One idea that just popped up in my head was about a way to maybe prevent MT camping. The idea is to add the wozzy sound that is for emf in ct to mt. It might stop people from having mt on while camping and waiting for the spy to drop a sound.
In PT there was actually a sound while MT was on, which served the purpose that you said. This was not included into CT, and I have it as a suggestion on my fix list thread.
Quote from: Frelli on May 10, 2007, 08:36:27 PM
One idea that just popped up in my head was about a way to maybe prevent MT camping. The idea is to add the wozzy sound that is for emf in ct to mt. It might stop people from having mt on while camping and waiting for the spy to drop a sound.
A good idea.
One could go a step further with this however.
Include the buzzing/whooshing noise - yes. But also have the merc lose his sound detector device.
This is something that would need balance testing, but the way I look at it is that if a merc wants as powerfull a device as a motion detector, he must be prepared to lose one of his other detection devices.
As long as 360 degree motion stays out of the initial build, this idea would definately cut down motion whoring. Which merc would would feel safe leaving it on always knowing his back is open to a spy simply running up without detection?
There'll still be EAX for normal audio, which can be an advantage for players who have EAX vs non-EAX players.
From what Scope said, a system where only one detection device could be active at a time, would be good. We can always say, that having too many system on simultaniously takes too much power, and would cause merc's power supply to overheat, thus eventually shutting it down. Maybe that could be a feature.
I don't even understand the problem (I don't have EAX). If this is a problem with MT, shouldn't this also be a problem without MT? Personally, I think everything will be fixed with MT once we remove EAX and motion detecting behind the merc.
And if the need be, to solve the nightvision problem, we could incorperate the distance of stuff from the merc into the shader. Blend stuff of like distances and contrast stuff of unlike distances. So a spy next to a wall will be blended together while a spy out in the corridor will contrast with the wall that's far away.
Quote from: Thy-Tormentor on May 11, 2007, 11:50:12 AM
From what Overstatement said...
I think you meant scope2005's post.
Oops. Heh, true. Pardon me.
QuoteI don't even understand the problem (I don't have EAX). If this is a problem with MT, shouldn't this also be a problem without MT? Personally, I think everything will be fixed with MT once we remove EAX and motion detecting behind the merc.
Nerf the detection radius, and you make aggro that much easier. MT needs a max distance like EMF, not a detection radius nerf.
Quote
And if the need be, to solve the nightvision problem, we could incorperate the distance of stuff from the merc into the shader.
If you are in a pitch-black shadow, MT will not invert it. For example, digger room if you don't blow the wall out. There are random spots along walls where this happens, too. Just fyi.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 11, 2007, 01:33:29 PM
Nerf the detection radius, and you make aggro that much easier. MT needs a max distance like EMF, not a detection radius nerf.
Assuming you are talking about the MT while being aggro'd, you'll be turning your head like crazy and once MT locks onto one spy, it will stay locked on for a couple of seconds regardless of where he is. And they'll probably be using chaff which makes MT useless.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 11, 2007, 01:33:29 PM
If you are in a pitch-black shadow, MT will not invert it. For example, digger room if you don't blow the wall out. There are random spots along walls where this happens, too. Just fyi.
Yeah, I don't really care about the night vision thing too. I just said it because it's a really cool programming idea!
Quote from: Spekkio on May 11, 2007, 01:33:29 PM
Nerf the detection radius, and you make aggro that much easier. MT needs a max distance like EMF, not a detection radius nerf.
I can certainly agree with that, though I've always believed that MT should be able to lock onto only a running spy that's behind you, that would prevent aggro, while not screwing over stealth people.
QuoteIf you are in a pitch-black shadow, MT will not invert it. For example, digger room if you don't blow the wall out. There are random spots along walls where this happens, too. Just fyi.
MT night vision, IMO shouldn't even exist. I'd like to see it work like the MT fix maps for CT where it doesn't invert shadows at all. If people want to see in the dark, they shouldn't be using MT, they should be using their flashlight.
QuoteMT needs a max distance like EMF, not a detection radius nerf.
affirmative. not something like a particular distance, but a smooth transition so that a spy far away can move quite quickly without being detected.
QuoteI can certainly agree with that, though I've always believed that MT should be able to lock onto only a running spy that's behind you, that would prevent aggro, while not screwing over stealth people.
If that's possible to program in, I'd be all for it. I'd also like an indicator on the merc's back if he's in red vision (similar to the visor) since it can detect you while he's not looking that way.
QuoteMT night vision, IMO shouldn't even exist. I'd like to see it work like the MT fix maps for CT where it doesn't invert shadows at all. If people want to see in the dark, they shouldn't be using MT, they should be using their flashlight.
I have to tell you that when Zed discovered how to do this, I was ecstatic. However, while playing the UMP maps that have this "fix", it really doesn't fix 75% of the problem with MT: if you so much as fart from across the map, the merc is going to turn around and start shooting at you. Also, the maps where MT whoring is most of a pain are ones with wide open rooms where you have to try to move from cover-to-cover (like Deftech outside or Sect 2 Station). Unfortunately, most of these maps are also well-lit enough to see the spies in MT anyway. The only map that really needed an MT fix to be balanced was Schermerhorn, because you have to move across the wide space in the train room and MT inverted the darkness. Good players use their flashlight, laser, and emf vision a lot already, so it really doesn't make a difference in regards to that. As Cataclysm once said, MT whoring is the crutch of a bad merc.
Put it this way: play bank and hack the lights. Notice how MT no longer inverts the shadows because the room is pitch black. Now MT whore it up and see if you can win. Also, if you find yourself using MT a lot in digger room, think about why that is: it's certainly not because it allows you to see in the dark.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 15, 2007, 06:35:44 PM
If that's possible to program in, I'd be all for it. I'd also like an indicator on the merc's back if he's in red vision (similar to the visor) since it can detect you while he's not looking that way.
I agree about the red indicator on the merc's back. That would definitely help. I wouldn't also mind if the merc gave off some kind of sound too while in MT, like a buzzing or whatever, so that he sort of gives away if he's nearby if he wants to MT whore.
One of the other big advantages of MT over flashlight is that you're much stealthier as well. Anyone can see a merc shining his bright light around. A merc in MT is considerably less detectable. You don't see a light shine around a corner before the merc rounds the bend. So I'd definitely want to make a merc in MT announce himself a bit more.
As far as programming it in, if we can program in MT as CT does it now, I think we'd definitely be able to program in a modification to vary detection speed, as it is now, all MT does is say "If speed > x, put a box around the spy". It's not especially difficult to just add another criteria that varies based on the merc's facing. I'm thinking any engine has to have basic functions to determine the distance and angle between two objects. I mean, without determining the angle we can't even program in a spy grab.
We could also be incorporate distance into the calculation too. I'm thinking something like.
close range (within vision): any motion triggers MT, even slowest speed.
medium range (within vision): can not trigger MT by slow crouching (possibly also allow slow walk too)
Long range (within vision): Only running triggers MT.
Medium range (out of vision): Only running triggers MT.
Long range (out of vision): MT doesn't trigger at all.
QuoteI have to tell you that when Zed discovered how to do this, I was ecstatic. However, while playing the UMP maps that have this "fix", it really doesn't fix 75% of the problem with MT: if you so much as fart from across the map, the merc is going to turn around and start shooting at you.
Yeah, which is why I propose more fixes than simply ditching the shadow inversion. Still though, getting rid of shadow inversion is definitely a positive move in my opinion and helps some of the problem. Hopefully coupled with some other fixes we can weaken MT sufficiently to get people using flashlights again.
^
"Hopefully coupled with some other fixes we can weaken MT sufficiently"
Wireframe? Guess that'd be too much. However, in my opinion it should be somehow annoying to use it.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 15, 2007, 06:35:44 PM
QuoteI can certainly agree with that, though I've always believed that MT should be able to lock onto only a running spy that's behind you, that would prevent aggro, while not screwing over stealth people.
If that's possible to program in, I'd be all for it. I'd also like an indicator on the merc's back if he's in red vision (similar to the visor) since it can detect you while he's not looking that way.
QuoteMT night vision, IMO shouldn't even exist. I'd like to see it work like the MT fix maps for CT where it doesn't invert shadows at all. If people want to see in the dark, they shouldn't be using MT, they should be using their flashlight.
I have to tell you that when Zed discovered how to do this, I was ecstatic. However, while playing the UMP maps that have this "fix", it really doesn't fix 75% of the problem with MT: if you so much as fart from across the map, the merc is going to turn around and start shooting at you. Also, the maps where MT whoring is most of a pain are ones with wide open rooms where you have to try to move from cover-to-cover (like Deftech outside or Sect 2 Station). Unfortunately, most of these maps are also well-lit enough to see the spies in MT anyway. The only map that really needed an MT fix to be balanced was Schermerhorn, because you have to move across the wide space in the train room and MT inverted the darkness. Good players use their flashlight, laser, and emf vision a lot already, so it really doesn't make a difference in regards to that. As Cataclysm once said, MT whoring is the crutch of a bad merc.
Put it this way: play bank and hack the lights. Notice how MT no longer inverts the shadows because the room is pitch black. Now MT whore it up and see if you can win. Also, if you find yourself using MT a lot in digger room, think about why that is: it's certainly not because it allows you to see in the dark.
I actually wouldnt mind if Motion-Tracking didnt add an overlay when enabled and looked something akin to Double Agent's "white outline" motion tracking, but not always active. If this was the case however, I would have to stand by my suggestion of disabling the sound detector when active, as there would be no real penalties for keeping it active constantly.
This way, nobody has to worry about it being used as makeshift NVG, and the merc is sufficiently penalised for over usage.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 15, 2007, 06:35:44 PM
QuoteI can certainly agree with that, though I've always believed that MT should be able to lock onto only a running spy that's behind you, that would prevent aggro, while not screwing over stealth people.
If that's possible to program in, I'd be all for it.
