Berserk uber-thread - have fun

Started by Hyrage, May 16, 2008, 09:23:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Hyrage

Have fun debating about "is berserk too powerful?" ^^, stay polite plz


Do you think that berserk is too much powerful? If not why?


  • A berserk is badly hurting the spies [this is normal]

  • It knocks down them too

  • It can knock down multiple enemy with one shot [isn't it too much powerful?]

  • Making them free-kills because they are knocked down and the merc simply have to shoot 'em up.

  • The strike isn't only acting in one direction but all-around in circle

  • The berserk can counter a Drop Attack

  • If you sneak around and avoid the move, sometimes it hurst you back even if the animation is finished... argh

  • You do not even have to aim properly to hit your enemies, you perform the action and boom! you kill. When you use a laser-mine, you have to properly palce is somewhere smart. If you throw a greande you have to aim accurately or anticpate the right wall rebound, etc.. But berserk is a lot easier to use, don't you think it could be "too much" OP?

What do you think? Isn't it too much powerful?
http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/1015/achievement3zo3.jpg[/img]

"Video Games are art, but we don't play art, we play games."

Cyntrox

Quote from: Hyrage on May 16, 2008, 09:23:53 PMIf you sneak around and avoid the move, sometimes it hurst you back even if the animation is finished... argh
Oh, really? It never did in any release of PS that I've played...

Farley4Fan

Cyntrox has the right idea Hyrage.  A lot of the reason you think it's overpowered is because of lag or bug issues that won't be present in PS, hopefully atleast.  I do not think that berserk is overpowered because a merc is supposed to destroy a spy up close, or anywhere for that matter.  Spies are supposed to avoid mercs and if they don't they are in for a world of hurt. 

I DO think that spies should have running elbow hit.  Ever played assassins creed?  I like being able to hold down a button and knock back someone who is in your way.  Of course it would just barely push the merc back a bit.  It's one of those nice to have things for me.  I'm sure a lot of people don't agree though...

Hyrage

Quote from: Papa Skull on May 17, 2008, 12:15:09 AM
Cyntrox has the right idea Hyrage.  A lot of the reason you think it's overpowered is because of lag or bug issues that won't be present in PS, hopefully atleast.  I do not think that berserk is overpowered because a merc is supposed to destroy a spy up close, or anywhere for that matter.  Spies are supposed to avoid mercs and if they don't they are in for a world of hurt. 

I DO think that spies should have running elbow hit.  Ever played assassins creed?  I like being able to hold down a button and knock back someone who is in your way.  Of course it would just barely push the merc back a bit.  It's one of those nice to have things for me.  I'm sure a lot of people don't agree though...
Lag issues have nothing to do with what I wrote above, it happens in lan and it's related to the way the move is programmed. Maybe they fixed it through the PC version, who knows.

If you see a Spy as a fag running around and hiding, it's your perspective. Me I see a spy as an incredibly smart agent who is simply using the shadows to achieve his goals and he uses a more passive way to fight. Spies are trained for close-combat fighting and seeing a merc with a berserk is ridiculous.

If the berserk was simply pushing both spies away making 50% damages it would be fine, but it's not only hurting, it knocks down the enemy + can touch multiple enemies + can counter a Drop attack what isn't logical at all because:
1. the spy is trained for that and the drop attack is his speciality... performed by surprise or not
2. falling from high places can hardly be countered
3. A jump attack is more deadly than a berserk
http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/1015/achievement3zo3.jpg[/img]

"Video Games are art, but we don't play art, we play games."

T2C LeBron

Quote from: Hyrage on May 16, 2008, 09:23:53 PM
Have fun debating about "is berserk too powerful?" ^^, stay polite plz


Do you think that berserk is too much powerful? If not why?


  • A berserk is badly hurting the spies [this is normal]

  • It knocks down them too

  • It can knock down multiple enemy with one shot [isn't it too much powerful?]

  • Making them free-kills because they are knocked down and the merc simply have to shoot 'em up.

