merc confusion gadget

Started by Gawain, February 05, 2008, 01:47:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

AgentX_003

Quote from: mentalmars on February 11, 2008, 01:36:52 PM
how many of you got set on the wrong path by a alarm snare?

i thing many ppl always look first when the indicator says that there's movement coming for a direction.
after a few seconds you discover that it's a alarm snare
1) you ignore the signal
2) you remove the snare

Looking at the hologram.
if you pick up a small glimes of a spy going somewhere you always try to engage him
or look where he is going to cut him of.
i think this is a good way to create a opritunitie

it does need a easy setup.
something like click point 'A' click point 'B' and it moves from  A to B

suggestions a way to set up your own way point (for A -> B -> C -> D)

a other suggestion is fixed waypoints at corners
if you let your hologram walk to the end of a room it wil automaticly walk around the corner.

Let a hologram fade out when ending animation, like a spy is using his camosuit

the only thing is  the holo pod should be the size of a dime for portablity / makes it harder for the merc to find.


-Thanks Murdy for da Sig <3  xD

Farley4Fan

With 5 slots new gadgets are needed.  If not, you could just take most of the gadgets, and that's stupid.

mentalmars

#137
Quote from: AgentX_003 on February 11, 2008, 03:20:29 PM
Quote from: mentalmars on February 11, 2008, 01:36:52 PM

the only thing is  the holo pod should be the size of a dime for portablity / makes it harder for the merc to find.

i think the pod should not be visable
you are trying to fool a merc.
if you see a huge disc flying as merc, would you be foold by it.


i only use the word pod so it's a device that creates the image
creating a hologram out of thin air would be difficelt ;)

Farley4Fan


Ion.67

You think it's a good gadget, I think it has no good qualities. We both have opinions.

There is nothing to suggest to make it better. It has absolutely no potential or use, and I don't like it. Go ahead and keep defending it, but I don't like it.

Don't try and tell us to think of ways to make it better, because this idea has no possibility of becoming better. People become used to things, just like the snare, so this would quickly become useless.

Vega

This is getting a little out of hand and becoming ridiculous.  It appears that a lot of you accept gadget ideas just for the sake of adding new gadgets.  The whole idea of having this hologram do all of these things is just plain stupid.  Either change the way the hologram works or just drop the idea entirely. 

Mimicking human action is going to be really tough, unless we record HUNDREDS of different moving patterns to make this shitty gadget more believable.  These moving patterns will have to involve lots of different animations or people will recognize a hologram too quickly and render this gadget useless.  Not only does that sound like a huge waste of time and effort, but simply idiotic when the team has to do a hell of a lot more before this mod ever sees release.

Westfall

Quote from: Vega on February 12, 2008, 05:25:32 AM
This is getting a little out of hand and becoming ridiculous.  It appears that a lot of you accept gadget ideas just for the sake of adding new gadgets.  The whole idea of having this hologram do all of these things is just plain stupid.  Either change the way the hologram works or just drop the idea entirely. 

Mimicking human action is going to be really tough, unless we record HUNDREDS of different moving patterns to make this shitty gadget more believable.  These moving patterns will have to involve lots of different animations or people will recognize a hologram too quickly and render this gadget useless.  Not only does that sound like a huge waste of time and effort, but simply idiotic when the team has to do a hell of a lot more before this mod ever sees release.

You must not have read the past few pages, so I'm not going to delve back in.

Welcome to a forum, where ideas are being posted because we don't have much else to talk about. You are seeing varying opinion here because its....a forum. The team does have much to do still, but that doesn't mean we cease all discussion. There are other threads. This thread you have obviously not read that much because everything is clearly stated. You either like it or don't like it. Doesn't mean you have to come in on a high horse and say "THEEZ THINGS AR3 B4D B3C4US3 M41 0P1N1ON FTVV!!!"