QuoteAlso, the maps where MT whoring is most of a pain are ones with wide open rooms where you have to try to move from cover-to-cover
You kinda confuse me... I's a bad idea to take away all usefull functions that are balanced + the functions that are not balanced. The aim should be, that a good player can't overuse one vision mode and has to rely on all of them. Imo all we shoud change are the inverted shadows, add some static noise, and allow spies farer away to move more quickly without being detected (or extend the detection time for larger distances so that small spaces between cover can be passed more quickly). But plz don't overdo this. If there would be a slow climb move + pitch black shadows/no inversion, it would cripple mt enough to balance it for maps like deftech (and no, the map itself wouldn't be balanced without further changes like the ones on spekkio's fix list).
Quote from: Gawain on May 17, 2007, 11:48:22 AM
The aim should be, that a good player can't overuse one vision mode and has to rely on all of them.
Well, the hard part is determining what MT's role is. MT right now performs the following functions:
-It acts as an anti-aggro vision, granting flashbang immunity, and the ability to track spies through smoke or detect an oncoming spy behind you.
-It acts as an excellent night vision in dark conditions granting shadow inversion.
-It acts as a way of detecting moving spies.
The real question is: When should we be using MT and what situations should we be using normal vision in?
To balance things out, normal vision needs to be better than MT at doing certain things.
It also seems that normal vision should be the main vision people should be using, since most of your graphics are present in normal vision, it's the screen people want to be looking at for the majority of the game, not the ugly MT vision.
QuoteThe aim should be, that a good player can't overuse one vision mode and has to rely on all of them.
They already do.
QuoteTo balance things out, normal vision needs to be better than MT at doing certain things.
Those things should be seeing in the distance and sound detection. The more I think about it, the more I like yours (or whoever said it) idea that the sound reticle shouldn't work in MT, but keep the 360 detection radius.
If I take the MT a bit further, what about the following changes (some are already proposed):
- Humming sound -> harder to hear
- Loss of ALL HUD functions. 'Yeah, it uses all of our power'-excuse. Even amount of bullets, and if you hit someone or not. Only thing that functions is the crosshair.
- Some visual (!) notification to the Spies that the Merc is in MT.
I think MT should be good for only one thing, detecting motion and making it extremely hard to see stationary spies. I don't see how limiting the detection field will help aggro, no one's explained it to me yet.
And if you're going to try to fix a problem, fix the problem! Don't add new stuff to balance it out...For example, MT is too powerful with nightvision? Change the shaders to undo that, don't take away the sound thing to balance it out... EAX + MT make camping mercs? Remove or dull EAX, don't add noise to balance it out...
The humming in PT worked ok.
Also how do you guys feel about an indicator for the spy that tells him he's been picked up by MT. Some kind of "there's a box around you, run like hell" alarm or something. It's not exactly realistic, but it would weaken MT some.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 22, 2007, 09:12:23 PM
Also how do you guys feel about an indicator for the spy that tells him he's been picked up by MT. Some kind of "there's a box around you, run like hell" alarm or something. It's not exactly realistic, but it would weaken MT some.
That's up to the spy to figure out.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 22, 2007, 07:17:25 PM
Those things should be seeing in the distance and sound detection. The more I think about it, the more I like yours (or whoever said it) idea that the sound reticle shouldn't work in MT, but keep the 360 detection radius.
Do we actually want MT to be the vision that sees into shadows, or would we prefer the flashlight do that?
Dudes, i got THE idea: let the motion view detect motion. sounds simple, but should work out perfectly, so that no other fixes besides the shadow inversion should be needed. it should set of when a rat is running around, birds scare up, wind is going through leaves or a courtain, a light is jittering etc. there are endless possibilities. the huge advantage is that each sector of a map can be balanced separately for mt. maybe the mercs can shoot the rats and the broken lights (would result in more shadows), close a shutter etc to make mt more reliable. it could also be funny if the spies get 5 rats as a new equipment, they could blow up mines, distract the mercs etc
i know i read a similar idea somewhere before, but imo it's the best solution. discuss. ;D
btw: im serious about this
That would completely screw MT's ability to counter aggro.
Quote from: Overstatement on May 25, 2007, 12:47:28 PM
That would completely screw MT's ability to counter aggro.
why that?
Well, when you're in smoke and you're looking around for boxes, you don't have the time to determine if it's a spy running towards you or something else. When you're being aggro'd, everything is a split second decision and since you don't have time (or it's impossible to tell), just looking at it (stopping your mouse) gives the a good chance for a spy to grab you.
well, that would only happen if its completely overdone. in most areas, a rat should be tripping mt say every 5 to 30 seconds, and the box of a small object like a rat far away could be quite small or somewhat and easy to distinguish from an aggroing spy. but it would be quite annyoing for a camping spy with mt, because he has to turn his head in order to check what set off mt ;)
there could also be aggro zones and non-aggro zones this way. btw, aggro is quite balanced, don't complain about it all the time.
Quote from: Gawain on May 25, 2007, 12:28:17 PM
Dudes, i got THE idea: let the motion view detect motion. sounds simple, but should work out perfectly, so that no other fixes besides the shadow inversion should be needed. it should set of when a rat is running around, birds scare up, wind is going through leaves or a courtain, a light is jittering etc. there are endless possibilities. the huge advantage is that each sector of a map can be balanced separately for mt. maybe the mercs can shoot the rats and the broken lights (would result in more shadows), close a shutter etc to make mt more reliable. it could also be funny if the spies get 5 rats as a new equipment, they could blow up mines, distract the mercs etc
i know i read a similar idea somewhere before, but imo it's the best solution. discuss. ;D
It's too elaborate and map dependent. I'd rather just have a fix that works in all maps, rather than relying on map designers to put in rats and moving shutters. That's a lot of extra coding to program in the motion of rats and things.
Also, while this change will certainly make you more paranoid, it's not really going to change balance that much, except against aggro. Most of the time, you've still got time to check your back then snap around to the front when you realize it was a rat, except when you're running through smoke fighting an aggro spy. Really the change amounts to discouraging MT whoring by annoying the hell out of the merc using it.
Quote from: frvge on May 22, 2007, 08:46:19 PM
- Loss of ALL HUD functions. 'Yeah, it uses all of our power'-excuse. Even amount of bullets, and if you hit someone or not. Only thing that functions is the crosshair.
I'm against that. MT's main purpose is to make chasing spies easier. Chasing spies includes shooting at them; and the reason there is hit detection on your crosshair is because some servers require that you adjust your aim.
Quote from: Gawain on May 25, 2007, 01:38:14 PM
well, that would only happen if its completely overdone. in most areas, a rat should be tripping mt say every 5 to 30 seconds, and the box of a small object like a rat far away could be quite small or somewhat and easy to distinguish from an aggroing spy. but it would be quite annyoing for a camping spy with mt, because he has to turn his head in order to check what set off mt ;)
there could also be aggro zones and non-aggro zones this way. btw, aggro is quite balanced, don't complain about it all the time.
I never said aggro wasn't unbalanced but it will be if you make changes to MT without considering aggro. I've never switch on MT as soon as spy aggro me (instead, I start tazing like crazy) but most mercs you aggro do; so I think anti-aggro is one of the most important uses of MT.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 25, 2007, 07:31:36 PM
It's too elaborate and map dependent. I'd rather just have a fix that works in all maps, rather than relying on map designers to put in rats and moving shutters. That's a lot of extra coding to program in the motion of rats and things.
Also, while this change will certainly make you more paranoid, it's not really going to change balance that much, except against aggro. Most of the time, you've still got time to check your back then snap around to the front when you realize it was a rat, except when you're running through smoke fighting an aggro spy. Really the change amounts to discouraging MT whoring by annoying the hell out of the merc using it.
Now that he said it, I agree. First, you can't assume that someone will stop using something because they'll be annoyed anymore than you can assume that sniping running headshots will be impossible because the beta team couldn't do it. There are certainly people with enough patience to keep on using MT dispite it being annoying.
And the idea would kind of limit the map marker's creativity. For example, if he wants to put in an analog clock on the wall, it could make that room unbalanced (just an example, lots of things move). And it's more complicated than it seems, what if you shot the rat? Would another rat take it's place or have we just made MT stronger in that area?
Why does everyone want to nerf MT into oblivion? Like I said, with the exception of a few ill-conceived map designs, MT isn't that big of a deal.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 26, 2007, 12:18:55 AM
Why does everyone want to nerf MT into oblivion? Like I said, with the exception of a few ill-conceived map designs, MT isn't that big of a deal.
that's exactly why i think about stuff like rats. mt whoring is no real problem in most areas, but we need a solution for maps like deftech, polar etc (ok they'r crap anyway) and some big rooms like digger, main, etc. but if the spy could move a little bit faster in the slow-mode, and gets a slow-climb move, things might be balanced.
Or instead of rats we can have some remote gadget for the spies that makes MT crazy :P
Say you are on Mount Hospital - rats are ok there, but what about Vertigo plaza or some maps that are Hi-Tech (Krauser Lab)? There the spies should get a gadet that you can plant, and remotely activate to fool mercs, or just to prevent MT camping.
^Thats just my opinion - rats on dirty/ abandoned maps - additional gadget on Hi-Tech maps 8)
Quote from: Spekkio on May 26, 2007, 12:18:55 AM
Why does everyone want to nerf MT into oblivion? Like I said, with the exception of a few ill-conceived map designs, MT isn't that big of a deal.
One of the problems I have with MT is that it's unintuitive for the spy. As a merc, I rarely use MT so I have little idea of how much it nightvisions. So when I'm a spy and deciding where to hide, I judge the darkness on my screen and choose one that seems sufficient. And the mercs in normal vision and flashlight off seem to agree with me but the mercs with MT on don't. So it's not that it's overpowered by itself but it's just something that rarely consider when hiding. Intuitively, I think one hiding spot should work for everything that's not a flashlight.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 26, 2007, 12:18:55 AM
Why does everyone want to nerf MT into oblivion? Like I said, with the exception of a few ill-conceived map designs, MT isn't that big of a deal.
