As chaff would in reality not affect some of the things it does in CT (Which has always bugged me) it had me thinking, and the one thing that would scramble all electronics would be an EM Pulse. This would also allow for a fun visual effect unlike the boring old chaff floating in the air. Mild distortion wave emitted from the grenade every second or so would be not completely realistic but pretty neat looking and serve the purpose of visually defining the affected area. Granted EMP usually permanently fries electronics but let's just say for the sake of argument that it's a weak device with limited area of effect and no real ability to permanently damage electronics.
But then it should take down the mercs hud just like a hs with the tazer...
Chaff used to do that in PT.
I like the idea. It could replace chaff one-on-one. Saves us legal things in naming. yay.
Chaff is awesome pretty if you look closely. An UE3 verison of chaff would be something I'd look forward to.
And it would still work through walls, YAY!!!
Quote from: Kok4f4n on August 24, 2007, 09:54:37 PM
But then it should take down the mercs hud just like a hs with the tazer...
As far as explaining it, you can think of all kinds of weird explanations. Maybe the merc's armor has EMP shielding or countermeasures.
It's a sci-fi game where people have a special bodysuit that turns them transparent. I mean wtf?
Things don't have to be 100% logical or realistic, it's just a game and we make choices for balance reasons.
don't forget the coolness factor!
Well camo suits exist. Of course not in civil, but think what we have, and what the army has.
Quote from: Kok4f4n on August 25, 2007, 01:41:10 AM
Well camo suits exist. Of course not in civil, but think what we have, and what the army has.
Who told you that one?
They do exist (camo suits), but they cost A LOT OF MONEY... How it works is there are REALLY small monitors that also have cameras in them. The suit is embedded with A LOT of the the little monitors with cameras installed. Each camera broacasts a little picture of what it sees on the other side of the suit in one of the little monitors directly across from it. This gives it the illusion that you are seeing what is on the other side of the person wearing the suit, but you are actually just watching pretty much a video of what the cameras see on the other side of the suit. VERY VERY HIGH TECH, really hard to explain. It doesn't make you completely invisible of course, but it works really well in shadows and in jungle areas.
Anyways I think the EMP grenade would be better than chaff. It would have to be a cool noise like a wave sound or electric pulse kind of sound. I suppose this would also help with copyright issues about naming of the gadgets. Was it just me or did chaff look like a bunch of little white rockets? ???
i'd say combine the effects of emp and chaff. the aluminium snippets in the air cause the lasting effect, and the emp kicks in right at the explosion with a larger radius, shuts down the hud and makes lights jitter or something like this.
removing the snippets would cause some balance issues as the merc can't see a possibly bypassed mine, for example museum exe vent mine.
Well he can't see it's bypassed if he's not there. And of what i figured the emp nade will make some hot airwaves or something?
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 25, 2007, 02:30:14 AM
They do exist (camo suits), but they cost A LOT OF MONEY... How it works is there are REALLY small monitors that also have cameras in them. The suit is embedded with A LOT of the the little monitors with cameras installed. Each camera broacasts a little picture of what it sees on the other side of the suit in one of the little monitors directly across from it. This gives it the illusion that you are seeing what is on the other side of the person wearing the suit, but you are actually just watching pretty much a video of what the cameras see on the other side of the suit. VERY VERY HIGH TECH, really hard to explain. It doesn't make you completely invisible of course, but it works really well in shadows and in jungle areas.
Anyways I think the EMP grenade would be better than chaff. It would have to be a cool noise like a wave sound or electric pulse kind of sound. I suppose this would also help with copyright issues about naming of the gadgets. Was it just me or did chaff look like a bunch of little white rockets? ???
I want to see a camo suit. hhmmm...I like the idea of an EMP nade btw.
i like the idea of combining emp and chaff, so that emp can be used like a flashbang against visions/hud in medium distance. flickering lights would also add to the athmosphere. but chaff shouldn't work through walls gameplay-wise, at least not thrown with quickdrop.
If was thinking on having some kind of waves emitted after it's detonated that last for the chaff-time. The grenade shell is never shown during that period tho, just like it is now.
Or:
What if the EMP goes through walls and does all the 'work' in disabling stuff, and the chaff is for visuals? Difference with above is that you see the chaff-particles instead of the EMP pulses. I do think that the EMP pulses look more high-tech and have a larger coolness factor, so I personally prefer the first listed option.
you can't see an "emp pulse"
who cares, it's not realistic.
:P
I was actually thinking of having the grenade stay where it was shot/thrown and be the emission source for the distortion waves. I had thought about having it shaped like a capsule and it sort of "telescopes" open to reveal emitter ribs when activated. Anyhow, chaff if you get real close looks like tons of little bow ties in my opinion. Hate the stuff.
oh and yes, the camo suit does exist, if you have a few billion for one. Chump change imo :P
Quote from: Gawain on August 25, 2007, 03:18:24 PM
you can't see an "emp pulse"
Chaff doesn't stay suspended in the air for 20 seconds either. Something like a constant heat wave distortion in the affected area could be used as well so it's constantly visible and you wouldn't risk glancing over between "pulses" and miss seeing it.
the snippets used to create the emp blast could fall to the ground and stay there.
I don't like EMP just because it's been in almost every game set in my lifetime.
? Name one where it's implemented like the way we want it here.
Chaff was also in MGS btw.
EMP destroys/disables electronics. Isn't that how it's always implemented? That's enough for me.
You know it's bad when wikipedia has it's own section on it (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_pulse_in_fiction#Games)
I actually wonder if chaff would be a bit better if we made it less visible. I mean we've been talking about giving chaff a boost... maybe making it unseen or harder to see would be a nice improvement.
so the mec can see it, make it like the flash on da, just except a blue smoke cloud.
would be perfect.
yeah chaff needs a little boost, especially if we won't make it work through walls any longer.
i suggest two boosts:
-let it make an emp boost with larger radius when exploding that kicks mercs out of vision modes and makes the lights flickering
-let the snippets slowly fall to the ground so that they can't be seen well for some less seconds
Quote from: Gawain on August 25, 2007, 10:52:18 PM
yeah chaff needs a little boost, especially if we won't make it work through walls any longer.
i suggest two boosts:
-let it make an emp boost with larger radius when exploding that kicks mercs out of vision modes and makes the lights flickering
-let the snippets slowly fall to the ground so that they can't be seen well for some less seconds
What if we made chaff just an instantaneous EMP explosion instead of a linger effect.
It'd make it easier to disable defenses stealthfully because you couldn't necessarily see the chaff (but you'd still hear it detonate), also against a merc, if you chaffed him, the effect would linger for some time, instead of just working while you were inside the chaff cloud, so getting hit by a chaff grenade would be a bit more serious.
Well i don't think that an emp bomb can be heard...
It sure can, it sounds like a wave kind of sound.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 26, 2007, 12:13:16 AM
It sure can, it sounds like a wave kind of sound.
Quote from: Kok4f4n on August 25, 2007, 11:40:00 PM
Well i don't think that an emp bomb can be heard...
plz stfu if you have no idea how an emp bomb works. emp bombs use an ordinary explosion to quickly move away charged particles ("capacitor plates") or compress a magnetic field.
You hear a minor explosion, then you hear a kind of wave sound ( the field or particles setting up ) correct?
You would think the thing that creates the EMP would make sound, not the EMP itself. There are two ways EMP works, it either emits (leaks out) or it explodes. Grenades tend to do the latter (even smoke, apparently). And explosions make noise.
leaks out????
it just makes "BUUUUUM"
Yeah, it leaks out. EMP is energy and just like any other energy, you would think it would be emitted. When we master EMP to the point that it can be created by a grenade, I would think contain electronics with a EMP generator that produces the energy like a radio rather than a result of a chemical process that produces explosions (probably of a nuclear variety).
an emitter would have to be very very strong and do the whole spectrum of frequencies to destroy electronics.
