Main Menu

Camnet

Started by Spekkio, October 28, 2007, 01:07:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Xan

Perhaps do a poll to see who would like camnet removed, who would like it changed and who would like the basic idea to remain the same.

After all if most people would prefer something else in the place of camnet it would be an awful waste of effort implementing it.

frvge

What about the following idea:

Mercs can have a gadget that plugs into several terminals around the map. He is now able to watch/cycle  through camnet.

Positive:
- limited places a Merc using camnet can be => easier target for grabs => probably less whoring.
- we can make it so that only 1 merc can view camnet at a time
- we can make it so that accessing and exiting the camnet system takes some time => visible clue for Spies to hide or to strike.
- Terminal placement can be balanced.

Neutral:
- May or may NOT take up a gadget slot.

Negative:
- ?
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

SITHDUKE

#167
Pros:
Some mobility and freedom while using Camnet

Cons:
Left rather vulnerable to cams and grabs
If Camnet is stripped of visions and laser while camo gets buffed to counter Camnet it could be boardering on flares for usefulness. It will have to be done carefully. Remember the idea is not to punish a merc for using his gadgets it should be a risk Vs. reward.

frvge

Hackable cage for Spies (6 seconds?), which is silent. Sticky Cams dont penetrate the cage.

'Aggroing' a Camnetting Merc takes time, but it also takes time for the Merc to go into and out of camnet.
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

Spekkio

#169
Quotea general problem is that by hunting the spies you leave the objectives and if they switch to aggro once you found them you are screwed. ways to avoid this problem with proper map design:
Well, that's the game. If the spy gets away, you should've killed him quicker. It's not like using camnet prevents the same thing. At least when the mercs have to use a patrol route, they open themselves up to being vulnerable and make the game move.

Unfortunately the meta-game has a lot of running around these days because of a general lack of passive security on a lot of maps. Oftentimes you can just bypass everything with just 1-2 chaffs. Camnet on some maps only encourages this because you have to keep the mercs moving, or else they just keep watching you.

Again, I'm generally of the opinion that passive defenses ought to be left up to the computer -- that includes cameras, lasers, etc. Yes, you can place mines and spytraps, but once you do the computer handles the detection part. That is mainly why I think camnet ought to be replaced by something different entirely, but it's also a large reason why I think that integrating camnet with security cameras is an absolutely horrible idea. Manual-izing (if that's a word) security cameras will not add to gameplay at all; it will simply detract from it because the player is doing something that the computer could do just fine. B1nary wrote a post that basically repeated "but the detection/viewing radius doesn't have to be the same" three times. Well, then why not just alter the detection radius and be done with it? There's absolutely no benefit to allowing the mercs to look through security cameras except to know instantly which one got shot out. As Invisible pointed out, that will just make people run through them and not bother, the same way that spies tend to start running around when they see that mercs have camnet now.

@Xan: camnet poll

http://sclamers.17.forumer.com/viewtopic.php?t=1473

frvge

[19:32] frvge: Merc wants camnet -> merc wants to terminal and presses RMB to use -> cage closes -> merc in camnet
[19:33] frvge: merc exists camnet -> -> cage protected by forcefield (anti-jump protection, also disables the Spy hack) cage unlocks -> merc walks out safely
[19:33] frvge: if there's a Spy wanting to grab the camnetting merc:
[19:33] frvge: spy sees merc enter cage
[19:33] frvge: (stupid merc! kill spy first!)
[19:33] frvge: spy hacks cage, cage opens, spy grabs merc
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

Succubus Dryad Of The Undying Comet

Or make camnet not work in the area the camnetting merc is - say the Cameras are used as links to the camnet.

frvge

Also an option.

I think the addition of a third party is good. It doesn't directly interfere with the camnet, nor the merc nor the spy. It can add extra rules for hacking/grabbing and stuff. These rules can be used to fine-tune and balance the game.
Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

InvisibleMan999

Here's my list of camnet nerfs. In progressive stages:

Stage 1: Remove camnet visions. Possibly give camnet a new blurred filter to see through
Stage 2: Remove camnet zoom/laser. Include delay for activating camnet, perhaps it takes 1 second or so to establish a connection. So you can't quickly flip through cameras without taking at least a second of dead time to activate the device.
Stage 3: Make panning for camnet cameras automatic instead of player controlled.

frvge

Quote from: savior2006SCDA has more bugs than a rain forest.
Quote
Treat your customers with respect you make more customers. Treat your customers like pirates, you make more pirates.

neth

Ive already said that i'd prefer getting rid of this gadget entirely but heres what i think about frvge's idea:

1. There could be terminals partially built into walls (like banking machines ?) but not secured anyhow and that means no damn booths, back must remain uncovered while using.

2. If this exists it must take a slot - I like the Idea with card accessing terminals

3. accesing terminal should take a while - perhaps a loading screen visible by merc taking like 3 - 4 sec

4. When the camnet is loading it should show that - I like the idea that the cam blinks during loading time so the spy can react somehow and perhaps hide.

5. Visions - No EMF but MT is ok in case it does not detect camo at all.

6. Positions must be balanced and thats the hardest work to do.

7. Terminals and cams must look pro.

If it is done like this I may even like the idea.

InvisibleMan999

Wow. Neth you want to totally nerf the hell out of camnet. A 4 second load time? wtf? That's like forever in this game.


neth

ok maybe 4 is too much but 2-3 is ok

Gawain

the problem with camnet is not the ability to use it wherever you are, but camping with it close to the objectives and still seeing the important stuff going on at the other end of the map. i think this problem could be solved by clever camnet positioning / obstacles / lightning in fov of cam. some examples:
-factory: remove it from corridors on factory and add more shadows in main hall/obstacle
-museum: way more shadows needed, maybe camnet on cafe inside side should face in the other direction
-polar: camnet shouldn't be able to watch spawn, eg obstacles in the higher fov
-river mall: remove camnet in hologram room
etc
this+better camo+no special visions make camnet make it even harder to master and allow sneaking past it.

neth

#179
hmm, i want to ask about visions and camo.

Do you guys think that camo should be detected by MT even when spy is moving ?

My opinion is - no, cause I see no reason why MT should detect something which is detectable by 2nd vision.
If it was like that, it would also be a small step forward to prevent vision whoring.
It could work like "rock>scissors> paper" system and here that means: EMF>camo>MT. Makes sense ?


When its done like that, camnet could use MT cause there would be an effective counter - camo.
It would be like this then: camo>camnet MT>no camo running. Ofc in this case camnet would have no EMF and thats quite fair i guess. Its also a way not to nerf camnet too much - it could be a counter for aggroing spies. Aggroing spies can be seen by camnet without MT, so I see no reason why it cant be boosted a little.

Whats your opinion ?