Well here's why. Comparing MT to flashlight.
Pro
-Long range shadow inversion on full screen, compared to short range flashlight.
-Detection of moving objects in 360 degrees wtihout any active player work. Even camo gets detected.
-Immunity to flashbangs
-Spy may not even know if he's been detected by MT, especially so if his back is turned.
-Doesn't announce your presence in advance to the spy.
-Spy has no indication he's been detected by MT.
Con
-can't see unmoving or creeping spy in total darkness.
All in all, there isn't much reason to use the flashlight, except in rare circumstances. I guess I've always felt MT should be a supplemental vision like EMF for special cases.
Now, I don't support any of these obscure rat ideas or things that will require a great deal of coding. This project has enough things to code just getting CT to work right. It's much easier to just apply conventional nerfs instead of getting elaborate.
As I see it, MT needs some (but not all) of the following nerfs.
-No shadow inversion
-Spy is allowed to move at normal crawl if merc is not facing his direction.
-Spy at long range can move faster.
-Maximum visual range.
-Indicator on merc's back to reveal he is in MT.
-Indicator for spy to indicate he's been placed in an MT box.
-Some kind of drawback, like turning off the sound detector.
-Noise emanating from merc, to alert spy that the merc is in MT, A way to announce the merc is coming.
-PT style static sound to screw up merc's mundane hearing.
Quote from: Gawain on May 26, 2007, 09:29:41 AM
Quote from: Spekkio on May 26, 2007, 12:18:55 AM
Why does everyone want to nerf MT into oblivion? Like I said, with the exception of a few ill-conceived map designs, MT isn't that big of a deal.
that's exactly why i think about stuff like rats. mt whoring is no real problem in most areas, but we need a solution for maps like deftech, polar etc (ok they'r crap anyway) and some big rooms like digger, main, etc. but if the spy could move a little bit faster in the slow-mode, and gets a slow-climb move, things might be balanced.
The solution is to not make shitty maps.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 26, 2007, 09:42:11 PM
The solution is to not make shitty maps.
Well, lots of maps tend to be flawed in that regard. I mean, MT is so good, I pretty much use it on everything. It spots spies in factory, spots spies through grated ceilings, like the top of showroom in river mall or above the blue tank room in Aqua. Will spot spies quite far away, so that you can wander about factory just waiting for them to ping the MT.
The problem is that the supposed counter to MT, standing still or moving slowly, doesn't really work because your sight is still fine in MT. So if you don't move, it won't stop the merc from just seeing you and shooting you down. You can't exactly move to cover either because the motion itself puts the big box of doom around you. Your only real option is to shoot the merc and try to run or aggro. In any case, you're forced to reveal your presence, making it a no-win situation for a stealth spy. Camo isn't even a big deal because you can flick from EMF to MT and back with zero activation time (unlike turning on MT or EMF from normal).
I so rarely use normal vision. Mostly for me, it's MT and EMF cycling and that's it. Occasionally if I want to check a deep shadow I may flashlight it for a second, but that's rather rare. Its a safe bet that if I'm in normal vision, it's because a spy SS or chaffed me. As it is now, I really don't see any advantage to using normal vision.
The counter to MT is to shock the merc in the head (which I think there should be some indication if you do). Regardless, if the map is designed well then there will be routes where you don't have to go through the merc. For example, in River Mall you don't have to take that grated ceiling up to offices...you could leave through the lower corridor.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 26, 2007, 08:58:50 PM
-No shadow inversion
-Spy is allowed to move at normal crawl if merc is not facing his direction.
-Spy at long range can move faster.
-Maximum visual range.
-Indicator on merc's back to reveal he is in MT.
-Indicator for spy to indicate he's been placed in an MT box.
-Some kind of drawback, like turning off the sound detector.
-Noise emanating from merc, to alert spy that the merc is in MT, A way to announce the merc is coming.
-PT style static sound to screw up merc's mundane hearing.
Some of those are just too much. Let me elaborate.
If a spy at long range is allowed to move faster, then there is no reason to add the "spy behind merc is allowed to move faster".
Indicator informing a spy that they have been detected - that's a no no. Let's not spoonfeed them with everything, huh? The merc's visor is glowing red, you've been moving fast - you are detected. The merc's behaviour is usually enough indication.
With all the other nerfs, removing the sound detector is just OTT.
Noise from the merc? Come on... the heavy footsteps are enough anyway.
I'd also like to add that if you fix the flashlight not working with sniper, as it did in PT, you'd see a lot more flashlight use.
maybe spies with camo should be allowed to move more quickly at lower ranges than spies without?
Quote from: Gawain on May 27, 2007, 11:31:03 AM
maybe spies with camo should be allowed to move more quickly at lower ranges than spies without?
Why?
That is contradictory to the whole point of camo. It'll make you almost invisible but you can't move fast or else it'll stop working.
Why don't we simply make it permanent and you can run around with it whenever you want without it stop working. And even better, while at it, let's make it that EMF DOESN'T DETECT IT!!!!1
Quote from: Gui Brazil on May 27, 2007, 02:43:17 PM
It'll make you almost invisible
fsure
i'm not talking about running mindlessly around, but atm camo is pretty useless as one merc even without camnet can, for example, cover main hall (factory) just by standing in the middle and switching mt on. sorry, but that's ridiculous if there's no counter to something such primitive than not being in his line of view. maybe "-Spy at long range can move faster" will fix this
Yeah, the thing in Main Hall in Factory is really annoying - and it gets even worse, when the guy is a good sniper -.-
Look, MT does need some tweaking, but it doesn't need the drastic nerfs that you guys are calling for. You all are really over-estimating how useful it is, as if it automatically finds spies for you all on its own. As for Factory main hall, MT does not detect a spy climbing the ladder to the top of the room unless you are standing right in front of spy spawn, and if a merc is standing deep in MH that means that either digger or machine is wide open, both rooms can be reached without crossing the wide open area of main hall. The hard task of stealthing factory is getting around camnet, which is doable with some decent timing, not motion tracking.
If there is no shadow inversion and it only works in FoV at a short range with no sound reticle functionality, there will be no reason at all to use MT except to shield yourself from flashbangs while being aggroed. If that's the case, you're better off using EMF anyway because it'll let you see the lit up spy who has to use thermal vision to see through his smoke grenades. In DA, I would rather have an option to turn MT off than have a redundant outline around spies that I can already see.
Quote from: Valserp on May 27, 2007, 03:24:22 AM
Some of those are just too much. Let me elaborate.
If a spy at long range is allowed to move faster, then there is no reason to add the "spy behind merc is allowed to move faster".
Well, there is. Basically it's to allow medium range spies to sneak a bit better. Now keep in mind that when I say move faster, I just mean a fast speed crouch, not a full run. Full run will always trigger MT. regardless of distance or merc orientation.
Quote
Indicator informing a spy that they have been detected - that's a no no. Let's not spoonfeed them with everything, huh? The merc's visor is glowing red, you've been moving fast - you are detected. The merc's behaviour is usually enough indication.
Well MT can be difficult to figure out if you were detected or not. Especially since it detects you by default going at normal crouch speed, which is 90% of the time what most spies are doing. A lot of the time you really don't know if a merc happened to MT you before you got behind cover.
I figure that since MT is automatic for the merc, requiring no actual real vision, it should be automatic for the spy as well, telling him if he got detected.
Quote
The counter to MT is to shock the merc in the head (which I think there should be some indication if you do).
But the problem isn't that MT is too powerful against aggro. Nobody is saying that.
The problem is MT versus stealth spies, and if you're a stealth spy, shooting the merc doesn't cut it as a counter. To get a headshot, you'll have to be close, and you'll have to turn on your gun's laser. This pings the mercs sound detector. Now speaking as a motion whore, if I see a sound ping and no MT box, I'm immediately switching to EMF. So a shooting spy is going to give away his position.
Quote
If there is no shadow inversion and it only works in FoV at a short range with no sound reticle functionality, there will be no reason at all to use MT except to shield yourself from flashbangs while being aggroed. If that's the case, you're better off using EMF anyway because it'll let you see the lit up spy who has to use thermal vision to see through his smoke grenades. In DA, I would rather have an option to turn MT off than have a redundant outline around spies that I can already see.
Well I don't think anyone is saying to nerf it that severely. Though I think ditching shadow inversion is necessary, because it phases out the flashlight almost completely.
MT really is very powerful though. Speaking as a motion whore myself, it's very good. It's really the presence detector of CT. Very minimal work required, you just do a basic patrol and see if it pings something. If you know the general vicinity of the spy, generally he has three options, stay still in deep shadow and hope you leave, make a break for it, go for a head shot. One of those is a phenomenal waste of time for the spy and the other two are almost assured to give away his position against a decent merc. MT in large rooms, like the main hall of factory, practically eliminates the need to actually look for spies manually. You just run around the room with MT and wait for it to put someone in a box. It has very little thought and it's highly effective.
MT is right now the biggest obstacle to stealth players.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 27, 2007, 07:02:13 PM
MT is right now the biggest obstacle to stealth players.
no, camnet is. but camnet requires timing and has some disadvantages, so it's ok.
if we disable the shadow inversion and allow spies far away to crouch without being detected, it should be balance out quite well. don't consider crappy maps like deftech as an paradigm how overpowered mt is. another idea: slightely increasing the detection time for spies far away, so that crouching from cover to cover gets easier and little mistakes do not result in giving away your position.
the challenge is to keep mt as a useful gadget. btw, will the ghosting totaly be removed in emf?
lol camnet rules and i use it all the time but i only use it at the begin of the game and whenever i cannot see the spies for some time.. or just randomly turn it on to see but that all depends.. like clubhouse, if the spies are doing coop and you try camnet you cannot see them and thats a disadvantage as for all the toher maps there are disadvantages with camnet.. and mt
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 27, 2007, 07:02:13 PM
Well, there is. Basically it's to allow medium range spies to sneak a bit better.