A very strong emitter we can someday do. An explosion that generates EMP but doesn't destroy the entire building is breaking the laws of physics. This is why I like chaff, it doesn't make sense so we can't have these kinds of discussions but believable enough that you could think it's some kind of weird science that your mommy never taught you.
What if spies were in the electro magnetic field or pulse as well? Wouldn't it like short circuit their gun or their NVG? And yes, the bummm sound was the kind of wave sound I was thinking of. It is just like bummmm mmmmm mmmmmm in a wave pattern.
That would be interesting if chaff worked on spies as well wouldn't it? Not exactly saying it should be added at all, but it would be interesting.
no. we don't wanna alter the gameplay too much.
Honestly, I could care less how EMP "really works". This is a game where we fire microcameras out of gun that can fire sleep gas. It's also a game where there's a suit that turns people invisible, and somehow you can detect spies with a magic laser.
Stuff doesn't have to work like it does in real life. It's a game and stuff works how we want it to work for balance purposes. And that's it.
Quote from: Gawain on August 27, 2007, 12:42:21 AM
no. we don't wanna alter the gameplay too much.
How long would you say that you spend your time right in the middle of a chaff grenade? I personally don't really like to because I would easily be detected. How exactly would this alter the gameplay too much, being that most spies don't spend their time right in the middle of a chaff grenade? I think it would be nice to see your night vision get all fuzzy when you are standing in chaff that would turn anything else fuzzy.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 27, 2007, 02:01:20 AM
Quote from: Gawain on August 27, 2007, 12:42:21 AM
no. we don't wanna alter the gameplay too much.
How long would you say that you spend your time right in the middle of a chaff grenade? I personally don't really like to because I would easily be detected. How exactly would this alter the gameplay too much, being that most spies don't spend their time right in the middle of a chaff grenade? I think it would be nice to see your night vision get all fuzzy when you are standing in chaff that would turn anything else fuzzy.
dude you just proved my point again that you totally overrate your skills. if spies aggro a merc with smoke and chaff in close combat, they need their thermal view in order to see any more than the merc does.
(of course, the merc can counter this by charging out of the chaff radius and switching to blue vision; just to stop the flaming on aggro tactics...)
Only a fucking idiot would go aggro with chaff and not a flashbang. And just like you said a merc can charge out of the chaff, and hey, so can the spy! Maybe he needs to rethink what the hell he is doing before he throws a chaff and smoke at a merc before he actually does it. A smart spy wouldn't even want to confront a merc, but if he had to he should use flash and smoke. Any retarded spy can run around and throw his chaff or smoke and go " hEy My ThErMaL nO wOrKIng? ", maybe it is about time spies thought about what they were doing before they run around mercs. Smokes and flashes shouldn't work on spies because that would effect gameplay waay too much. But chaff should definately screw with the spy's HUD or something.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 27, 2007, 05:28:38 AM
Only a fucking idiot would go aggro with chaff and not a flashbang.
Ummm... ever been triple naded?
Well umm, duh? But why would you chaff someone instead of flashing someone? You read it totally wrong.
chaffing someone is in close combat it something totally common; chaff needs a little boost, not a nerf anyway.
...are you guys arguing over three threads?
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on August 27, 2007, 01:48:43 AM
Stuff doesn't have to work like it does in real life. It's a game and stuff works how we want it to work for balance purposes. And that's it.
I'm not saying this for the sake of reality. But it may affect a gamer's experince because EMP has been overused so lots of people know what EMP is, how it's made and how it doesn't make sense, even in the future's advanced technology. Chaff doesn't make sense so no one knows how it works but it would seem believeable. Isn't that partly why people love Spinter Cell? Because they love
new ideas of future technology, not the same EMP grenade we've seen for years.
We should give the merc a airsoft gun then. rifles and bullets are in 100x more games than EMP grenades. As a matter of fact, I don't know of a game with EMP grenades. Granted I don't play a huge variety of games but I've never seen one. It seems like a relatively un-used idea when compared to mines, remote charges, frags, rifles, shotguns, uzis etc etc.
good points.
there is a lot of emp stuff in bf2142 btw
game play wise emp=chaff
for project stealth= grenades need to be visible so the merc knows what and where
name wise, we can use emp for the sake of differance....but it has to maintain the visibility of chaff. How is up to our effects programmer.
spies, as a rule are not effected by there grenades -that includes smoke and cams
and Personally: I think we really need chaff to go through walls. CT has some damned clever mine spots that are impossible to get passed even with this feature. (storage in Orph, vents in Factory). If we nerfed chaff like this, you would realistically see the amount of impassable areas from mines and spytraps double.
Also, if we called it EMP, it would be somewhat credible that it could go through walls.
And finally, EMP exists already : Nuclear Bomb, and Lightning disable electronics.
The storage poisons are impassable even with chaff in its current state, plus they're extremely far from a healthbox. That's what makes them so good (glad I originated those :)).
The factory mines are all passable without chaff going through walls.
There isn't one trap in the game that, if placed by the host so the laser goes straight, will suddenly be changed from passable to impassible if chaff stopped going through walls. Furthermore, your teammate can remove poison/traps anyway, which already diminishes their usefulness by a lot.
If you need to nerf the trap laser length back to PT's distance to compensate, then do so (this might make the impassible poisons in Storage unusable, btw). Chaff going through walls is too powerful and allows the spies to move way too quickly. There's no reason for anyone to want chaff to go through walls unless they feel that the spies should be able to run around the map virtually unimpeded. If you believe that, then we just disagree on a fundamental level.
ADDED: Just in case someone wants to throw the "EMP isn't stopped by walls" argument...if you are saying that, then you are saying that EMP grenades need to shut down every single electrical device in the map when thrown anywhere, including the spy equipment, until it wears off. In this case, gameplay must trump realism.
I really think that having an emp grenade would be a great addition for project stealth, while still including Chaff grenades. They might do the same thing, except for game play reasons you change it a little.
Chaff: Does what it's always done, but not through walls. the end.
EMP: does what chaff does, but affects spies, goes through walls but is silent. How do you see it would be a cool heat like light wave ripples through the air. I've seen the effect in other games, so I see no reason not to apply it here.
While looking at photos from UT3 and of our wonderful spy model, we have to make sure that the levels, and effects are just as cool and spectacular looking. Going from CT versus, to our Versus will be one hell of a jump.
Well apparently everyone hates the chaff effect and name (we should take a poll) for reasons that are beyond me (I still think it's a great idea). But if we're going to replace it, it would be nice to replace the name with something vague (like the less used name, ECM) and leave the team to come up with some kind of strange unique effect. The kind of effect where you don't know exactly what it does but looks very cool.
Either that or we put in some creativity. The gamer in me is just getting sick of seeing EMP in anything that has to do with fighting microchips. I'm also getting bored of GTA clones...
i like the chaff effect.
no1 had any problems with the pt chaff nades, they didn't work through walls but had a much larger radius. i like the idea that you have to pull your gun out and shoot a chaff in a room (slower), but after doing so you were completely safe from any security and mines in it.
Having chaff and EMP nades is redundant, even if they have *slightly* different features. If new gadgets are to be added, I'd prefer that they be a bit more original than that.
I have no qualms with the current chaff name or gfx effect, but would presume both would be updated both for the sake of originality and risk of copyright infringement.
How about you drop it, a blue ring explosion ensues from the source of the grenade outwards to it's max radius, and then have some sort of effect that lingers until the grenade wears off?
Yeah, if a new gadget doesn't have enough unique features to make it a significant addition to the game, then it's not worth the trouble of coding its graphics and animations.