Vega

Hey now, I gave a reason behind my "this idea is stupid" so YOU JUST WATCH YOUR MOUTH, WESTFALL.  DUN GIVE ME ANY LIP 'FOR I RECKON I GON BEAT YOU AGAIN, BOY.

frvge

Keep the sclamers stuff at sclamers please.
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

Farley4Fan

Quote from: Vega on February 12, 2008, 07:31:05 AM
Hey now, I gave a reason behind my "this idea is stupid" so YOU JUST WATCH YOUR MOUTH, WESTFALL.  DUN GIVE ME ANY LIP 'FOR I RECKON I GON BEAT YOU AGAIN, BOY.

Reasons that have no meaning if you look back at the previous pages.  This wouldn't take much work.  No more than how much time optic camo takes to make probably.

Cyntrox

Quote from: Ion.67 on February 12, 2008, 04:55:07 AM
You think it's a good gadget, I think it has no good qualities. We both have opinions.

There is nothing to suggest to make it better. It has absolutely no potential or use, and I don't like it. Go ahead and keep defending it, but I don't like it.

Don't try and tell us to think of ways to make it better, because this idea has no possibility of becoming better. People become used to things, just like the snare, so this would quickly become useless.
Good work! This was such an intelligent and thought-through argument, I must worship your intellect. What have you done to grace the earth with such heavenly reason and, not to mention, common sense?

mentalmars

we dont al have to agree with all the gadgets.
some pll like to take the spy bullet other choose the hartbeat sensor becase it doesnt limit you to 5 scans
but the bullet has other +Points
i dont see the point of a photonic granade, why not just shoot a normal granade.
a buddy of mine loves flares, i dont see why.
But hey if it works for him.

everyone likes different things
everyone likes to take different gadgets becase the one or the other will fit him better.
the gadgets just need to work.
When i started playing SCCT when it came out everyone wanted the camosuit and a pack of granades
no one used the alarmsnare, but i did and very effectively becase no one played that way anymore.
playing styles change.
yes after a few games you know where most ppl place there mines
but then ppl start placing them on other spots.

the same will be for the hologram
at first you will be foold, after a few weeks you know a bit better.
then thing start to shift ....

Spekkio

Quote from: Vega on February 12, 2008, 05:25:32 AM
This is getting a little out of hand and becoming ridiculous.  It appears that a lot of you accept gadget ideas just for the sake of adding new gadgets.  The whole idea of having this hologram do all of these things is just plain stupid.  Either change the way the hologram works or just drop the idea entirely. 

Mimicking human action is going to be really tough, unless we record HUNDREDS of different moving patterns to make this shitty gadget more believable.  These moving patterns will have to involve lots of different animations or people will recognize a hologram too quickly and render this gadget useless.  Not only does that sound like a huge waste of time and effort, but simply idiotic when the team has to do a hell of a lot more before this mod ever sees release.
Vega is wise.

Quote from: Papa Skull on February 12, 2008, 07:56:29 AMReasons that have no meaning if you look back at the previous pages.  This wouldn't take much work.  No more than how much time optic camo takes to make probably.
Are you a programmer? A modeller? Anyone on the PS team?

If you answered "no" to all of the above, you should stfu about how much time it would take to implement something.

Cyntrox

Mines are a good example of how it would work.

It's a huge beeping, flashing thing on the wall that does literally nothing to hide its presence - yet people keep using them and people keep dying on them. Even though the locations are all used to death.

Farley4Fan

Good example.  And Spekkio, I don't have to be a dev to predict how long something would take.  I can predict all I would like.  And think about it, all the game has to do is render a recording of a spy moving.  The thing that projects the hologram would look just like a spy bullet.  So, that's already done.  Not much work I can see, any dev want to elaborate on how much work this would take?

People won't become used to it, how you come to that conclusion is beyond me Vega.  It looks just like a spy.  EXACT.  You won't be able to tell apart a hologram from a real spy at first glance, no matter who you are, or what graphics card you have.  Yet, somehow you predict that people would just see it and know that it isn't real?
Nope, doesn't work that way Vega.