You're almost trying to take the MT out of the game. I mean, medium range? Seriously, if we do something like that, we'll be just making something near a new DA. Beside, it seems, atleast to me, that you're trying to make MT something so useless, that it won't even be used.
Quote
Well MT can be difficult to figure out if you were detected or not. Especially since it detects you by default going at normal crouch speed, which is 90% of the time what most spies are doing. A lot of the time you really don't know if a merc happened to MT you before you got behind cover.
Shame on you for running around when a merc is right in front of you with MT. And if he's with his back to you, how can you be sure that he's not with MT to move fast?
just add a static noise, fix the shadow inversion, and allow spies really far away to crouch in normal speed. maybe even this is too much...
By the way, I believe that MT should assist the merc in navigating in dark areas(since it's primarily made for chasing spies, and doing that isn't easy in a pitch-blck room). Therefore, shadow inversion isn't all that bad as long as there is some way to make a non/or slow/-moving spy transparent.
u can use emf for navigation purposes lol
Quote from: Gawain on May 29, 2007, 06:58:15 PM
u can use emf for navigation purposes lol
So I switch on MT to chase a running spy lol, but we enter a dark room lol and I have to switch to emf just to navigate lol? So once we're out of the room lol and he's behind some cover lol I totally lose track of him lol woudn't that suck lol?
Quote from: Gui Brazil on May 29, 2007, 02:21:04 AM
You're almost trying to take the MT out of the game. I mean, medium range? Seriously, if we do something like that, we'll be just making something near a new DA. Beside, it seems, atleast to me, that you're trying to make MT something so useless, that it won't even be used.
Note that I'm not saying spies can "run", just that they can move at their normal fast crouch.
Running should always be picked up by MT, regardless of range. At some distances or merc orientations however, I think you should be able to crouch move at normal speed.
Quote
Shame on you for running around when a merc is right in front of you with MT. And if he's with his back to you, how can you be sure that he's not with MT to move fast?
You do realize that by "move fast", you mean anything faster than going at your absolutely slowest crouching speed.
Quote from: Valserp on May 29, 2007, 03:38:47 PM
By the way, I believe that MT should assist the merc in navigating in dark areas(since it's primarily made for chasing spies, and doing that isn't easy in a pitch-blck room). Therefore, shadow inversion isn't all that bad as long as there is some way to make a non/or slow/-moving spy transparent.
Well, One of the easiest pursuit techniques is just to follow the spy's trail. After all, MT shows you that.
I wouldn't be against keeping shadow inversion and just making the spy transparent though. That sounds fine, though it would nerf MT quite a bit.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 29, 2007, 08:33:39 PM
Quote from: Gui Brazil on May 29, 2007, 02:21:04 AM
You're almost trying to take the MT out of the game. I mean, medium range? Seriously, if we do something like that, we'll be just making something near a new DA. Beside, it seems, atleast to me, that you're trying to make MT something so useless, that it won't even be used.
Note that I'm not saying spies can "run", just that they can move at their normal fast crouch.
Running should always be picked up by MT, regardless of range. At some distances or merc orientations however, I think you should be able to crouch move at normal speed.
I know that you're saying walking at a normal speed and that, doesn't change my opinion about it.
Quote
Shame on you for running around when a merc is right in front of you with MT. And if he's with his back to you, how can you be sure that he's not with MT to move fast?
Quote
You do realize that by "move fast", you mean anything faster than going at your absolutely slowest crouching speed.
I do know that, and that doesn't change my opinion about it, either.
Quote from: Gui Brazil on May 29, 2007, 09:44:09 PM
I do know that, and that doesn't change my opinion about it, either.
I'm kind of curious why you think that being able to move at normal crouch speeds at medium range while a merc's back is turned without setting off MT is so broken. I mean is it too much to ask that the merc at least be looking in the direction of the spy to sense him with such precision?
I'd really like to make MT less of a newb vision. It's bad enough to get the box when you're looking at the spy, it's even worse when your back is turned to the spy and he can't even fast crouch from cover to cover.
I mean, is it really that bad to ask that the merc at least face the right direction to pick up a spy on MT at medium ranges? Lets have it require some degree of skill.
invisible cmon ::)
the big problem with mt is overlooking huge areas from sniping spots, and the shadow inversion. there are already enough possibilities to play stealth, and mercs couldn't cover big maps like factory well if spies could move around mindlessly. and don't forget, the merc can turn his head like nuts...
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 29, 2007, 11:40:25 PM
I mean, is it really that bad to ask that the merc at least face the right direction to pick up a spy on MT at medium ranges? Lets have it require some degree of skill.
At first I thought the same. But at the same when I was thinking it I was playing against an insane aggro team. After the game finished, I thought to myself "thank the Splinter Cell-God for MT's detection radius".
Sure, it's a bitch on stealthy spies, but it's a necessity against aggro spies. What it needs is a slight nerf to encourage stealth, but not too much - for it can make aggro too powerful.
Note: Also, you can always depend on cover and vents to avoid detection. "But I want to move from cover to cover" you say? "The merc just stands there with MT on!". Well, wait for him to turn his back, shock him and move away. You play stealthy, right? Surely you know how to get out of sight in 3 seconds.
good point
Quote from: Valserp on May 30, 2007, 01:21:50 AM
At first I thought the same. But at the same when I was thinking it I was playing against an insane aggro team. After the game finished, I thought to myself "thank the Splinter Cell-God for MT's detection radius".
Sure, it's a bitch on stealthy spies, but it's a necessity against aggro spies. What it needs is a slight nerf to encourage stealth, but not too much - for it can make aggro too powerful.
No it wouldn't because running always triggers MT. regardless of distance or merc orientation. I'm just saying that you should be able to fast crouch when at medium range and behind the merc, or while at long range in front of the merc. If you do a standing run at any distance, you get picked up. Period. Aggro players will get detected easy on MT.
I'm not sure why this sounds so uber to everyone. I mean, it's not like a spy can't also be detected with normal vision and flashlight. Yes, this change will require people use their flashlights more often. It will require mercs to actually search for the spy instead of just waiting for their MT box to go off. Yes, you are going to need to turn MT *off* now and then. That's a good thing.
This change doesn't make it more difficult to hold off aggro spies either.
Quote
Note: Also, you can always depend on cover and vents to avoid detection. "But I want to move from cover to cover" you say? "The merc just stands there with MT on!". Well, wait for him to turn his back, shock him and move away. You play stealthy, right? Surely you know how to get out of sight in 3 seconds.
Stealth isn't giving away your position by shocking the merc.
Most of the time, this will get you killed. the instant you draw your gun for the head shot, his sound detector pings and he does a 180. He doesn't see you moving so he switches to EMF. Even if you succeed on the head shot (which is tough against a moving merc at medium range), he still likely has a fix on your position and has a good idea where you're going to run to. Even if you do pull it off, the merc now knows that you're in that room somewhere. Likely he even has a good guess of which part of the room. I don't mind spies shooting me when I'm the merc. If they want to do my job for me and give themselves away, then great.
Also, if the only counter to MT is shooting the merc and getting him out of it, then MT really is the uber vision.
if you cant wait until the merc leaves, you can taze and run. if you manage to taze him in the back or drop flash on him, you can run very far in 3 seconds and he has to guess where you have been gone.
just try full running with rolls and see how far you get in 3 seconds, it's really insane...
Yeah, and if you managed to get a chaff and a smoke in the way, you can get about double distance without being spotted (at a straight escape) ;D
Quote from: Gawain on May 30, 2007, 10:58:11 PM
if you cant wait until the merc leaves, you can taze and run. if you manage to taze him in the back or drop flash on him, you can run very far in 3 seconds and he has to guess where you have been gone.
just try full running with rolls and see how far you get in 3 seconds, it's really insane...
Isn't it hard enough to sneak past a merc in normal vision who can turn super fast?
You can go pretty far, but running full speed is also a great way to get yourself blown up by mines, trip a spytrap or even static defenses. In any case, you'll give away your position pretty quick doing that.
And besides, this is a stealth game. It's okay if I sneak past a merc in normal sight or EMF, but I can't sneak past a merc in MT? Why is that? Because he's seeing in ubervision and can completely nullify stealth? But that's okay, because you can just aggro him to death.
Oh wait, MT is great against aggro too.
But yeah, there's no problem with MT. It's just perfect as is. So perfect that you might as well never use your flashlight. Ever.
::rolls eyes::
Maybe we should change the name from Project stealth to project taze-and-run.
No one's saying that MT is perfect, but the idea of being able to move more quickly at X range than Y range is gay because it's impossible to know exactly where that line is in-game.
To be honest, if a merc is just standing there looking in one direction, you can usually sneak by him by creeping. You can do the same if he's in normal vision. In reality, the mercs are going to be looking around no matter what. What you're so vehemently arguing for wouldn't change a darn thing.
dude, it's MOTION tracking. only on bad maps like deftech a merc can camp with mt and win. usually the merc has to patrol; if he doesn't, there are plenty ways of distracting him. so just sit still, slow crouch, distract him (teamwork, snares, etc), shoot a well placed cam or aggro him ffs.
My sentiments exactly.
If there's any problem with MT, it's that it can detect stationary spies, not that it detects MOTION as its name implies. I'd be more for an EMF type translucency than modifying the shadow inversion to fix that, though.
idk i really see no problem with mt whoring or w.e u guys are complaining about or wanting to change. i would just say keep it the same period.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 31, 2007, 01:09:13 AM
No one's saying that MT is perfect, but the idea of being able to move more quickly at X range than Y range is gay because it's impossible to know exactly where that line is in-game.
Sure it is. You do it by feel. That's like saying it's gay that emf has a limited range because it's impossible to know where that range ends. Hell, even the sound detector has an enigmatic range. We can live with it.