As far as chaff going through walls, I can think of a few good reasons why they should:
Even if chaff doesn't go through walls, we need it to burst out around walls. nobody wants to detonate a chaff only to be destroyed by a mine that happened to be a little niche because the chaff didn't have a direct LoS to the mine. It's going to be difficult to code chaff properly to burst around walls in a fashion that works. Imagine one of those glitch mines that's inside a wall, and imagine if the chaff spread algorithm doesn't accurately penetrate wherever it happens to be hidden. You chaff, you run in thinking you're okay and the boom. A mine that happened to evade the chaff field blows you to pieces.
It's simply easier to code chaff as a wall piercing radius effect, because then you're certain that it disables all mines in its area.
as spekkio and me already stated several times, chaff working through walls totally takes away the anti rush aspect of mines.
That's nice but don't go around saying it like there has been an official annoucement that we're going to change chaff. That's why I got confused. Maybe you can make a thread about it if there isn't already one.
I haven't been talking about adding a new grenade. I thought no one liked chaff and wanted it replaced with something else that works exactly the same.
QuoteEven if chaff doesn't go through walls, we need it to burst out around walls. nobody wants to detonate a chaff only to be destroyed by a mine that happened to be a little niche because the chaff didn't have a direct LoS to the mine. It's going to be difficult to code chaff properly to burst around walls in a fashion that works. Imagine one of those glitch mines that's inside a wall, and imagine if the chaff spread algorithm doesn't accurately penetrate wherever it happens to be hidden. You chaff, you run in thinking you're okay and the boom. A mine that happened to evade the chaff field blows you to pieces.
This is a "I think the spies should be able to run around freely if they take chaff" argument in disguise, since that's the only time you'd be using the quick-throw to get around a mine on the other side of a wall. For proxies you can just crawl and save your chaffs for something else; for lasers you will have to shoot the chaff anyway since the mine isn't going to be right next to the doorway.
Anyway, if they program the game properly then you won't have to worry about these glitches. Saying that something shouldn't be implemented because it might not work right is a poor argument, since everything has a possibility of malfunctioning.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 27, 2007, 06:27:09 PMADDED: Just in case someone wants to throw the "EMP isn't stopped by walls" argument...if you are saying that, then you are saying that EMP grenades need to shut down every single electrical device in the map when thrown anywhere, including the spy equipment, until it wears off. In this case, gameplay must trump realism.
Not every EMP device is powerful enough to knock out a whole map or city as you see in movies. Like any bomb/grenade/emitter it has a "blast" radius determined by its payload or the amount of power behind the discharge. It's not really a question of realism but a question of what people think would serve the purpose of chaff but look and sound better. Like with any fictional item it only needs to be loosely based on reality and then artistic liberties can be taken.
So, the question is, which do you think is more visually appealing? A bunch of bow-tie sparkles in the air or something an artist can freely create a top-notch next gen effect for?
the chaff effect can be done "next-gen", too.
Quote from: Gawain on August 28, 2007, 01:35:45 AM
the chaff effect can be done "next-gen", too.
Yes it could be but the fact remains that chaff is... well... chaff. It is limited in its appearance in many more ways than other options. IMO anyhow.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 28, 2007, 01:13:30 AM
This is a "I think the spies should be able to run around freely if they take chaff" argument in disguise, since that's the only time you'd be using the quick-throw to get around a mine on the other side of a wall. For proxies you can just crawl and save your chaffs for something else; for lasers you will have to shoot the chaff anyway since the mine isn't going to be right next to the doorway.
Well, I could see the argument if people just wanted to say that chaff doesn't work on proxies at all, but I figure if it can disable prox then throwing a grenade down at the entrance to a place should get the mine. You shouldn't be constantly guessing if your chaff is going to work or not, or it will make it a big pain. Chaff really has to spread around walls, otherwise you'll find it crazy difficult to chaff some mines that happen to be protected by cover.
A complex 3D spread algorithm is going to be tough to code. Given the small design team, it's probably easier just to say it goes through walls.
Coding concerns may not exactly sound like great arguments but for this project I think they're certainly valid. The game will be worthless if it's never finished.
"takes progamming time" is a quite weak point...
Quote from: Gawain on August 28, 2007, 10:09:29 PM
"takes progamming time" is a quite weak point...
Not when you've got a small design team it's not.
Seriously, every change we put into this game, the design team has to ask itself: is it worth the trouble to code/animate?
Quote from: Gawain on August 28, 2007, 10:09:29 PM
"takes progamming time" is a quite weak point...
Despite what some people think, we only have 2 amateur programmers without 3D engine experience, and some advisors who dont have the correct hardware to run UE3.
You'd have a point if we had 10 fulltime, experienced programmers. Now, every feature we put in, will take long and needs to be weighted carefully. Of course, we have the plus that there isn't a deadline ;) But to have you wait for 6 months just because we need to think of that chaff-around-wall-algorithm... meh.
Quote from: frvge on August 28, 2007, 11:46:22 PM
some advisors who dont have the correct hardware to run UE3.
My new role is code quality control. I take all your messed up code and rewrite it to be more understandable/proper/less buggy. Perfect role for me since I have the most practical programming experince (?) and am critical of things to the point of perfectionism. Changing code introduces less bugs (which is a big problem for someone who can't debug) than if I created something.
Quote from: B1nArY_001 on August 27, 2007, 04:46:19 PM
We should give the merc a airsoft gun then. rifles and bullets are in 100x more games than EMP grenades. As a matter of fact, I don't know of a game with EMP grenades. Granted I don't play a huge variety of games but I've never seen one. It seems like a relatively un-used idea when compared to mines, remote charges, frags, rifles, shotguns, uzis etc etc.
I am pretty sure that Sam Fisher had EMP grenades in SP mode of DA. When he threw one, there was a little electric sound after a little pop sound.
IIRC, Chaff in PT didn't affect proxies. I could be wrong though.
However, again there is little point in using a chaff at a doorway to disable a mine unless you are running very quickly.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 29, 2007, 04:47:54 AM
However, again there is little point in using a chaff at a doorway to disable a mine unless you are running very quickly.
Well of course, but if you're using a chaff instead of sneaking in more stealthfully, chances are it is a rush of some kind. Chaffs make quite a bit of noise. You really need to move quick after dropping a chaff, because the merc is coming.
Not to mention they have white particles floating around. I think that EMP grenades would be more useful depending on how it is made.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on August 27, 2007, 11:41:27 PM
Yeah, if a new gadget doesn't have enough unique features to make it a significant addition to the game, then it's not worth the trouble of coding its graphics and animations.
As far as chaff going through walls, I can think of a few good reasons why they should:
Even if chaff doesn't go through walls, we need it to burst out around walls. nobody wants to detonate a chaff only to be destroyed by a mine that happened to be a little niche because the chaff didn't have a direct LoS to the mine. It's going to be difficult to code chaff properly to burst around walls in a fashion that works. Imagine one of those glitch mines that's inside a wall, and imagine if the chaff spread algorithm doesn't accurately penetrate wherever it happens to be hidden. You chaff, you run in thinking you're okay and the boom. A mine that happened to evade the chaff field blows you to pieces.
It's simply easier to code chaff as a wall piercing radius effect, because then you're certain that it disables all mines in its area.
Here is the flaw in your argument. Making chaffs work through walls because of possible glitch mines is NOT a good design decision. If there is a glitch mine, the glitch should be fixed. End of story. You shouldn't tweak the gadgets to allow people to continue to use the glitch because it is still possible to chaff it and take it out. A glitch is still a glitch.
Now, as for programming time for something like this, yes, I can see that being an issue. If it comes down to having to make them work through walls because of programming limitations and not wanting this to take years (I'd like to at least playing something related to this in 2008) then I can live with that. Chaffs work through walls in CT, so it won't be a huge earth-shattering change if they have to do it in PS.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on August 29, 2007, 05:57:29 AM
Quote from: Spekkio on August 29, 2007, 04:47:54 AM
However, again there is little point in using a chaff at a doorway to disable a mine unless you are running very quickly.