  • The strike isn't only acting in one direction but all-around in circle

  • The berserk can counter a Drop Attack

  • If you sneak around and avoid the move, sometimes it hurst you back even if the animation is finished... argh

  • You do not even have to aim properly to hit your enemies, you perform the action and boom! you kill. When you use a laser-mine, you have to properly palce is somewhere smart. If you throw a greande you have to aim accurately or anticpate the right wall rebound, etc.. But berserk is a lot easier to use, don't you think it could be "too much" OP?

What do you think? Isn't it too much powerful?


well it isn't overpowered at all, if anything it is underpowered for the mercs.  But i like it ho wit is now if you got rid of a couple glitches.  Some of you think that the point of splinter cell is to be able to double team mercs and break his neck with no danger of going at the merc or be able to put the merc in a vunerable position and giving him no way of defending himself.  No it is about stealth and teamwork about discouraging overaggression, making it more dangerous then if you ran away or stealthed.

.leelu12.

Agree with lebron, beserk isnt a problem really. Nothing more satisfying that knocking down 2 aggroing spys :D
http://i282.photobucket.com/albums/kk268/anaperkovic/LeeluPinkFLowers.jpg[/img]

Add my xfire (leelu12) to chat sc/ps or organise a game/train me :D
<|TLK|>  {{ (T)eam (L)ion (K)ing - if you think this film is cool, add this below your sig :P }}

Gawain

berserk is in no way op in story mode hyrage...

Farley4Fan

Quote from: Hyrage on May 17, 2008, 12:42:54 AM
Quote from: Papa Skull on May 17, 2008, 12:15:09 AM
Cyntrox has the right idea Hyrage.  A lot of the reason you think it's overpowered is because of lag or bug issues that won't be present in PS, hopefully atleast.  I do not think that berserk is overpowered because a merc is supposed to destroy a spy up close, or anywhere for that matter.  Spies are supposed to avoid mercs and if they don't they are in for a world of hurt. 

I DO think that spies should have running elbow hit.  Ever played assassins creed?  I like being able to hold down a button and knock back someone who is in your way.  Of course it would just barely push the merc back a bit.  It's one of those nice to have things for me.  I'm sure a lot of people don't agree though...
Lag issues have nothing to do with what I wrote above, it happens in lan and it's related to the way the move is programmed. Maybe they fixed it through the PC version, who knows.

If you see a Spy as a fag running around and hiding, it's your perspective. Me I see a spy as an incredibly smart agent who is simply using the shadows to achieve his goals and he uses a more passive way to fight. Spies are trained for close-combat fighting and seeing a merc with a berserk is ridiculous.

If the berserk was simply pushing both spies away making 50% damages it would be fine, but it's not only hurting, it knocks down the enemy + can touch multiple enemies + can counter a Drop attack what isn't logical at all because:
1. the spy is trained for that and the drop attack is his speciality... performed by surprise or not
2. falling from high places can hardly be countered
3. A jump attack is more deadly than a berserk


Well, duh.  Berserk is in no way possible in real life, but that's why I've suggested many alternatives.  If one of your main points is realism then you won't win this argument.  I've suggested things that are much more logical but achieve the same result as the berserk does now.  It's balanced.  My only problem with berserk is the often lag hits you get with it.  Or on the other side, if you berserk as a merc with a spy nearby or on top of you and hit nothing at all.  For example on CT the host jump range is bigger than the merc's berserk range.  That's a huge reason why host jump is so powerful.  Keep in mind these problems won't exist in PS Hyrage.

Btw, if 2 spies are both dumb enough to get berserked at the same time by 1 berserk, why does it matter if it can knock them both down?  A successful team isn't going to run straight for the merc at the same time, but instead make constant attacks at different times - making it easy for the merc to miss the berserk and giving an easy grab for spies.  And that's only a successful aggro team.  A smart team isn't going to mess with the merc too much, on story of course.  Have you ever seen Havoc and Weezer play together?  They run at the merc almost like they are taking turns hitting him back and forth or grabbing.  They almost never are both in berserk range at the same time unless one of them is grabbing the stunned/elbowed mercenary. 