Quote
To be honest, if a merc is just standing there looking in one direction, you can usually sneak by him by creeping. You can do the same if he's in normal vision. In reality, the mercs are going to be looking around no matter what. What you're so vehemently arguing for wouldn't change a darn thing.
Well, yes it will, because MT doesn't activate instantly. It takes about a second or so, and you'd have to have the spy in your view the whole time to trigger the detection, so I think it would make a difference.
If you have a hard time spotting a stationary spy with mt even if he's close to you (camo=invisible to mt btw) you have to cycle through your visions. maybe we could make camo stronger, but quite easy to be seen if spotlighted by the merc's flash light (it needs a range buff anyway, maybe it should be focusable like in sc:da). and i like the shader idea, that there is the less contrast the closer an object is to the wall. PS really shouldn't change too much in the first version, i'm sure the gameplay will change quite a lot alone with the fixes from spekkio's list and smooth aiming+no lagg.
Or you can simply make the merc see only moving objects in MT, so he doesnt see the map or anything, only when something moves, he sees a box - that would make MT harder, while spies would have bigger chanses to hide in the dark.
lol imagining mercs running blinly around the map and into obstacles XD
but the idea is bad as it would encourage camping
Nah, i don't think so, the mercs still wouldn't be able to see spies that are creeping, and cause of that, they will have to move - i mean the spies can't hide forever
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on May 30, 2007, 10:48:45 PM
Quote from: Valserp on May 30, 2007, 01:21:50 AM
At first I thought the same. But at the same when I was thinking it I was playing against an insane aggro team. After the game finished, I thought to myself "thank the Splinter Cell-God for MT's detection radius".
Sure, it's a bitch on stealthy spies, but it's a necessity against aggro spies. What it needs is a slight nerf to encourage stealth, but not too much - for it can make aggro too powerful.
No it wouldn't because running always triggers MT. regardless of distance or merc orientation. I'm just saying that you should be able to fast crouch when at medium range and behind the merc, or while at long range in front of the merc. If you do a standing run at any distance, you get picked up. Period. Aggro players will get detected easy on MT.
I'm not sure why this sounds so uber to everyone. I mean, it's not like a spy can't also be detected with normal vision and flashlight. Yes, this change will require people use their flashlights more often. It will require mercs to actually search for the spy instead of just waiting for their MT box to go off. Yes, you are going to need to turn MT *off* now and then. That's a good thing.
This change doesn't make it more difficult to hold off aggro spies either.
Quote
Note: Also, you can always depend on cover and vents to avoid detection. "But I want to move from cover to cover" you say? "The merc just stands there with MT on!". Well, wait for him to turn his back, shock him and move away. You play stealthy, right? Surely you know how to get out of sight in 3 seconds.
Stealth isn't giving away your position by shocking the merc.
Most of the time, this will get you killed. the instant you draw your gun for the head shot, his sound detector pings and he does a 180. He doesn't see you moving so he switches to EMF. Even if you succeed on the head shot (which is tough against a moving merc at medium range), he still likely has a fix on your position and has a good idea where you're going to run to. Even if you do pull it off, the merc now knows that you're in that room somewhere. Likely he even has a good guess of which part of the room. I don't mind spies shooting me when I'm the merc. If they want to do my job for me and give themselves away, then great.
Also, if the only counter to MT is shooting the merc and getting him out of it, then MT really is the uber vision.
Agreed.
Mercs should not be able to detect crouched running spies BEHIND them AT ANY DISTANCE though.
we should give the SS full auto aim, so that the spy always hits first
Yeah, that would make sense, but only if there was auto-aim for the first shot, because otherways, the spies would just run around and shock teh emrcs
u didnt get it, did u oO
Wouldn't this be abused like how sometimes when I charge, the autoaim tells me there is a spy near by? Wouldn't this make shooting a merc in the head, trivial? Why do we autoaim? That was a pretty random suggestion.
not on the head, but on the body. and the spies should know that there is a merc if they wanna taze him lol
I've never really seen a spy have too much trouble shooting a merc, I mean you get like 6 shots. It would be really annoying for a spy to shoot you and your buddy and still have the energy to go into camo a second later. What if the spy wants to shoot the head, what if he wants to shoot a boom boom on the map, what if he wants to deploy some kind of equipment. I think it's just a useless (and random) idea.
Quote from: Gawain on May 31, 2007, 08:59:34 PM
we should give the SS full auto aim, so that the spy always hits first
Auto hit the merc, um no... that'd be way too broken.
You could maybe make it so drawing the gun with laser sight no longer pings the sound detector, but that's about it. Even that change is not something I'd be enthusiastic about.
Really, I think the shocker gun is fine. If we are thinking about buffing it because MT is a problem, we're better off just nerfing MT.
And keep in mind that even if we nerf MT so hard that it's just good as anti-aggro vision, we won't impact the gameplay all that much. I mean imagine if you couldn't motion whore, at all. Does this make it impossible to beat a stealth team?
Are stealth spies going to walk all over us if we're allowed to motion whore? Really, I think MT has made us far too complacent and we're too used to relying on it to find spies and do our own work for us.
Quote from: Gawain on May 31, 2007, 08:59:34 PM
we should give the SS full auto aim, so that the spy always hits first
What if you don't want to shoot at the merc? In any event, the first shot auto-aims as is. If you're missing it's because you either moved the mouse or have high ping.
QuoteAre stealth spies going to walk all over us if we're allowed to motion whore? Really, I think MT has made us far too complacent and we're too used to relying on it to find spies and do our own work for us.
Speak for yourself. Good stealth spies can get around MT, and good mercs don't MT whore.
As it's been said 5,000 times in this thread, there are ways around MT in its current state. What you're basically saying is that you don't like it so you want the game to be catered to you.
the autoaim for the first shot doesn't work on moving mercs. all i want are more predictable consequences for similar situations.
Quote from: Spekkio on May 31, 2007, 11:58:26 PM
Speak for yourself. Good stealth spies can get around MT, and good mercs don't MT whore.
As it's been said 5,000 times in this thread, there are ways around MT in its current state. What you're basically saying is that you don't like it so you want the game to be catered to you.
The only way around MT that I've heard is shooting the merc in the head, and then making a run for it.
I've already refuted that as a good tactic, given that it's hard to get head shots against a moving merc (which is any merc who isnt' a total newb) and your gun gives off sound when you draw it. Going for these miracle head shots just isn't going to work very well. Most of the time you're going to get taken out trying that. At the very least, you compromise your position and risk blowing yourself to hell on a mine when you make your suicide run after shocking the merc.
It's a terrible tactic and sadly it's your only option against MT.
Seriously, I know this MT crap, cause I motion whore all the time... It is crazy powerful. One way or the other, it will reveal the spy's position. I love it when the spy tries to shoot me, then I just switch to EMF and blow the hell out of him.
Seems to me you want the only counter to MT to be run and gun on the merc. What if I want to sneak past him?
Quote from: Gawain on May 31, 2007, 01:18:52 AM
dude, it's MOTION tracking. only on bad maps like deftech a merc can camp with mt and win. usually the merc has to patrol; if he doesn't, there are plenty ways of distracting him. so just sit still, slow crouch, distract him (teamwork, snares, etc), shoot a well placed cam or aggro him ffs.
this + stealth routes + good map (+ maybe autoaim for spies)
i hate having to quote myself -.-
you want to know the easiest stealth counter to mt whoring? just don't make quick movements in the same room as the merc is...
if the shadow inversion (and the eax camo noise bullshit) get's fixed, this will be an even more powerful counter.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 01, 2007, 01:04:39 AM
The only way around MT that I've heard is shooting the merc in the head, and then making a run for it.
If the merc is standing at a certain place and mt whoring, there's atleast 1 or 2 ways to get to your objective that are not being covered at that particular moment. If you know the map and you're a good stealth player, you'll be able to get pass that merc. Beside, you can always get your mate to do distractions.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 01, 2007, 01:04:39 AM
Quote from: Spekkio on May 31, 2007, 11:58:26 PM
Speak for yourself. Good stealth spies can get around MT, and good mercs don't MT whore.
As it's been said 5,000 times in this thread, there are ways around MT in its current state. What you're basically saying is that you don't like it so you want the game to be catered to you.
The only way around MT that I've heard is shooting the merc in the head, and then making a run for it.
Yeah, I didn't say "to the head", but you just refuse to get it.
This game is not designed for full stealth. There - has - to - be - interaction - between - the - teams. Therefore you are sometimes forced into shocking the merc. WOW BIG DEAL you can hide in about 47 different places by the time he gets unshocked. If you lack creativity - you die, gg.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 01, 2007, 01:04:39 AM
Seems to me you want the only counter to MT to be run and gun on the merc. What if I want to sneak past him?
Sneak past his position by using another route maybe? Really, there's plenty of those(on the balanced maps ofcourse. Please, don't think Warehouse)
dudes, if you don't believe me, at least listen to valserp and spekkio.
but tbh, we need better map design than most ct maps; on a good map, the mercs have to patrol or at least to use camnet/spytraps. atm on most maps the mercs can camp in 2 positions and wait for the spies to give away their location. this is not the best way for the mercs of course, but it works quite fine. the problem with open maps however is that they tend to reduce the strat to just running around in circles or hack-taze-run. i think much of the anger about mt comes from bad map design.
I agree on the poor map design. I have been studying the CT maps lately and it really does come down to the spies have too few alternate routes. Consider the spawn point for spies in museum. There is the ceiling, the fan vent and the main entry. A good merc team can keep the spies from ever seeing the back half of the map.
The problem also exists that there are too few hacking points in the maps or they are poorly placed. A good example is deftech. A spy must hack 2 of the 3 objectives. The only problem being that the objectives in B and C are too close together and most merc teams will let the spies take A, because two mercs covering B and C is near impossible to break through. Not to mention mercs will know the second a spy enters either building. Shooting out the levels defenses immediately lets the mercs know you are in, and the shocking sound can be heard.