Well of course, but if you're using a chaff instead of sneaking in more stealthfully, chances are it is a rush of some kind. Chaffs make quite a bit of noise. You really need to move quick after dropping a chaff, because the merc is coming.
dude, mines are primarily against rushers, not against stealth players.
I use mines as path blocking for stealth players. Slowing them down and requiring them to either remove the mine or shoot it, which in turns reveals that they were there.
that's a quite weak use on most maps. that's what spytraps are for.
One of the most frustrating things about playing seefoo and vantage, one of the best stealth teams to ever play, is that you would spend the first 30 sec planting all your mines and a few minutes later they all vanished. In short, a team who is being careful will never run into mines.
Gawain hit the nail on the head: mines are generally for players who are moving quickly. Chaff going through walls circumvents this. If you believe that should happen, then fine. All this hooplah about "well it protects against glitch mines" and "what if I'm going slow but decide to quick-throw a chaff to wrap around the wall" is retarded. If there is a glitch mine (of which there are many in CT because the laser for clients "bend"), it should be fixed. If you're going slow, how about creeping to take out the mine, or drawing your gun and firing the chaff?
Furthermore, even if you're using the mines to "slow down stealth spies," the fact that chaff goes through walls means that it doesn't slow them down too much, if at all. Quick throw --> remove. Takes all of 2 seconds.
I agree that mines should slow down spies but not because they are hard to disable but are hard to find. You can't chaff something if don't know it's there because you've been running so much. Would you agree that this would work if we continually tweak the sound levels and get rid of EAX?
spies are supposed to know where stuff is. and if you go around suspicous corners, chaffing the next corner is enough if you keep distance to the walls.
EAX is not at fault for spies hearing proxies. With better sound, proxies would probably become even easier to spot. Furthermore, as Gawain said it doesn't take too long to start throwing chaff at doorways /corners whenever you are being chased.
Yeah, I get your point. But it is a trade off between speed and stealth since chaff makes noise and you have a limited amount.
if you're being chased making noise doesn't make a difference.
with chaff going through walls you don't have to make plans and throw a chaff next to the mine, you can react in no time and run around the map way too safely.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 29, 2007, 06:55:45 PM
Furthermore, even if you're using the mines to "slow down stealth spies," the fact that chaff goes through walls means that it doesn't slow them down too much, if at all. Quick throw --> remove. Takes all of 2 seconds.
Well, there are other types of mines that you can place, beyond just the proxy next to a laser.
I mean for instance, getting into greek from the sea tunnel side. You could put a proxy right next to the lasers, that way if someone rolls through they get blown up.
You could also put a poison mine stretching from one of the room's corners.
One forces you to fire a chaff in with your gun, the other can be quick chaffed. And I really don't think it's that bad for the game. I could be wrong, but thus far I haven't really seen any examples of why this makes mines useless. It seems the obvious solution to people quickchaffing mines is to put the mine itself in a place where the spy can't quickchaff it.
you can't put proxy and laser mines in places the spy can't quickchaff them (except some climbing passages)
Doesn't EMP go through walls in real life? If it does it gets weaker through the wall or something like that. I think I remember some kind of video I watched where they sent an EMP through a wall and short-circuited a radio.
sure it does. but it's not emp, it's chaff. and it's not a realistic combat simulation, it's a very unrealistic game.
But since EMP actually goes through walls, why wouldn't we use EMP? How about a chaff EMP combination that does the exact same thing as a EMP/Chaff would do. It works through walls ( explained by EMP ), and the chaff particles are still there for those who want to keep it for balancing issues. Wouldn't this solve all problems?
i'm pretty sure spekkio suggested that on page 3, but it got ignored as it may have been an edit.
I believe I also said that. Or at least I've thought about it.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 29, 2007, 09:46:43 PM
But since EMP actually goes through walls, why wouldn't we use EMP? How about a chaff EMP combination that does the exact same thing as a EMP/Chaff would do. It works through walls ( explained by EMP ), and the chaff particles are still there for those who want to keep it for balancing issues. Wouldn't this solve all problems?
NO FFS. it's about the gameplay, not about effects or realism.
Uh, having Chaff go through the wall didn't affect gameplay too greatly. Rather than, bouncing a nade off the wall they saved 2 seconds by quick droping. While 2 seconds can be long in a game like Versus. It's not gameplay altering.
1. Stop with this realistic bullshit. Realistically a spy can't take a bullets to the chest and leg and proceed to run away full speed, then magically heal his wounds by standing still. So until spies scream like a banshee and crawl into a ball when you shoot them in the thigh with a high-powered rifle, leave the realism arguments out of this.
2. Daybreak, I disagree. Chaff going through walls has a huge effect on gameplay from an aggro standpoint. You don't play aggro one bit, so you probably wouldn't see the difference. The club house garden hopping is one example where chaff through walls allows for something ridiculous. The extra 2 seconds it would take to actually fire the chaff would allow the merc to take the elevator to the previous floor. Alternatively, it'd allow the merc to actually go chase the spy out in garden cuz he can't quickly chaff his way into the map unless he wants to hit the spy trap or anything else you might have waiting for him.
Another example is the ridiculous Museum run around. People often try to place proxies around the cafe to prevent this, but with chaff it doesn't matter. Just throw them at the corners and keep running.
Another example is Aquarius in greek room. Many people place a proxy on the pillar that is on the objective side of the entry door coming from spy spawn. A quick-throw chaff will not only disable the lasers for that doorway, but also magically goes through the pillar and disables that proxy mine completely. The extra 3-5 seconds that would ordinarilly be spent crawling to remove the mine are another 3-5 seconds you have to cover the objective.
And the biggest ridiculous example is Hospital. That map is just ridiculous. I can't remember the last time I lost a spy round on that one with Mr.Mic. The last time we played it, both spy teams won in under 4 minutes. This is largely because one quick-throw chaff disables any mines that you can place near the doorways. Another one a few steps later takes out the rest of the room. You don't have to spend the extra 5 seconds to remove the mines -- an important 5 seconds the mercs need to react (the motion sensors should be put back, too, but that's besides the point).
I don't know how anyone could argue that this "doesn't have a huge effect on gameplay." It's a small change, much in the way that removing SS + Jump is a small change, but it has a HUGE effect on gameplay.
I find it ironic that so many people on these forums were aggro haters, yet many are arguing against something that would nerf aggro. Oh, and you'd still be able to bypass proxies quickly by running around corners and then running back quickly. You just wouldn't be able to do that with a merc there because, well, he's going to shoot you.
Quote from: Gawain on August 29, 2007, 09:33:11 PM
you can't put proxy and laser mines in places the spy can't quickchaff them (except some climbing passages)
Yeah, I'm thinking chaff probably shouldn't affect proxies at all. As far as lasers, I've always considered them to be surprise mines. You put them in places that people don't expect a mine and are moving relatively quickly, usually after just rounding a corner.
Lasers are generally fairly easy to disarm if you know they're there, and I guess I"m fine with that. Poisons are designed as the more secure, yet slightly less lethal way of protecting a doorway.
So I guess I'd say keep allowing chaff to go through walls but make proxies immune to chaff. Would that fix the problem?
QuoteSo I guess I'd say keep allowing chaff to go through walls but make proxies immune to chaff. Would that fix the problem?
No. You're not considering laser mines, poison mines, and spy traps. The point I'm making is that if you are being sneaky and careful, you'll have the time to draw your gun and shoot the chaff. Only when you are running around with no concern about being detected will you need the ability for chaff to go through walls.
Also, chaff needs to be able to affect proxies. Take Schermerhorn, for example. People place mines in the sewers in such a way that climbing sets them off, and then you blow up. If you have chaff, you can fire one up there and bypass it.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 29, 2007, 10:35:08 PM
Also, chaff needs to be able to affect proxies. Take Schermerhorn, for example. People place mines in the sewers in such a way that climbing sets them off, and then you blow up. If you have chaff, you can fire one up there and bypass it.
