80
Quote from: Ion.67 on April 17, 2010, 06:10:08 PM
Do you have an HD PVR?

I would like one, but no, I use a Dazzle DVC170.

Quote from: FarleyFan on April 17, 2010, 07:10:56 PM
The stealth in Conviction is just too simplified.  You can "ghost" but you have to memorize the dark/light spots so it's reminiscent of Frogger with 1 route.  There is no choice of where to go when there is only one possible route that you can "ghost" with.  And even then, it's only a matter of time until you will HAVE to get into a firefight.

No, you're wrong. Watch my videos when they're out (for most of the missions anyway, this isn't the case in the tutorial level for example, or the mission in Iraq).

Merchant's Street Market, Full Stealth (Realistic Difficulty)
Kobin's Mansion, Full Stealth Part 1 (Realistic Difficulty)
Kobin's Mansion, Full Stealth Part 2 (Realistic Difficulty)

Farley4Fan

What do you mean I'm wrong?  You even said that you have to memorize the dark spots before.  You never had to do that in CT.  You could always improvise and now you HAVE to plan a perfect route like frogger.  You could probably ghost through a few dungeons in Oblivion by memorizing dark spots/enemy movement, but you don't see anyone praising that stealth system ever.

Farley4Fan

Well I've been suspended for a week at ubi for apparently insulting people.  I say I was merely calling them what their parents should have named them, hardly insulting.

I went there to rant about how terrible Face Off is.  I'll do it here to get it out of my system.

I joined a random game with a random guy on realistic.  The game was laggy as all shit.  I still beat this guy to a pulp in this laughably bad "game mode" by like 20 kills for 2 rounds.  Then, near the end of the 3rd round which turned into a frag fest, I was up by about 15 kills.  Yay, I got it in the bag, right?  Nope.  He leaves.  I get no credit for winning.  That's nearly 15 minutes completely wasted.

I join a different game with a different guy.  Laggy again.  Again I beat him 2 rounds, then almost win the third round, and he leaves before it ends.

The game is just a random frag-fest.  It lags like crazy and the frame rate drops all the time.  When the 2 players try to kill eachother up close it becomes a button mashing fest and it is random whoever wins.  Cool.  There is no strategy involved in this.  None.

This game has next to zero amount of replayability.  That is, unless you want to play through the single player or coop multiple times, but I don't.  I beat them both on realistic easily and very quickly.  The "versus" is so terribly bad that I can't imagine ANYONE playing it more than 2 or 3 times. 

It's all the same thing over and over again in every single game mode.  Get in the room, clear the room or try to ghost the room, rinse and repeat.  There is absolutely no variety in this game.  It feels like it was thrown together in like 8 months. 

VaNilla

Quote from: FarleyFan on April 17, 2010, 09:52:50 PM
What do you mean I'm wrong?  You even said that you have to memorize the dark spots before.  You never had to do that in CT.  You could always improvise and now you HAVE to plan a perfect route like frogger.  You could probably ghost through a few dungeons in Oblivion by memorizing dark spots/enemy movement, but you don't see anyone praising that stealth system ever.

I said you had to in the demo, not in the full game. I've even mentioned that the game's black and white filter is problematic, but I had no trouble distinguishing between light and shadow in the final game. There is usually more than one route to full stealth, but not all of the time. That is why I think you're wrong.

Farley4Fan

The game funnels you into chokepoints at every turn so you are forced into either going full assault or sort of fudging your way through with stealth.  The point is that I can't stand the red light/green light stealth system. It started with DA with removal of the meters.  Either you are completely visible or you are completely invisible.  COMPLETELY lame.  And now it seems that the enemies are completely deaf. 

Farley4Fan

My review... :)


I'm a huge fan of the Splinter Cell series. I've been there since day one. I've played Pandora Tomorrow and Chaos Theory's Spy versus Mercenary game mode for hundreds of hours. Here is an honest review from a fan:

For those of you who are looking for a quick game to play and finish, your search is over. This is it.

Story:

The story of ConViction is decent. Some of the twists are well done but unfortunately a lot of the impact of the events do not stir much emotion. It starts off as a search for the answers to the questions Sam has for his daughter and eventually he gets his answers. Unfortunately, the events that follow are unsatisfying and poorly written. There are almost too many organizations and individual bad guys to keep track of and it gets fairly jumbled. There are also a few plot holes that you will probably notice.