I wonder if implementing a system like in coop for CT where one spy can disable a security system with their gun aimed at it to let the other spy pass would be a great way to get around undetected.
Quote from: Innocent-US on June 01, 2007, 10:27:06 PM
I agree on the poor map design. I have been studying the CT maps lately and it really does come down to the spies have too few alternate routes.
i'd love to see more routes the merc have to watch, but this also encourages aggro. and i don't wanna see more vents/spy only zones, because they suck.
Quote from: Innocent-US on June 01, 2007, 10:27:06 PM
I wonder if implementing a system like in coop for CT where one spy can disable a security system with their gun aimed at it to let the other spy pass would be a great way to get around undetected.
i'd love to see more coop moves, and this sounds kinda interesting to me. but didn't we have another thread for new coop move ideas?
yea we had i think and also we had other threads that suddenly become new ones again
QuoteI agree on the poor map design. I have been studying the CT maps lately and it really does come down to the spies have too few alternate routes. Consider the spawn point for spies in museum. There is the ceiling, the fan vent and the main entry. A good merc team can keep the spies from ever seeing the back half of the map.
I don't know if you were around for it, but now imagine PT where all those entrances had either a camera or motion sensor on it, and once you shot that out you had 24 random lasers strewn throughout the map....yeaaaa.
at least it stopped the mindless running in circles XD
we just need more maps where the merc has to patrol to beat a stealthy team.
Quote from: Gawain on June 01, 2007, 06:31:19 PM
dudes, if you don't believe me, at least listen to valserp and spekkio.
but tbh, we need better map design than most ct maps; on a good map, the mercs have to patrol or at least to use camnet/spytraps. atm on most maps the mercs can camp in 2 positions and wait for the spies to give away their location. this is not the best way for the mercs of course, but it works quite fine. the problem with open maps however is that they tend to reduce the strat to just running around in circles or hack-taze-run. i think much of the anger about mt comes from bad map design.
Nah. You don't want maps that have too many spy routes and/or too big, otherwise it becomes a matter of spies just shocking and running around using superior speed to speed hack things.
This is exactly the sort of paradigm I want to avoid. I dont' want to turn the game into DA where you're basically facing mercs who can detect your presence easily and your main recourse is either attacking them or going another route altogether.
As spekkio said earlier, interaction is important and I don't disagree with that. Though I do disagree on the kinds of interaction. Interaction doesn't always have to be shooting the merc or getting into a run and gun battle with him. Interaction just means that the two have to come close enough where the actions of one can influence the other.
Or to be more specific: the merc needs a chance to detect the spy. The basic stealth contest is that the spy is trying not to be detected and the merc is trying to detect him.
One thing that's kind of nice about big open areas is that they give the merc that chance. It's tense when you're creeping through the shadows, hoping the merc doesn't shine his light on you or come in your direction. That's what I think this game should be all about.
It's no fun when you're dealing with the merc who happens to be patrolling the room and can see in 360 degrees anytime you move. Seriously, it's hard enough to be stealthy without automatically giving away your position anytime you move faster than slowest speed. MT just makes detection too effortless on the part of the merc. It's pretty bad when you can have your back turned to the spy and still detect him. Basically MT removes the need to patrol large rooms (beyond just moving a bit to make it harder to hit with the shocker). MT does all the work for you. Actually searching for spies with your flashlight is well... never used.
The main problem with MT is that it requires bigger levels and more spy routes to make it work. I mean we can claim it's poor map design if we want, but then we just move towards DA style maps where spies are constantly crawling in vents and such. This also improves aggro because it takes longer for a merc's partner to arrive. New maps aren't necessarily the answer.
But none of us actually want that. We want a game where spies and mercs interact. But interaction could just be slipping past a merc while his back is turned. The thing people are assuming for whatever reason, is that spies can't be detected by flashlight, or that the game will somehow fall apart if everyone doesn't motion whore.
Why are you all so afraid of a stealth game? Is it too hard to ask mercs to search out spies in normal vision with the flashlight? I mean, what's wrong with that?
omg spamming a long post doesn't give your arguments more weight. the main problem with mt is the shadow inversion and maybe that it detects crouching in long ranges. a not moving spy, especially in the shadows, or a spy in huge distance should be hardly or not visible at all with mt. if you can't get around a mt whoring merc, you have to get some skills. stealth is also about confusion and distraction, and it needs good team work just like aggro does in order to be effective. stealth will work much better after the eax bullshit and the emf ghosting is fixed, and aggro will get much harder with no host advantage/ smooth aiming/ hardly laggs. pure stealth and pure aggro should not work the best, but a mix of both with the emphasis on stealth should do.
if you really happen to be in a big room with a mt whoring camping merc, and your mate can't do any distraction, and you really can't get around him (it's quite easy in main hall factory for example, just use camo and climb the ladder), stop whining and fucking taze him. you have to adapt to the current situation...
QuoteWhy are you all so afraid of a stealth game?
We're not. You want to make stealth easy when it shouldn't be. Stealth is doable, you just have to take your time and be good at it.
he thinks ct is an aggro game lol. just go out and try aggro against a decent team on a good server and see what happens...
Well, he's also an Xboxer... :o.
But the actual balance of CT is fine...2 mercs > 2 spies > 1 merc > 1 spy in aggro situations. The problem is when some maps force 2 mercs and 2 spies to be in close proximity all the time, and the huge amount of bugs that plague the game.
Quote from: Spekkio on June 02, 2007, 04:58:31 PM
Well, he's also an Xboxer... :o.
haha sometimes i almost wanted to say this, thx that you did it :D
Quote from: Spekkio on June 02, 2007, 04:58:31 PM
Well, he's also an Xboxer... :o.
Well, yes I do primarily play CT on xbox now, but I played the PC version for quite some time too, as well as all my time playing PT was the PC version, so it's not like I don't know what I'm talking about with regards to the PC version, just because I play the xbox version right now. (which is mostly to get away from EAX and high res MT bullshit). Believe me, I logged a lot of hours playing the PC version too and I've said before, I was great at taking out stealth spies on either platform. Now arguably my xbox time gives me a somewhat bias towards anti-aggro, since aggro is much more powerful on the box than on PC. But keep in mind that stealth is also lots better on xbox too (no EAX, low res display, no post render). And I still feel as though stealth is underpowered even on the box. Good players on the box don't sneak past mercs, they just fire a bunch of stickies and hope one of them KOs the merc.
In fact, it probably gives me a little more insight into how good the motion detect of MT really is. On xbox you don't have high res displays or post render quality, and still, MT is freaking awesome. I regularly MT whore on xbox.
And honeslty, I really do have to call bullshit on the whole shock and run thing, on either platform.
seriously, it doesn't work nearly as well as you guys claim, and that's regardless of if you're playing xbox or PC. It's actually probably a *Better* tactic on xbox because the merc can't snipe you as fast on EMF. But even on the box, it sucks. When you shock the merc, you give yourself away to any decent merc. So as soon as you make a break for it, the merc knows what direction you've gone and now pursues. Seriously, it ain't that hard. If you're trying to infiltrate the back of the map that way, like museum or river mall, likely a shock and run strategy means you run headfirst into a proxy. Factory and orphanage is about the only maps where shock and run works okay on. Even on orphanage, you'll probably end up running into a mine or spytrap.
Shock and run is fine for an escape strategy, but it sucks as an infiltration strategy. It just doesn't last long enough for you to disarm any defenses the merc has left for you and any decent merc can guess where you went to.
As a side note, while Spekkio, and possibly the rest of you, do not believe that full stealth should be viable, the majority of people in this poll (taken on this forum) disagreed with you:
http://projectstealth.splintercellnetwork.com/index.php?topic=219.0 (http://projectstealth.splintercellnetwork.com/index.php?topic=219.0)
So if you want to make total stealth non-viable, then you're in the minority.
In closing, let me ask you guys this:
Taking aggro out of the equation, do you think the game turns into a one-sided total stealth match if MT were completely taken out of the game?
Or to ask it another way... Is MT whoring required to be in the game to beat stealth spies?
QuoteIt's actually probably a *Better* tactic on xbox because the merc can't snipe you as fast on EMF.
But he's in MT...
QuoteAs a side note, while Spekkio, and possibly the rest of you, do not believe that full stealth should be viable, the majority of people in this poll (taken on this forum) disagreed with you:
Sometimes I think you just like to read your own writing...
I voted for the third option in that poll. Yes, I believe that the game should offer flexibility in the way that spies choose to play the game.
We already have this in CT on the balanced maps. Nevertheless, there still needs to be interaction between the two sides or else the game will be very, very boring.
You're basically saying over and over again that
you have a problem getting past MT, so we need to nerf it to oblivion to make stealth easier.
Look, I used to think the same thing...then one day a long while ago, I came to the realization that Ubi isn't going to patch the game anymore, and even if they did they weren't going to listen to the community. It was right about the time when Weezer told me I was bitching too much, and he was right. So instead of focusing on how overpowered MT is, I accepted it as part of the game and worked on trying to get around it. I highly suggest you do the same, you might be surprised.
MT is for detecting MOTION, and that's what it should keep doing. Like it's been said 100x in this thread by everyone except you, the only problem with MT is when it helps you see spies that aren't moving. Considering the game is moving to a new engine, I'm sure Kebab et al will find a way to fix that.
If Ubi patched CT by doing the following:
-forcing normal post render for MT
-lowering the sensitivity a bit so that slow creeping doesn't set off the box sometimes, esp. when moving on a slant
-adding the background static noise that was present in PT, perhaps a little louder so you don't get the benefits of EAX while in the vision
MT would be perfectly fine. You gain sight awareness at a sacrifice of sound awareness, and the normal post render means you can't see shit in the shadows anywhere nearly as easily. That's it...that's all it needs. None of this other crazy stuff you are proposing.
QuoteOr to ask it another way... Is MT whoring required to be in the game to beat stealth spies?