Having a slow climb should fix that problem though.
As far as lasers and spytraps, generally you'll place them far enough from the door that a chaff won't take them out if someone just drops it there.
And really, it's not that I'm against chaff not going through/bending around walls as a concept, I'm more worried about actually getting it to work right. I'd love to slow down aggro players as much as you would, but I can imagine so much cheese coming out of a change like this. All I can think of is mines or traps placed in such a way that you cannot chaff them due to the new way chaff works.
So while you're fixing one problem, I feel like the solution will create many more problems and make chaff too unreliable.
just give it a larger radius
QuoteHaving a slow climb should fix that problem though.
I'm talking about climbing up ledges. You don't need to have two different speeds for this.
Another nasty example where chaff needs to affect proxies is the coops into office on Aquarius.
QuoteAll I can think of is mines or traps placed in such a way that you cannot chaff them due to the new way chaff works.
Tell me of an example where this will be a NEW problem once chaff is changed. I can think of examples where you can't bypass lasers now regardless of whether or not chaff goes through walls. I can't think of any spot where disabling that function would suddenly create a situation where chaff worked before, but doesn't work now.
I already conceded that the lasers on traps and mines might need to return to PT length to compensate.
I'm not really for a blanket increase of chaff radius off the bat, but it might be necessary. If it is increased, it definitely shouldn't even approach the PT radius -- that was just absurd.
QuoteI'm more worried about actually getting it to work right.
Let the programmers worry about getting it to work right.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 29, 2007, 11:08:40 PM
QuoteHaving a slow climb should fix that problem though.
I'm talking about climbing up ledges. You don't need to have two different speeds for this.
Another nasty example where chaff needs to affect proxies is the coops into office on Aquarius.
I'm thinking that those animations should just not trigger a proxy. Any animation you're capable of doing, whether getting up from a ledge or climbing into a window or whatever should be able to be done slow enough as to not trigger a proxy.
Whether we want to make a "slow" version of each animation or just want to say that normal speed animations of these kinds don't trigger proxies I'm not sure, but I think you should definitely be able to get by a proxy if you know it's there. I've never really liked the autoscrew proxies that just go by animations anyway.
QuoteTell me of an example where this will be a NEW problem once chaff is changed. I can think of examples where you can't bypass lasers now regardless of whether or not chaff goes through walls. I can't think of any spot where disabling that function would suddenly create a situation where chaff worked before, but doesn't work now.
Well, I'm thinking more of firing in a chaff into a room and the chaff 'missing' the mine because the mine happens to be slightly around a corner or in a little niche or whatever. Obviously it's hard to think of these things now, because chaff doesn't work that way, so we haven't been looking for them. But give it a couple weeks and people will find optimal spots for mines to be virtually unhittable with chaff.
There are right now a lot of various things you can do with mines. Have them half sticking out of walls, sometimes have them 'inside' various barriers, behind objects or what not. If chaff is indeed simply a straight explosion, as opposed to something that bends or goes through walls, then I suspect people will find ways to evade it. And given that many mines require chaff to evade right now, if we take away the only means of avoiding them, mines will become too secure.
Though I suspect this issue may well be more of a coding issue than a balance one, so we should hear what the programmers have to say. They can probably be the most able to think up an effective algorithm to do what we want to do and avoid what we don't want to happen, because really, I agree with you about detracting from quick chaff rush aggro, but I fear that there are more side effects than you have anticipated.
spekkio posted great examples. there's nothing to discuss about that.
the easiest way to solve the programming issues that comes to my mind is to make quickdropped chaffs work only in straigt lines, but chaffs shooted with the ss work like they do now.
QuoteWell, I'm thinking more of firing in a chaff into a room and the chaff 'missing' the mine because the mine happens to be slightly around a corner or in a little niche or whatever. Obviously it's hard to think of these things now, because chaff doesn't work that way, so we haven't been looking for them. But give it a couple weeks and people will find optimal spots for mines to be virtually unhittable with chaff.
There is a very obvious visual cue when chaff shuts down the mine. Proxies stop blinking (could program them to stop beeping, too), and the lasers disappear. I really don't foresee this being an issue.
QuoteHave them half sticking out of walls, sometimes have them 'inside' various barriers, behind objects or what not.
Walls =/= textures. Regardless, the mines that can be stuck "inside" stuff like lights and such shouldn't exist in the first place.
if there's only a proxy, you don't need to chaff it in most situations.
"boosting" mines this way won't hurt the gameplay. if i die because of a mine, 80%of the time it's because of no pieppiep, and 10% because of unknown bugmine in texture/lagging into it/chaff/slow mode not working. assuming we won't have these bugs (besides lagg maybe), mines need some boost.
once again, one look on spekkio's fix list shows the solution: instant laser mines, 10s timer for poison mines, fixed chaff.
Mines don't need a boost, it all has to do with placement and what kind of mine is laid down. Something useful is laying a poison where there are usually laser trip wires, where it can't be affected by a chafff ( out of its range ) and where there isn't a health pack nearby. An example of a place like this is in greek where the sea tunnel lasers are. You put it behind the counter on the left side and shut the sea tunnel doors. This way, its laser looks like a laser trip wire and they think they disable it when they chaff it. When they are poisoned they can't reach the health pack in time because the doors are shut. I don't think that mines need a boost, they are meant to kill stupid spies who are agressive and not aggro. They are not meant to kill smart stealthy spies as well, that would make them overpowered.
you talk complete bullshit. it's hard for me, but i'll try to ingore your posts full of bloody ignorance in the future.
I talk bullshit and you say mines need a boost? WTF? Mines are meant to kill uncareful retarded spies. If you don't like them, then don't bring them into a match. Plain and fucking simple. That is like giving frags a boost, it doesn't need a damn boost whatsoever. Most people bring them into every game, get a few kills with them maybe, use them to defend objectives or choke points on the map. If you think a gadget that can do all of that needs a boost then you are fucking retarded.
Please, I doubt anybody besides you think they deserve a boost, THAT is TOTAL bullshit.
The only things that might need boosts are flares, tazer, maybe heartbeat, and maybe spy bullets. I can't even begin to think how you would even mention giving mines a boost. Totally ridiculous.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 30, 2007, 02:50:29 AM
I talk bullshit and you say mines need a boost? WTF? Mines are meant to kill uncareful retarded spies. If you don't like them, then don't bring them into a match. Plain and fucking simple. That is like giving frags a boost, it doesn't need a damn boost whatsoever. Most people bring them into every game, get a few kills with them maybe, use them to defend objectives or choke points on the map. If you think a gadget that can do all of that needs a boost then you are fucking retarded.
Yes, some mines need a boost, especially laser. You are aware that you can just trip a laser mine then run back and you won't even die. That's because there's a delay between triggering the mine and the mine actually detonating.
About the only real thing I disagree with on Spekkio's list of mine improvements is the poison mines. Personally I don't think they need to be more deadly, but I don't think it would impact gameplay that much if they were a bit nastier.
Quote
the easiest way to solve the programming issues that comes to my mind is to make quickdropped chaffs work only in straigt lines, but chaffs shooted with the ss work like they do now.
I'd be on board with that. I have no problem with nerfing quickdrop chaff a bit.
That isn't exactly a boost, that is more like fixing a little glitch. It is a glitch somewhat because that does not happen with poisons. It is just something that Ubi didn't notice or they forgot to fix.
What you didn't understand what I wrote before: Mines are meant to kill uncareful spies that aren't looking where they are going, and spies that don't think before they drop from ledges or turn corners. If you are smart enough to turn on thermal vision, locate a mine, trip it purposely and run back before it kills you, you are smart enough to not die from it. The only time you should die from a mine is when you fail to be careful and look for mines before they blow you up. If you are running around like an idiot, not looking around corners, not looking for mines that CAN kill you, you can/could/should be killed by a mine.