This goes for DM as well.  Don't both rush into his deadly range at the same moment.  Try to confuse the merc and knock him around before he commits to a charge or berserk, then grab him if you must.

I see the spy as an intelligent character too.  A smart enough spy to avoid someone whose got bigger guns and complete the mission w/o even worrying about fighting him/her.  Not a cocky dumbass who is going to say: "Hell, I've got elbows, grabs, a ss, and gas nades.  He's got berserk/nades/tazer/gas mask/charge/shotgun or uzi or rifle/insta turn/jump etc...  I can kick his ass up close!@!1"  An awesome spy would outsmart his opponent and grab him from behind.  I wouldn't call that being a fag.

Hyrage

I haven't ask to know how Weazer and Havock are playing and lag isn't an issue to game balance, it's an Online Game fact and consequence.

Without the Berserk

The Merc is ALREADY stronger at close combat because he simply have to hit the spy to kill him, by knocking him down while the Spy can only knock him down and needs to do it twice to kill. If you tell me that the Berserk is there to counter the Spy Drop Attack, it can't be valuable for the following reasons:

- If the Berserk was created to counter the Drop-Attack, it means that the Merc performing it is concious that the Spy is performing it.

- And if the Berserk is there for this reason, than means that there is no other way to counter it what isn't true... so it's Unbalancing the game between Spies and Mercs. If you see the spy making a drop attack, you avoid it... wait for the hard landing and charge the spy right now or shot his face. This is how you can counter a drop attack.

- If you tell me here again, "it's to counter the lag", you should know that you NEVER add a gameplay to counter Internet issues, because this isn't part of the game content... it's a bad connexion issue.

- When a gameplay is created, to make it balanced... the player has to "control it". What means, aiming because here it's a shooter. Berserk doesn't require aiming skills

- Plus it's hitting all around the player

- Plus it could knock down more than ONE enemy with one action. [I don't care if no spies would attack at the same time, the fact is it is doing it and you have to consider it]

- The BERSERK is for the Merc, what means once the enemy is knocked down he is already dead because the Merc can kill his kocked down opponent with his gun or with a strike. Theorically, the opponent is automatically dead on the first hit.
1. The spy can't even perform something that = a charge, but he gets his advantage in his movement speed.

2. The Spy can't counter with any attack a Berserk, but the Berserk can counter the spy.


.... Too much advantages for a single action compared to all the others plus comparing both sides = OP

Have fun.
http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/1015/achievement3zo3.jpg[/img]

"Video Games are art, but we don't play art, we play games."

Gawain

hyrage, what you don't get is that in story mode, 1 merc really has to totally dominate 1 spy up-close when he's aware of his presence, otherwise no stealth at all would be required. if you think berserk is op in dm, fine, i could care less. but it's definitely not op in story mode.

Cyntrox

Quote from: Hyrage on May 17, 2008, 03:53:12 AM
The Merc is ALREADY stronger at close combat because he simply have to hit the spy to kill him, by knocking him down while the Spy can only knock him down and needs to do it twice to kill. If you tell me that the Berserk is there to counter the Spy Drop Attack, it can't be valuable for the following reasons:
And the merc is SUPPOSED to be stronger at all-out close combat when he knows the spy is there.

Quote- If the Berserk was created to counter the Drop-Attack, it means that the Merc performing it is concious that the Spy is performing it.
Uh, and...?

Quote- And if the Berserk is there for this reason, than means that there is no other way to counter it what isn't true... so it's Unbalancing the game between Spies and Mercs. If you see the spy making a drop attack, you avoid it... wait for the hard landing and charge the spy right now or shot his face. This is how you can counter a drop attack.
Again: It isn't supposed to be balanced, if the merc didn't have more killing power than the spy this game would be boring.