I don't
need any one feature the merc has in an isolated vacuum. Individually, MT is just a tool like any other gadget and ability. It's the synergistic effect of them all that allows me to hunt down spies efficiently, and your proposals about MT would be a huge detriment not only to hunting stealth spies, but to aggro spies as well.
Quote from: Spekkio on June 02, 2007, 09:53:20 PM
QuoteIt's actually probably a *Better* tactic on xbox because the merc can't snipe you as fast on EMF.
But he's in MT...
You realize how fast it is to switch to MT to EMF, right?
Here's how it works to MT whore. If you see a sound on your SD and you don't hear an MT box, you instantly turn on EMF, as it's likely someone has drawn out his gun on you. It's really that simple.
Also, answer my question in the previous post.
Do you think that MT is required to stop stealth spies?
QuoteHere's how it works to MT whore. If you see a sound on your SD and you don't hear an MT box, you instantly turn on EMF, as it's likely someone has drawn out his gun on you. It's really that simple.
In that time you should be able to shock the merc quite easily.
haha that's exactly what i wanted to say. the best counter to mt is not moving and hiding with camo/in the shadows/in long range. i can only speak for myself, but i got fooled quite alot when i used to mt whore. isn't i proof enough that most good merc players don't mt whore?
btw you complain alot about aggro, but u have to accept that aggro most times works only out of stealth situations, so that you aren't prepared for it and your teammate needs some time to help you out.
the funny thing about scct is, that i think it became such good just because of coincidence. the developers had/have no idea how the gameplay works in higher levels of experience. but they also didn't do one thing: listen to the newbis complaining about everything appearing to them as 'lame'. we should get the best stealth team and ask them what they encounter the most annoying thing, and do the same for the aggro part. spekkio is quite competent in the stealth sector...
if stealth gets too easy you won't get the omgwtf feeling anymore and the games will get quite boring.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 02, 2007, 10:04:22 PM
Do you think that MT is required to stop stealth spies?
Yes, I would usually turn MT on if a spy has shot a few snares around my patrol, hoping that it'll cover up his fast movements. I would usually turn on MT in areas, where spies can roll from cover to cover. I usually turn MT on near pipes, that lead to vents/ceilings.
MT MT MT thats all there is and MT whoring lol.. NO i have only gotten hit by a hs a couple times with "mt". I think its not as bad as you people are making it sound. Maybe you guys are unlucky players and get hit with it a lot. It does not bother me but it does need some tweaks as for everything else in CT.
Quote from: Gawain on June 03, 2007, 12:08:47 AM
haha that's exactly what i wanted to say. the best counter to mt is not moving and hiding with camo/in the shadows/in long range. i can only speak for myself, but i got fooled quite alot when i used to mt whore. isn't i proof enough that most good merc players don't mt whore?
Not from my experience. If you flick on standard vision or EMF once in a while but keep on MT 90% of the time, you're still an MT whore, and that's exactly what I've experienced good players do, that applies to PC and xbox.
As far as countering it by not moving, that's rather counterproductive. Keep in mind that you've got to move to get objectives and in some cases, there's no guarantee the merc is going to leave. If you could sneak while his back is turned that would remedy the situation some IMO.
Quote
spekkio is quite competent in the stealth sector...
if stealth gets too easy you won't get the omgwtf feeling anymore and the games will get quite boring.
Well Spekkio has voiced his opinion in many cases that he dislikes the design of many maps. Instead of seeing it as a problem with MT, he thinks that open rooms where spies have to hide in shadows and go from cover to cover, shouldn't exist.
And while that might work, I'm worried it could bring about Double Agent syndrome where we have too many spy routes, given the main counter to MT is to be behind total cover and not be seen at all. From a map design point of view, that's not very interesting because it removes the possibility for interaction. You can easily just use heartbeat to stay out of the merc's way.
Also, I'd like you and Spekkio to answer my previous question about if you think MT is required to stop stealth spies. It'll give me an idea of what page you guys are on, because before the concern wtih nerfing MT was that it would help aggro spies too much, now it seems that you're more concerned with stealth spies dominating the game if MT were nerfed.
QuoteAlso, I'd like you and Spekkio to answer my previous question about if you think MT is required to stop stealth spies.
You don't like to read very much, do you? Check the last page, I answered your question.
QuoteAnd while that might work, I'm worried it could bring about Double Agent syndrome where we have too many spy routes, given the main counter to MT is to be behind total cover and not be seen at all. From a map design point of view, that's not very interesting because it removes the possibility for interaction. You can easily just use heartbeat to stay out of the merc's way.
Yea, but the only maps where MT whoring is a real bane are Warehouse Sect 1 & 3, Bank sect 1, Museum cafe (although EMFing the ceiling is harder to get around than an MT whore in this area), Mall lobby, Station sect 2, and Deftech outer courtyard. These specific areas create bottlenecks that are very tough to pass because you HAVE to go through them to access the rest of the map. On the other maps, it's very possible to get around it either because there is adequate cover or enough objectives/routes where you don't even need to cross the open, and I don't think any of the CT maps suffer from "DA syndrome." That's not to say that all the other maps are balanced, or that the above ones aren't, it's just that MT whoring doesn't matter on them.
As far as sneaking behind mercs, you already can. The problem is that in the real world mercs tend to look around, so like I said your suggestions are pointless.
Quote from: Spekkio on June 03, 2007, 11:34:56 PM
QuoteAlso, I'd like you and Spekkio to answer my previous question about if you think MT is required to stop stealth spies.
You don't like to read very much, do you? Check the last page, I answered your question.
Odd, that wasn't there when I checked originally, did you add that in an edit?
Also, you said that my change would make MT weaker against aggro spies. I'm curious why. Aggro spies don't tend to walk around crouched, so I don't see how it would have much impact.
QuoteI don't think any of the CT maps suffer from "DA syndrome." That's not to say that all the other maps are balanced, or that the above ones aren't, it's just that MT whoring doesn't matter on them.
You're right, most maps aviod DA syndrome by being so small that they force aggro, like aquarius. But these tend to get the classification as poorly designed maps too.
If aqua were bigger or had more spread out objectives, it'd be very much a DA syndrome map. I mean, I can use heartbeat and avoid mercs easily on that map, it's just you have to confront the mercs because the map is so small and the mercs can camp.
Quote
As far as sneaking behind mercs, you already can. The problem is that in the real world mercs tend to look around, so like I said your suggestions are pointless.
Please, make up your mind, would my suggestion do nothing or would it unbalance the game? It can't be both pointless and game breaking at the same time. That makes absolutely no sense.
QuoteIf aqua were bigger or had more spread out objectives, it'd be very much a DA syndrome map. I mean, I can use heartbeat and avoid mercs easily on that map, it's just you have to confront the mercs because the map is so small and the mercs can camp.
No, there are two problems with Aqua:
1) REQUIRING coop to access objectives to win the game. Without coop you have a choice of going to greek or pirates...with two mercs, you can see the issue there. If you kill one spy off you know that unless the other one escapes back to spawn, you don't have to guard tech room. I don't think any map should require coop to win...Club and Factory are examples of maps with good coop options; Aqua and Station are examples of maps with bad coop options.
2) The map is too assymetrical. Other than greek, the mercs can both stay in the pirate/tech area and guard the entire map -- well, at least anything that's important. Which is why getting greek first is a terrible thing to do, despite the benefit of opening all the doorways.
well i hack greek first and then me and my mate play an aggro game and we win. even though tank would be the best thing to get first. me and my mate rarely get it
Yea, that works really well ::)... and when it doesn't, crying about it is even better.
hacking greek first isnt the best but it catches the merc off guard and you can cam him or fight him and then hack. i am not saying this is the best idea but it shows what a mercmap aqua is. in order to get an obj you must fight at one point or another and by getting tank first you can then go tech, pir, and greek so its the best thing to get first.
Quote from: Spekkio on June 04, 2007, 12:17:27 AM
QuoteIf aqua were bigger or had more spread out objectives, it'd be very much a DA syndrome map. I mean, I can use heartbeat and avoid mercs easily on that map, it's just you have to confront the mercs because the map is so small and the mercs can camp.
No, there are two problems with Aqua:
1) REQUIRING coop to access objectives to win the game. Without coop you have a choice of going to greek or pirates...with two mercs, you can see the issue there. If you kill one spy off you know that unless the other one escapes back to spawn, you don't have to guard tech room. I don't think any map should require coop to win...Club and Factory are examples of maps with good coop options; Aqua and Station are examples of maps with bad coop options.
2) The map is too assymetrical. Other than greek, the mercs can both stay in the pirate/tech area and guard the entire map -- well, at least anything that's important. Which is why getting greek first is a terrible thing to do, despite the benefit of opening all the doorways.
Oh, I agree. Which is why I said "if aqua were bigger or the objectives were spread out more". As is, Aqua is a plain old merc map. It's probably one of the most merc advantageous maps in the game. This has almost nothing to do with MT either, which is why I use it as an example. It's style makes MT very weak.
The only reason aqua is a merc map is because the mercs just don't have to patrol. They can pretty much stay in a couple designated locations with minimal movement and win.
But lets imagine for a bit if it were changed around some. It's rather amazing how quickly the advantage can shift.
Lets say that we put a bombing objective in the office in a back room.
Now, aqua is going to actually become a strong spy map, because of the heartbeat. If the mercs are forced to patrol aqua, it's nearly impossible for them to do much, because it's rather easy for you to just use heartbeat to strike at a location the merc isn't present in.
In a map without open spaces, heartbeat is king.
I mean, just look at orphanage. spies have to get 1 objective out of 3, then 1 objective out of 3 and then a disc. And yet this map is seen as a spy map. The toughest part in orphanage is not surprisingly the top area with the discs, where MT works well.
That's what would happen to aqua if you forced the mercs to patrol.
if aqua were spread out then it would be a normal map and u guys would say MT whoring in that map too. I dont think i even use MT in that map unless in tech sometimes. also i dont use mt a lot lol.. i get hs without it even if it helps
whenever i use mt on aqua it's only a counter to flashbangs and going-for-neck aggro.