Like I said before, I do not think that mines should recieve a boost because the only kill you will/should ever get with a mine is when you have an aggro spy running around, or one who is not careful.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 30, 2007, 05:14:35 AM
Like I said before, I do not think that mines should recieve a boost because the only kill you will/should ever get with a mine is when you have an aggro spy running around, or one who is not careful.
How do any of the proposed changes make mines more deadly to spies who are careful?
I can't remember the last time that I died directly from a poison mine. That's the only reason I suggest a timer of 10 seconds instead of 15. Another reason it's a bit BS that you can get poisoned next to most objectives and still get them in time.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on August 30, 2007, 05:19:20 AM
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 30, 2007, 05:14:35 AM
Like I said before, I do not think that mines should recieve a boost because the only kill you will/should ever get with a mine is when you have an aggro spy running around, or one who is not careful.
How do any of the proposed changes make mines more deadly to spies who are careful?
What proposed changes? Mines shouldn't be deadly to spies who are careful.
dude you are a toal idiot. some1 had to say that.
Wow spekkio, each of those points I didn't think of. It's also probably why I lose so many damn games. WTF! Damn chaff through walls.
Quote from: Daybreak on August 30, 2007, 02:45:30 PM
Wow spekkio, each of those points I didn't think of. It's also probably why I lose so many damn games. WTF! Damn chaff through walls.
:D
tbh, fixed chaff would make me enjoy club and museum again.
If mines were completely able to kill spies who are careful and spies who are running around like idiots, then what is the point of being careful? The reason people like me are stealthy is that we don't want to die or get detected.
And I agree fixed chaff would make maps like club house better.
Quote from: Papa Skull on August 31, 2007, 12:05:54 AM
If mines were completely able to kill spies who are careful and spies who are running around like idiots, then what is the point of being careful?
dude, how dumb are you???? did you even read the last posts????
changing chaff and mines the suggested way will in no way affect careful stealth players.
wtf did you think posting this crap?
Well i understand the things you (Gawain) say the same way Papa Skull does. But then again, i'd say examples of the changes should be added to every suggestion.
I've given 6 concrete examples of where chaff not going through walls would slow down aggro, but not affect stealth, and why chaff needs to remain effective against proxy mines. Again, if you believe that spies should be able to run around that freely, then we just disagree on that point. However, no one seems to be arguing that. I'm still waiting for specific examples of spots where a mine or trap, when placed by the host so the laser is straight, is suddenly unchaffable if chaff didn't go through walls when it was bypassable before.
Speculating that the programmers might not get it right, or that bugged mines might pose too much of a threat, is not good reasoning or evidence in support of not changing chaff. Unless told otherwise by the people making the game, you should assume that it's possible to make it work right. Otherwise, why even bother making a game at all, cuz, you know, it just might not work right.
Furthermore, "It's not realistic" is a weak argument as well. There is very little that is realistic about SvM, both in concept and execution.
Umm, I believe I read someone's post wrong. I thought someone said they should be boosted enough to be deadly to all spies or something like that. Never mind, I see that the proposed changes would make them even more deadly to aggro spies. My bad. ;D
who said something about realism?
Quote from: Spekkio on August 31, 2007, 05:29:50 AM
I'm still waiting for specific examples of spots where a mine or trap, when placed by the host so the laser is straight, is suddenly unchaffable if chaff didn't go through walls when it was bypassable before.
It's rather difficult to produce examples of mechanical bugs when those mechanics aren't in place yet, as I have nothing with which to test them.
Lets remember that people have found some impressive places to put mines that do things that we have never imagined they'd do. There's one spot on aqua where you put it behind the greek door such that you can blow the mine and kill a spy hacking greek from the explosion at the doorway. Now these things weren't thought of fast, it took lots of experimentation and testing. I can't do that experimentation and testing, because there's nothing to test right now.
As far as a solution, I like Gawain's solution that quickdrop chaff is blocked by walls and launched chaff isn't. That seems to produce the effect of slowing down aggro spies, while making sure that no mine is out of reach.
the problem with this solution is that it's kinda incoherent, and especially newcomers won't understand it.
i can't remember any mines/traps that couldn't be disambled with chaff in pt, so i don't think there will be new bs because of this change. it's way better to copy the best of ct and pt from the very beginning imo. there's no question that a little bit more security and a chaff more like in pt would improve the gameplay.
QuoteIt's rather difficult to produce examples of mechanical bugs when those mechanics aren't in place yet, as I have nothing with which to test them.
Again, forget about mechanical bugs. You always go back to "but it might be bugged."
Anything can get bugged; that is not a reason for or against including a feature in the game. Bugs will always pop up, and unlike Ubi, the PS team is going to fix them.
As for coming up with what I asked for, it's simple: think of a mine or spytrap where you HAVE to drop the chaff through a wall or else you wouldn't be able to disable it. You can find this without having to change the mechanic. Hint: I don't think any such spots exist, which is the entire point of my argument. But I could be wrong.
QuoteLets remember that people have found some impressive places to put mines that do things that we have never imagined they'd do. There's one spot on aqua where you put it behind the greek door such that you can blow the mine and kill a spy hacking greek from the explosion at the doorway. Now these things weren't thought of fast, it took lots of experimentation and testing. I can't do that experimentation and testing, because there's nothing to test right now.
What does this have to do with chaff? Even if you chaff that mine, the merc is gonna blow you to hell anyway.
QuoteAs far as a solution, I like Gawain's solution that quickdrop chaff is blocked by walls and launched chaff isn't. That seems to produce the effect of slowing down aggro spies, while making sure that no mine is out of reach.
I don't. It's unnecessarily inconsistent. Currently, no one has provided any circumstance where you need this feature to bypass a trap, even though I've asked like four times for one.
There are times when a spytrap is hard to shoot out, because the gun on the right side. If you can switch shoulders, I think all mines etc can be chaffed. However, there should be a limit on the range of laser/poison mines. Especially annoying if you can't reach it by bounching the chaff to the mine via a wall.
So if its ambidextrous and there's a limit, I dont think chaff needs to go through walls.
EMP should go through walls by definition.
there are some tricky spy traps on orph and club that can be disabled way faster/reliable with chaff going through walls, but afaik spekkio already suggested giving spytraps/poisons less range.
another solution i'd prefer is the shoulder switch frvge suggested, or a safe way to lean around the corner without setting off the trap.
Quote from: frvge on August 31, 2007, 06:27:36 PM
There are times when a spytrap is hard to shoot out, because the gun on the right side. If you can switch shoulders, I think all mines etc can be chaffed. However, there should be a limit on the range of laser/poison mines. Especially annoying if you can't reach it by bounching the chaff to the mine via a wall.
I don't care if it's
hard to shoot out; that's the point of a well-placed mine. I care if it
becomes impossible to shoot out if chaff didn't pass through walls. Furthermore, there already is a limit on the length of the laser. It's just really long, so most of the time it doesn't come into effect.
The poisons in storage, or the poison in Deftech building C covering the passageway, aren't submissible because they already cannot be shot out when placed properly. They don't
become impossible to shoot out with the change because they're like that already. I actually believe that those two mines in particular are a driving motivation for Gawain desiring a larger chaff radius.
Furthermore, a spy trap like the one going from the first floor light across the Garden 1st floor entryway doesn't count because 1. You might actually be able to chaff it and 2. more importantly, that is a bugged trap, and unlike Ubi the PS team is going to fix such bugs. That is the entire point of Project Stealth -- to reproduce SvM's gameplay on a bug-free and more balanced platform, and ultimately add to it from there. If they aren't going to fix the bugs, or if they're just going to leave other bugs in there, then there's absolutely no point to this project. We already have a buggy game to play.