Quote- When a gameplay is created, to make it balanced... the player has to "control it". What means, aiming because here it's a shooter. Berserk doesn't require aiming skills
It does, however, require you to know that the spy is there (which is much more in focus in an SvM than aiming skills), and it requires you to get the distance right.

Quote- The BERSERK is for the Merc, what means once the enemy is knocked down he is already dead because the Merc can kill his kocked down opponent with his gun or with a strike. Theorically, the opponent is automatically dead on the first hit.
1. The spy can't even perform something that = a charge, but he gets his advantage in his movement speed.

2. The Spy can't counter with any attack a Berserk, but the Berserk can counter the spy.
You're not dead once you're berserked, a good teammate can save you.

.leelu12.

#11
Quote from: Rambo on May 17, 2008, 11:36:53 AMin story mode, 1 merc really has to totally dominate 1 spy up-close when he's aware of his presence, otherwise no stealth at all would be required

As i was telling khris on xfire, i dont really like other shooting games and i only play sc cos i like sneaking places. Im glad the mercs are so powerful or sc would bore me im sure.
Iv been in some good player servers recently and iv notice that when i beserk they put a cam really fast and get me  :-\. I never really get close to hitting them.
http://i282.photobucket.com/albums/kk268/anaperkovic/LeeluPinkFLowers.jpg[/img]

Add my xfire (leelu12) to chat sc/ps or organise a game/train me :D
<|TLK|>  {{ (T)eam (L)ion (K)ing - if you think this film is cool, add this below your sig :P }}

VaNilla

I don't have to read any of this topic to have the common sense to know this, a spy must be ready for beserk, and if he isn't then thats his own fault in most cases. If you're sneaking up to a merc ready for a neck, and he gets you with a beserk, then bad luck. If you're in hand to hand combat with the merc then you're an idiot for getting beserked, if that happens you should know that any good mercanary will kill you and you should retreat, no doubt about it.

Sure, it takes a certain amount of skill before you know these tactics, but so does anything. Hacking objectives competently, staying hidden, shooting out a mine... every element needs a small amount of skill before you can do them, and this is one of them. Believe you and me most of the time it doesn't take rocket science to know when a merc is likely to try and beserk.

AgentX_003

Quote from: STON3COLDKILLA on May 17, 2008, 02:27:59 PM
I don't have to read any of this topic to have the common sense to know this, a spy must be ready for beserk, and if he isn't then thats his own fault in most cases. If you're sneaking up to a merc ready for a neck, and he gets you with a beserk, then bad luck. If you're in hand to hand combat with the merc then you're an idiot for getting beserked, if that happens you should know that any good mercanary will kill you and you should retreat, no doubt about it.

Sure, it takes a certain amount of skill before you know these tactics, but so does anything. Hacking objectives competently, staying hidden, shooting out a mine... every element needs a small amount of skill before you can do them, and this is one of them. Believe you and me most of the time it doesn't take rocket science to know when a merc is likely to try and beserk.

but on the other hand  Deathmatchers will do everything in their power.. in thier own minds of trying to get the neck.. People i can't stress this enough..  Its not about the neck, its about the objective.


-Thanks Murdy for da Sig <3  xD

Kurbutti

Good point. A skilled spy knows to expect merc to berserk and will have his cam ready for him. Merc can of course activate the mask before making his move, but to be honest I've seen almost none doing that, in my time. However, I don't think berserk is unbalanced at all, because in most cases the merc happens to knock only one spy out at a time; both getting fucked is very rare in my exprience. So, if you double team a merc and he gets you with a berserk, your mate has a chance to save you by tazing the merc and dropping a nade. If both spies get knocked down they kinda deserve that for being such idiots.

Also, if there will be no auto-aim for spies when trying to jump the merc, then I don't think berserk should neutralize any falling spies, because the chances of a merc being knocked out from hight altitudes becomes extremely low as you have to time your fall exactly right. (Although devs might want to make spies control their landing a bit for more accurate movement) If you can move freely mid air then berserk should harm spies trying to land on mercs.