QuoteNow, aqua is going to actually become a strong spy map, because of the heartbeat. If the mercs are forced to patrol aqua, it's nearly impossible for them to do much, because it's rather easy for you to just use heartbeat to strike at a location the merc isn't present in.
In a map without open spaces, heartbeat is king.
What's your point? If you're trying to convince us of the need to nerf MT, which is a merc ability, because spies have it too easy due to HB sensor, you're not making a very good case.
QuoteI mean, just look at orphanage. spies have to get 1 objective out of 3, then 1 objective out of 3 and then a disc. And yet this map is seen as a spy map.
Well, if there are two mercs and 3 objectives always accessible, that does create a problem in coverage, doesn't it?
QuoteThe toughest part in orphanage is not surprisingly the top area with the discs, where MT works well.
LoL...MT doesn't work well in the attic because of the sheets sectioning it off. It also doesn't invert any of the shadows near the ammo box.
to me MT is good and maybe it might need some tweaks but i think its good for now. idk when its so powerful maybe because i dont use it often
Quote from: Spekkio on June 05, 2007, 12:12:22 AM
Well, if there are two mercs and 3 objectives always accessible, that does create a problem in coverage, doesn't it?
Yep, but I mean compared to something like clubhouse or factory, where you've got 6 objectives and 2 mercs, it's a pretty big difference.
1 out of 3 twice should be pretty tough, but due to the nature of the map, it's really not. That's my only real point here.
I'm just saying that when you have maps that feature lots of small rooms and spyroutes, like orphanage, they're much easier than large room maps, like river mall. So I'm not certain why we have to nerf large room maps further by having uber MT. If people can get by without needing MT much on orphanage, they can probably get by without having it on River mall. People still play Orphanage even though you can't win purely by MT whoring as you can on some maps and game balance doesn't fall apart, so I'm really inclined to think that we can nerf the anti-stealth aspects of MT pretty heavily and still have a balanced game.
The only place I think the game gets hurt is if we nerf MT against aggro.
ok, just made some screenshots for a comparision between normal and high post render and the shadow inversion fix on the ump maps. i want mt to look like it does with normal post render and zed's fix (+slow climb + fixed slope bug), but with higher sensivity in the los (eg lower detection timer).
Why even have slow climb? Why not just make regular climbing not set it off. I mean, it's not like spies climb all that fast anyway.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 20, 2007, 07:23:59 PM
Why even have slow climb? Why not just make regular climbing not set it off. I mean, it's not like spies climb all that fast anyway.
don't think so.
i think if one is in slow mode (and not jumping down a high object or rolling), he shouldn't set off mt detection. everything else should be detected, so that it's a coherent concept.
no comments on my screenshots? (am i the last one comparing this ingame?XD)
Quote from: Gawain on June 20, 2007, 07:44:24 PM
no comments on my screenshots? (am i the last one comparing this ingame?XD)
I think the MT fix might help quite a bit on some maps. Though a lot of the maps, CT maps especially just aren't dark enough for it to matter much.
i think dark maps are superior. imo a combination of the effect normal post render and zeds shadow fix do is the way to go, but with zero detection timer in the mercs los. this would result in careless/aggro spies getting detected better, and sneaky spies much harder. one would have to use flashlight again ;)
btw, what about emf ghosting? is it something we only want in very close ranges, and in combination with the zoomed sniper rifle, or something like now that some people with ultra high resolution and a good monitor can abuse?
Personally I really dislike EMF ghosting. EMF isn't meant for seeing spies who dont have vision/gun out, IMO.
imo it should only work in a 2 meter range and in zoom.
Quote from: frvge on June 21, 2007, 02:32:55 PM
Personally I really dislike EMF ghosting. EMF isn't meant for seeing spies who dont have vision/gun out, IMO.
agreed. EMF ghosting is a bug and should be treated as such.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 21, 2007, 07:39:21 PM
Quote from: frvge on June 21, 2007, 02:32:55 PM
Personally I really dislike EMF ghosting. EMF isn't meant for seeing spies who dont have vision/gun out, IMO.
agreed. EMF ghosting is a bug and should be treated as such.
I approve of this
removing emf ghosting totally will make ceilings a way too good spot for camping, it'll change the gameplay on museum quite a bit. some good players like nxr jason play with more than 50% emf btw
Quote from: Gawain on June 21, 2007, 11:26:59 PM
removing emf ghosting totally will make ceilings a way too good spot for camping, it'll change the gameplay on museum quite a bit. some good players like nxr jason play with more than 50% emf btw
Yeah, but he must have some uber-pr0-super-overclocked screens to see the ghosts...
Quote from: Gawain on June 21, 2007, 11:26:59 PM
removing emf ghosting totally will make ceilings a way too good spot for camping, it'll change the gameplay on museum quite a bit. some good players like nxr jason play with more than 50% emf btw
That may be true, but why do we even care. If a spy is sitting up in the ceiling without his gun drawn, what harm is he really?
too many spy-only zones like vents are bad for the gameplay.
Quote from: Gawain on June 22, 2007, 04:01:26 PM
too many spy-only zones like vents are bad for the gameplay.
While I agree with that, generally there are more ways of seeing through ceilings. Museum has holes in the cieling where you can frag, you can see with EMF if the spy turns on vision or draws his gun. And you can shine your flashlight to see various areas anyway. I mean if you're careful you can watch the ceiling vent from cafe to corridor.
If all else fails, you can always take random shots.
I just would like most of the uneven graphics problems to be fixed. It's crazy when you've got some fool who EMF ghosts you cause he has tweaked hardware and has way better vision than you do.
Quote from: Kok4f4n on June 21, 2007, 07:44:15 PM
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 21, 2007, 07:39:21 PM
Quote from: frvge on June 21, 2007, 02:32:55 PM
Personally I really dislike EMF ghosting. EMF isn't meant for seeing spies who dont have vision/gun out, IMO.
agreed. EMF ghosting is a bug and should be treated as such.
I approve of this
It's definitely not a bug. You are entitled to not like it, but to call it a bug is an extreme stretch. Also, someone should let you in on the secret that one's ability to EMF ghost has nothing to do with the graphics settings.
K, now that i thougt of it second time...
Spekkio is right - the human body has a elecromagnetic (or something) field of its own, so it sould be visible - maybe even more than it is now, really...
MT's purpose: see moving objects
EMF's purpose: see objects with electromagnetic fields.
While I dont know the exact amount of EMF a human body generates, I haven't seen any other object in the game that makes that doesnt use electricity and still is barely visible.
My point is that in a room made out of wood, you wouldnt be able to navigate with EMF.
Quote from: frvge on June 22, 2007, 09:04:17 PM
MT's purpose: see moving objects
EMF's purpose: see objects with electromagnetic fields.
While I dont know the exact amount of EMF a human body generates, I haven't seen any other object in the game that makes that doesnt use electricity and still is barely visible.
My point is that in a room made out of wood, you wouldnt be able to navigate with EMF.
lol you seem to know nothing about physics XD
the whole emf thingy is total bullshit
I know that EMF in the form in PT and CT isnt possible...
Honestly, I don't really care much about physics or realism in general for this game. I mean, lets face it, the game itself doesn't make much sense... you've got spies with no lethal weaponry, who apparently aren't supposed to kill, yet they're allowed to snap necks.
Quote from: InvisibleMan999 on June 23, 2007, 05:06:00 PM
Honestly, I don't really care much about physics or realism in general for this game. I mean, lets face it, the game itself doesn't make much sense... you've got spies with no lethal weaponry, who apparently aren't supposed to kill, yet they're allowed to snap necks.
Yea, that's odd, but still, the spies shouldn't be allowed to carry lethal weaponss for gameplay reasons
make the MT system like the kind that is used in double agent where youd have to move really slowly for it to have a good range and if u move too quickly the range is hella demoted. and make it have a battery so they dont keep it on foreva
NO! the mt will be the one from PT, just with fixed shadow inversion.
Um, for all you wondering the human body should actually be able to be seen quite easily using EMF, equipment like EM Sensors are used to detect people underneath rubble in collapses and such. However it shouldn't be in the game. Its another one of those Gameplay > Realism.
Just say the spies suit makes them undetectable :P
Quote from: Tidenburg on June 28, 2007, 10:42:01 AM
Um, for all you wondering the human body should actually be able to be seen quite easily using EMF, equipment like EM Sensors are used to detect people underneath rubble in collapses and such. However it shouldn't be in the game. Its another one of those Gameplay > Realism.
afaik thats wrong
Quote from: Gawain on June 28, 2007, 11:21:27 AM
Quote from: Tidenburg on June 28, 2007, 10:42:01 AM
Um, for all you wondering the human body should actually be able to be seen quite easily using EMF, equipment like EM Sensors are used to detect people underneath rubble in collapses and such. However it shouldn't be in the game. Its another one of those Gameplay > Realism.
afaik thats wrong
afaik it is possible, but not really easy - it needs quite powerful hardware to be done
Actually there is a certain amount of electromagnetism everywhere. If objects didn't have electromagnetism then we would simply all fall through the planet, this means that when there are different amounts of the energy then the contrast should be visible in EMF vision, say for example, that a spy is in between a machine and a merc. The spy has a lower EM field than the machine so there should be a dark shadow where the soy is standing. Does that make sense to you?
Quote from: Kok4f4n on June 28, 2007, 11:28:36 AM
afaik it is possible, but not really easy - it needs quite powerful hardware to be done
Exactly, while Tidenburg may be right. How sensitive can a portable EMF scanner in a helmet really be? Answer: Anything we want.
I'd like to see the EMF to be Black and white, not blue and white - it would make better constrast ;D
Exactly what I was saying overstatement, we CAN make it realistic but we choose not to because we value the game play more than the realism. This is something many people who come onto these boards (people who usually get violent and then banned ;) ) do not get.