Be specific please. When you say "there are some traps that...," I tend to think you're pulling shit out of your ass because you refuse to look at the situation objectively. I don't really get what's so hard about this. I'm telling the detractors specifically what would refute my argument, yet you guys keep coming up with crap out of left field like "what if such-and-such is bugged," which is a poor argument because we should assume that the dev team is going to troubleshoot bugs, and "emp, by definition, has to go through walls." No, it doesn't because this is a
video game. It's
not realistic. There are only two cases you could make to refute this change:
1. You believe that spies ought to be able to move as freely as they do now to maintain balance. ie you disagree with the fundamental concept of it. So far, no one seems to disagree with the concept.
2. There are a significant number of mines/traps that would become impassible with the change, thus nerfind stealthy spies as well. Goodkebab has made this argument himself, but no one has been able to tell me one, let along many, specific places where an unbugged mine or trap is unable to be chaffed except by throwing it through the wall.
QuoteEMP should go through walls by definition.
-1000 to you for using the coveted realism argument.
Quote from: Spekkio on August 31, 2007, 08:39:57 PM
2. There are a significant number of mines/traps that would become impassible with the change, thus nerfind stealthy spies as well. Goodkebab has made this argument himself, but no one has been able to tell me one, let along many, specific places where an unbugged mine or trap is unable to be chaffed except by throwing it through the wall.
As I've already said, it's impossible to test sometihng that doesn't exist yet and it's not something that's immediately obvious. Figuring out good mine placements takes time, and requires you have some method of testing it. I can go through the levels and look for little niches where one could place a mine or trap and take guesses, but I can't actually prove anything, because it's an unimplemented mechanic. It just sounds like a potentially dangerous balance change on concept, which may render some traps or mines unchaffable. Of course I can't prove it, because the mechanic doesn't exist yet.
It's never bad to err on the side of caution when making a change like this, as impossible to reach mines or traps would be more harmful to gameplay than chaff going through walls would be.
invisible: we already had a damn good test of this, it's called pandora tomorrow versus mode ;)
spekkio: i liked the way the pt chaff was throw-and-forget-about-traps/mines/security in this room. though used for aggro, the radius is way too big. furthermore, with a larger radius, it's a lot easier to get tricky mines/traps (like the ones in orphanage big entrance room to corridors spytraps). chaff needs a little buff. you showed me personally that playing without chaff is quite possible.
Quote
As I've already said, it's impossible to test sometihng that doesn't exist yet and it's not something that's immediately obvious. Figuring out good mine placements takes time, and requires you have some method of testing it. I can go through the levels and look for little niches where one could place a mine or trap and take guesses, but I can't actually prove anything, because it's an unimplemented mechanic.
*Sigh*...
Yes, you can find these spots, if they even exist. You have someone plant a mine or trap that you can disable with through-the-wall chaff. Then you try to get around it without using a through-the-wall chaff; in other words, you draw your gun and chuck the chaff to where the mine or trap is. If you can't do the latter, but can take it out with through-the-wall chaff, you've found a spot to support goodkebab's statement.
Quotechaff needs a little buff. you showed me personally that playing without chaff is quite possible.
How is the fact that you can play effectively without chaff evidence for increasing its radius? My only reservation is that if you buff the chaff radius, you are buffing aggro. Aggro is already going to receive a large buff when funny punches, lag charges, and insta frags are taken out of the game, along with fixing the jump hit detection. This might be over-the-top already, let alone without adjustments to MT and chaff radius. Mines like the poison that locks off the under route to building C in Deftech would be best fixed via map design, not buffing chaff. Then again, I personally don't believe that chaff absolutely needs to be able to hit every mine and spy trap in the game.
i don't give a shit about deftech.
i don't think that aggro will receive a buff (no host grab/jump bs, way better aiming, no chaff through walls,...). on good servers with the mercs hosting, aggro in terms of breaking/jumping the merc is no real issue atm. i just like the idea of throwing chaff in a room and don't care about security etc any more, and i also like the way you can hinder someone from sniping more easily than shocking the head.
if i wanted to go for necks, i wouldn't use chaff, i'd use taze+flash+smoke. i can't see a problem giving chaff a little boost, if it gets a large anti aggro nerf.
The biggest anti-aggro nerf is going to be getting rid of side grabs IMO. They caused so many problems. If side grabs don't exist then you can back to a wall and be completely invulnerable to grabs. That'll hurt aggro considerably.
will one still face the direction a punch came from? will punch+insta grab be possible? (i think it should, but atm most times only the host is able to do so)
Quote from: Gawain on September 01, 2007, 11:56:45 PM
if i wanted to go for necks, i wouldn't use chaff, i'd use taze+flash+smoke. i can't see a problem giving chaff a little boost, if it gets a large anti aggro nerf.
Aggro doesn't necessarily mean going for necks.
Quote
will one still face the direction a punch came from? will punch+insta grab be possible? (i think it should, but atm most times only the host is able to do so)
Merc have to have some time to berserk, otherwise it will make aggro ridiculously powerful.
Quote from: kronf on September 02, 2007, 04:44:32 AM
Aggro doesn't necessarily mean going for necks.
i'm aware of that, thus i wrote "going for necks".
Quote from: kronf on September 02, 2007, 04:44:32 AM
Quote
will one still face the direction a punch came from? will punch+insta grab be possible? (i think it should, but atm most times only the host is able to do so)
Merc have to have some time to berserk, otherwise it will make aggro ridiculously powerful.
well, if this isn't possible, going aggro for necks will be nearly impossible against good players.
Quote
i'm aware of that, thus i wrote "going for necks".
I think we were discussing how powerful is chaff when it comes to disabling mines in a fast way near objective, not "going for necks".
Quote
well, if this isn't possible, going aggro for necks will be nearly impossible against good players.
Huh?
i suggested giving chaff a larger radius, and spekkio is of the opinion that it will be too strong aggroeing the merc.
Quotei suggested giving chaff a larger radius, and spekkio is of the opinion that it will be too strong aggroeing the merc.
What? Where did he say that? I re-read all his posts in this thread and couldn't find it. Spekkio haven't said anything about aggroing a merc and chaff. He might have said that with larger radius it will make aggro easier, but then again aggro DOESN'T always mean going for necks.
Quote from: gawaini just like the idea of throwing chaff in a room and don't care about security etc any more,
Why is this necessary, and why would this be good for gameplay?
I like the idea of spies with rocket launchers. Let's put that in the game, too, cuz I think the spies should be able to shoot a rocket into a room and never have to worry about any mercs. While we're at it, why don't we restore the tazer to its PT ownage state just because I think using the tazer was fun. Point being, you're giving no reason to re-implement what once was an extremely overpowered mechanic other than the fact that you like it.
The chaff in PT was ridiculously too large. I honestly think that the chaff area is perfect the way it is now. Any larger and that "one chaff that takes out all the security" is also going to disable any merc in the room from reloading, using any visions, or sniping you. Furthermore, the whole point to changing the fact that chaff goes through walls is to slow down the spies, and I've detailed many instances where this would amend what is, in my opinion, a ridiculous game mechanic where the spies can pretty much run around freely. If you make the radius larger to compensate, you're negating the purpose of the change because where the spies needed to throw two chaffs to get rid of everything, they can now do it with one.
To be more concrete, let's use the club house 1st floor garden entry again. The spy trap is placed on the 2x4 pillar next to the health box, blocking off the doorway. There is also a mine at the healthbox, and to the left of the objective. With the current chaff radius, you'd need three to take out all those traps -- one shot near the spy trap, and then another shot near the objective. If we were to use PT's chaff radius, you could just throw one in the middle of the room and take out all 3. This would take the same net time as quick-throwing one at the spy trap, quick throwing one at the outside of the doorway, and then just running in. Even if you used a radius size inbetween, one chaff shot near the spy trap would also take out the mine at the healthbox, saving you any time that would have ordinarilly been lost by the change in the first place.