The characters, on the other hand, are fairly high quality. The voice acting is solid throughout and some of the new characters are convincing in the Splinter Cell universe. Michael Ironside is great as Sam, as always.

7/10

Graphics:

Graphics aren't a huge priority for me but they do help immerse the player in the experience. The graphics are pretty good but are held back by some bland textures and the low resolution. The black and white filter (when hidden) is not only bad for gameplay, but it hides the sheen of the great looking environments.

The projected text became a bit annoying after a while and personally I thought it was the opposite of immersive. It reminded me that I was playing a game and seemed a bit goofy. I'm sure a lot of other people don't feel this way though.

Gameplay:

The controls are a bit awkward. Contextual controls are a bit wonky. There is a place in the coop campaign where you have to board a helicopter. You push the A button to do this. For some reason they put a railing right underneath the helicopter. So, instead of boarding the helicopter when pushing A, you jump over the railing. My partner and I were killed multiple times in this section due to simple design flaws.

The new additions to the gameplay aren't too good. I can't really comment on Mark and Execute since I refused to use it during the campaign. The last known position (or "Ghost Sam") can be annoying. It completely takes you out of the zone and reminds you that you are playing a video game. I do not know why they had to have this visual sign of being undetected.

The stealth system has been completely neutered. There is no complexity to how well hidden you are. Either you are hidden, or you are not. It's black and white (literally). Often times I would think I was hidden, move a mere inch, and then become completely visible to the enemy. The enemies can hardly hear you and they never hear you if you are crouching. This over simplification of the stealth system that the first 3 games nearly perfected was a terrible move for this franchise and a complete cutting of its roots.

Don't be fooled, this is hardly a stealth game. It is now an action game with stealth elements, and, if you memorize the dark spots, it gives you a slight opportunity to sneak past enemies. However, there will be points where you are literally forced to shoot people. There are points where stealth is nowhere near a viable option. In my opinion, since stealth is pretty unorthodox, this makes it less of a stealth game than an action game.

Not only is it an action game, it is a relatively easy and SHORT action game. I played it on realistic difficulty on both the single and multiplayer campaigns. I easily defeated both within 4-5 hours a piece. This is why you MUST rent the game. The replayability is also low.

But despite all these issues there is some good fun to be had. The interrogations can be pretty fun, stalking your enemy before pouncing on him from above and then grabbing his buddy right after, it's a good game overall. It's just too easy, too short, and too repetitive. Damn good rent, damn terrible buy.

8/10

Multiplayer:

I'll make this section quick since I've already written so much.

It is not even close to a good replacement for what came before in previous titles. Face off doesn't hold a candle to Spy vs Merc. The gameplay is identical in single player, coop, and "versus" (if you can call it that). Coop is single player with 2 guys, and versus is coop without cooperation.

I did have some fun with the coop but the boredom quickly set in after the 3rd or the 4 quick missions in the game. The coop campaign gave some backstory to the events of the single player, but naturally people will beat the main game before the prologue coop campaign. It seems awkward.

6/10

Conclusion:

This game is a step in the wrong direction for the series. It is becoming too simple, using too much action, so shallow, and full of gimmicks. I really, really hope they go back to the roots of the series and bring some of the things that worked with Conviction. This doesn't make it terrible though, it's good, but not great.

To enjoy it for what it is then you need to come in with low expectations and the realization that this is simply not a splinter cell game.

This is a quick game with quick gameplay and a quick lifespan. It is my recommendation that you do not buy it. There is little that will keep you busy afterwards. Rent it.

7.5/10

VaNilla

To let you guys know; I've made a breakthrough :). Almost the full length of the Iraq level can be done using Full Stealth; I've recorded myself reference clips of each part without being detected, so I can make a full playthrough soon; stay tuned :).

tigaer

Quote from: STON3COLDKILLA on May 01, 2010, 09:42:45 PM
To let you guys know; I've made a breakthrough :). Almost the full length of the Iraq level can be done using Full Stealth; I've recorded myself reference clips of each part without being detected, so I can make a full playthrough soon; stay tuned :).

I've ran through an entire level on Halo 1, Call of Duty 4 and Halo 3 without being seen. Still doesn't make it a stealth game.

VaNilla

Yes, but this is clearly more stealth orientated than those games you have mentioned. Just recorded it, will render and upload as soon as I can :).

Farley4Fan

Like Tigaer said, I'd rather not fudge my way through a level just to say it's possible.

I can ghost some of the dungeons/factories on Oblivion/Fallout.  Are they stealth games because they have a stealth element?