Then, when the merc comes to get you, since you caused a security failure, he can't use visions, reload, or snipe you anywhere in that terminal area. You essentially created a huge "no go" zone thanks to chaff's large radius. Hell, shoot another chaff in the elevator room near two doorways, and then the merc is really screwed.
So again, if you agree with reverting chaff behavior to PT with regards to going through walls in order to slow down spies slightly, how would increasing its radius be a good thing? You'd be negating the purpose for the change entirely, and giving a strong buff to aggro spies.
Quote from: kronf
What? Where did he say that? I re-read all his posts in this thread and couldn't find it. Spekkio haven't said anything about aggroing a merc and chaff. He might have said that with larger radius it will make aggro easier, but then again aggro DOESN'T always mean going for necks.
At least kronf understands.
QuoteThe biggest anti-aggro nerf is going to be getting rid of side grabs IMO. They caused so many problems. If side grabs don't exist then you can back to a wall and be completely invulnerable to grabs. That'll hurt aggro considerably.
Are you sure about this? Interesting notion considering that A) the grab area will be the same width, just shifted and B) you haven't played with it.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on September 02, 2007, 12:44:44 AM
The biggest anti-aggro nerf is going to be getting rid of side grabs IMO. They caused so many problems. If side grabs don't exist then you can back to a wall and be completely invulnerable to grabs. That'll hurt aggro considerably.
While I agree the grab box needs to be adjusted better, I don't think it will have much effect on anything if at all.
it takes 4 seconds after pulling your weapon until the chaff explodes. so one can't use chaff for running away anymore. your example on club does only make sense with the smaller proxy mine trigger radius you suggested, because disabling the spytrap with chaff and triggering the mines by running a small circle would be sufficient.
generally i have to concede that you are right that giving chaff a larger radius is probably a bad idea, but i think chaff needs some kind of boost if you take away it's strongest ability. especially the disk type objective will get quite harder, creating a new challenge for the level designers.
another idea of boosting chaff would be increasing the number. it won't help aggro as one can't spam it well with the delay, but it will help spies that play carefully and don't die the whole game, thus not getting new equipment.
regarding the grab hitbox: it won't make a big difference i guess.
What about This:
Buffs to chaff:
-Acts as a flashbang against mercs in MT.
-slightly larger radius
-makes no noise at all.
Nerfs to chaff:
-Doesn't go through walls (assuming programmers can get it to work right)
-Doesn't prevent merc reload anymore (that was kind of stupid anyway)
-Doesn't disable proxies at all.
Quote from: Gawain on September 02, 2007, 02:30:58 AM
will one still face the direction a punch came from? will punch+insta grab be possible? (i think it should, but atm most times only the host is able to do so)
For this, I say that after you elbow shot somebody, you shouldn't be able to grab them, but your partner should. So you can elbow them into your partner, but you can't do any kind of 1man punch + grab host cheese, since that's really nothing more than a disguised host grab.
Punch+insta grab is really frustrating if you're merc, but way cool when you do it to other mercs :D. It's a nice feature/glitch and grants some advantage for the spies, and compensates the lack of firepower. That has to be included in P:S. Make a lot of spies' dreams come true :D.
Yeah but currently the punch + grab doesn't happen 100% of the time. This is a reason that spies don't always go for necks after they elbow someone, sometime they just run away and try to buy some time with that elbow. If it was implemented it wouldh have to be added very carefully and not too powerful and overwhelming.
the mt (/emf?) flashbang idea sound interesting, but how is it supposed to work exactly?
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on September 03, 2007, 02:23:10 AM
Nerfs to chaff:
-Doesn't disable proxies at all.
I completely disagree. If I'm running away from a merc, I won't have the time to crouch, remove a mine and keep going. I'll just throw a chaff so it doesn't go boom on me, and keep avoiding bullets to get up on my ass.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on September 03, 2007, 02:23:10 AM
What about This:
Buffs to chaff:
-Acts as a flashbang against mercs in MT.
-slightly larger radius
-makes no noise at all.
No. This is encroaching on basically re-introducing PT chaff, which made flashbangs obsolete.
QuoteNerfs to chaff:
-Doesn't go through walls (assuming programmers can get it to work right)
-Doesn't prevent merc reload anymore (that was kind of stupid anyway)
-Doesn't disable proxies at all.
Again, no. I already detailed why chaff must affect proxies. Go back to page 8 or 9 and re-read that explanation. There's also no reason to take out the fact that it disables merc reload.
Quote from: gawainit takes 4 seconds after pulling your weapon until the chaff explodes. so one can't use chaff for running away anymore. your example on club does only make sense with the smaller proxy mine trigger radius you suggested, because disabling the spytrap with chaff and triggering the mines by running a small circle would be sufficient.
Example 2: Cinema. You want to grab the disk. You throw a chaff at the lower lobby objective area, and any mines in there are automatically disabled due to the larger radius. It would even be more advantageous than having chaff going through walls and being smaller, since one chaff won't do the job currently.
Example 3: Museum inner cafe. Quick-Throw a chaff in the middle of the room and the merc is pretty much at the mercy of aggro spies unless he finds the small doorway and runs away.
I can come up with a ton of these.
Quote from: kronf on September 03, 2007, 12:37:57 AM
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on September 02, 2007, 12:44:44 AM
The biggest anti-aggro nerf is going to be getting rid of side grabs IMO. They caused so many problems. If side grabs don't exist then you can back to a wall and be completely invulnerable to grabs. That'll hurt aggro considerably.
While I agree the grab box needs to be adjusted better, I don't think it will have much effect on anything if at all.
I agree.
Quote from: Papa Skull on September 03, 2007, 05:45:02 AM
Yeah but currently the punch + grab doesn't happen 100% of the time. This is a reason that spies don't always go for necks after they elbow someone, sometime they just run away and try to buy some time with that elbow. If it was implemented it wouldh have to be added very carefully and not too powerful and overwhelming.
Actually, without extreme lag punch + grab
never works. The merc
always has a small timeframe which he can berserk, and you can
always jump immediately after a berserk without getting grabbed.
Quote from: gui_brazilI completely disagree. If I'm running away from a merc, I won't have the time to crouch, remove a mine and keep going. I'll just throw a chaff so it doesn't go boom on me, and keep avoiding bullets to get up on my ass.
If chaff doesn't go through walls, that probably won't work, which is part of the point of it.
Quote from: Gawain on September 03, 2007, 01:24:01 PM
the mt (/emf?) flashbang idea sound interesting, but how is it supposed to work exactly?
Basically, the same way a flash works, only people in normal vision are immune and people in MT get blinded. We could change the chaff blinding effect from a flood of white to a lot of static for effect if we wanted to.
I wouldn't want it to effect EMF, because EMF is easy enough to beat as far as visions go anyway. But I figure it'd be another way to help balance out MT.
An alternate idea is instead of blinding, it could draw the MT box for the duration of the chaff, forcing the box to lock onto the chaff, and making it unable to lock onto anything else. Though that might be a bit too powerful, so blinding is probably a better option, as you could basically fire off a chaff in the middle of the room and render MT useless as an aggro spy. So yeah, best bet might be go with the first idea.
Invisible,
Most of your complaints about MT are that you can't sneak by a merc when he's using it. How is a "MT flashbang" going to help you sneak past a merc any differently than what we have now? It's going to just buff aggro, since currently MT/EMF are your only safeguards against getting bombarded with grenades and being blind for 30 seconds.
:) :D ;D
spekkio ftw
It isn't hard (not sure about unreal though) to stop chaffs going through walls. The actually dust, maybe, but to stop it from affecting the player you simply have to check the line between the grenade and the player and see if the line his the wall. If so then the wall is in the way. As i've said i'm not sure if it is that simple for unreal but in the basics i've done in other languages...